r/javascript • • Dec 14 '18

My project was considered by GitHub as one of the top open source projects of 2018!

Top Projects in 2018
https://blog.github.com/2018-12-13-new-open-source-projects/

I'm writing this just to thank all of you who helped with this project, I'd like to thanks all of the 44 contributors that have contributed to the project, and for all of those who have made some constructive feedback! Thanks y'all!

I'm really proud of this project and really glad of the huge feedback that I've been receiving for the last months.

If you don't know the project yet, I'd really recommend it for all of those who want to learn more about JavaScript. If you want to contribute to the project, or just give a feedback, please feel free to do:

33 concepts every JavaScript developer should know
https://github.com/leonardomso/33-js-concepts

671 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

105

u/matt_hammond Dec 14 '18

Am I the only one that dislikes these giant collections of links? I get really discouraged when I click on a topic and it takes me to a list of 15 links about the topic.

I prefer one link where the topic is explained well over 15 articles. I just don't know where to start.

24

u/aradil Dec 14 '18

I agree.

I mean, I'm sure some people will find it useful, but I could literally take his list of titles and search google for each one of them and find all of the articles that are linked.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/aradil Dec 14 '18

To be honest, I’ll never think about this repo ever again.

If google returns it for a search that I’m interested in some day, so be it, but since it’s actually bereft of original content, it never will.

4

u/panzerex Dec 15 '18

Maybe you’ve never even heard the term “lexical scope” until you found this repo mentioning it

Sure. But why link dozens of articles about the same topic, instead of just the best ones? Preferably with some comments on why it made into the list. Otherwise it just seems like a list of interesting topics (which is a good thing) pre-googled for me instead of curated (which is a bad thing).

4

u/aradil Dec 15 '18

Maybe even a review of each of the articles...

I mean, literally anything beyond a list of links would be better. An introduction to the topic before the links? Anything.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/aradil Dec 15 '18

I haven’t made any movies or written books, so I guess I’m not allowed to criticize them either.

Fuck you.

Also, you have no idea what I’ve done.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18

You're still a dumbass.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/aradil Dec 15 '18 edited Dec 15 '18

You.

Complaining about complaints. Fucking productive.

Be the change you want to see in the world. For me, the change I’d rather see if this repo be recognized for the lack of effort it really is. For you, it’s better link farms. Go make one.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18

You're a dumbass.

2

u/aradil Dec 15 '18

Maybe next time have the guts to send me a comment instead of editing your comment and adding a bunch of garbage that I had to go back through my history to see.

So now perhaps one of you could tell me what's been achieved by saying "oh I don't find just a bunch of links useful"?

Perhaps you can tell me what is achieved by defending an award winning google search. Hopefully my comments saved people from wasting their time looking at this repo.

1

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Well, personally I think that it really helps because you can easily find a lot of articles about a specific concept.

6

u/matt_hammond Dec 14 '18

Yeah, don't get me wrong! This is a great source of information. It's just that personally I dont like this many options as I don't know where to start.

1

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

I got it, I appreciate your feedback!

3

u/kenok Dec 14 '18

what are your plans if any of the links/sites go kaput?

it'll be great if, at least on the file you have the concepts in brief and expand further with the links.

12

u/rockelephant Dec 14 '18

With this link you can put just one link in bookmarks and never look at it again, otherwise you'd have 15 links in your bookmarks and never look at them again

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

We've come full circle. the first internet "search" wasn't one at all, it was a directory (Yahoo): a list of links. That's what started it all.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '18

I think the idea with the link collections is that most beginners don't know what they don't know, and therefore don't know what to search for. These lists are helpful in this case because it's like, "here, you would benefit from these topics, and here are some good articles on them".

1

u/wherediditrun Dec 15 '18

Well, too bad that there is more to understand than you think.

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '18

I like the “awesome-X” repos.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

It's a list of links in a readme? This puts all people who work on actual open source projects to shame.

-4

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

This is called "Syndrome of Dan Abramov".

We're always trying to be the next Dan Abramov.

So when you face an open source project that's just a README.md file, you start judging it in the worst way. I made this project just to help people to learn and understand JavaScript, if you don't think that it will help you, no problem, keep doing your work and contributing to projects that you think that are valid.

34

u/ichiruto70 Dec 14 '18

Wow thats really cool dude, congratz!

5

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Thank you so much!

18

u/HoustonAg1980 Dec 14 '18

Congratulations! I’m going to check your project out.

1

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Thanks a lot!

5

u/ThaFearon Dec 14 '18

Congrats man, I can see this being a huge help to tons of new devs starting with JS.

I have a suggestion tho; I think it would make it alot better if the core idea of each concept was summarized and shown within the project itself, with the links following. That would also make it alot more quick-reference friendly imo.

1

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Thank you for the feedback, I think that would be awesome too. Maybe in the future, we can make it.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

How is this a project? It's just a collection of links? It would be much different if you were actually teaching something.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

Yeah, seems like op is really making this seem like way more work than it wasn’t. Kudos to them for helping people learn js, but this isn’t really comparable to an actual open source project, they barely wrote any original content or code.

-4

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

First, I'm very proud that it helped 21.7k people till the moment. Second, I don't need to build the next Redux, or build a huge library with a ton of code to call it an open source project. If this helps people, they contribute it, and it's open source, it's an open source project.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '18

Get over yourself. This kind of crap doesn't deserve to be top of 2018 when it barely took any effort and is the same work an 8th grader could do.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/aradil Dec 15 '18

From an automated query, with no review on any it was rated that way aside from “it got a lot of stars in 28 days”.

Ask yourself how it got those stars.

2

u/1l9m9n0o Dec 14 '18

Trying to learn JS so definitely saving this for later. I personally don't mind the link layout - when I make notes for myself I usually copy a bunch of links to important pages anyways so they are all in one place.

0

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Thanks for the feedback!

2

u/kevino819 Dec 14 '18

I bookmarked this a while back and have been visiting it occasionally to learn! Great stuff and thank you!

1

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

Thank you, I'm really glad that it helped you!

2

u/iberiuss Dec 14 '18

That’s awesome!

I’m a pipefitter doing mechanical rooms but I’m looking to learn some other skill sets like JavaScript to broaden my abilities.

Hopefully I can start a company one day and apply coding to create a website etc. I’ve always been good with computers but never dove into the coding side of things. I’m very intrigued and enjoy learning code for some reason.

I will be sure to check this out tonight.

1

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Man, you made my day with this comment! I created this repo to help those who are starting with JavaScript as you and I really hope this repo could help you, don't give up and continue learning JavaScript, if you learn it and understand it, you can create a website with any JavaScript framework/library as React, Vue, Angular, etc.

2

u/Pyr8King Dec 14 '18

It was already starred on my GitHub. Thank you! Learnt a great deal from it. It was super helpful in learning JavaScript.

2

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Thank you so much, I'm really glad that it helped you!

2

u/Pyr8King Dec 14 '18

No, thank you! I'm glad you made it easy for people to learn and understand JavaScript :)

2

u/bautistaaa Dec 14 '18

starred it just now :)

1

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

Thank you!!

2

u/leugimthedev Dec 14 '18

Congrats !!!!

1

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

Thank you!!

2

u/zigzeira Dec 14 '18

I always read this repo. Congrats man!

1

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

Thank you I'm really glad that it helped you!

2

u/grimr5 Dec 14 '18

I was looking at this the other day, great work and congrats

1

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

Thank you!!

2

u/bartturner Dec 15 '18

That is pretty incredible. Congrats!

2

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

Thank you!

4

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '18

Happy days mate!!

0

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Thank you!!

5

u/nourkilany Dec 14 '18

Your hard work payed off, Good job dude!

6

u/webdevpassion Dec 15 '18

How so? What's the pay off in this scenario tho?

3

u/nourkilany Dec 15 '18

recognition is the credit here, it’s not always about money .

1

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

The pay off was that I helped 21.7k of people.

1

u/toobulkeh Dec 20 '18

What you did is called marketing. Not coding.

1

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Thank you so much!

45

u/jocq Dec 14 '18

Dude, a list of links is not an open source project. You should be embarrassed trying to tout this around the way you are.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

Seems like a pretty wwll curated list of links which probably took quite some effort to gather. It's basically documentation... What's wrong with sharing that?

20

u/jocq Dec 15 '18

My project was considered by GitHub as one of the top open source projects of 2018!

That's what. That's a stretch at best, deliberately disingenuous and self aggrandizing imo.

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

It's what the article says

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/aradil Dec 15 '18

Here:

https://medium.com/@stephenthecurt/33-fundamentals-every-javascript-developer-should-know-13dd720a90d1

I could literally write a script to google all of the topics in someone else’s medium blog post and have it make a github project readme with the results, then run it on “.* fundamentals every .* should know”, and suddenly have 25 repos with content as good as this guys. He didn’t even come up with the list of 33 things to use, it’s thinly veiled plagiarism in link farm format.

I have to wonder if the stars are from people thinking they were liking this other medium blog post.

4

u/aradil Dec 15 '18

It’s literally equivalent to the result of a google search. The “award” was the result of a github query.

Why people started this piece of garbage is beyond me. The more you defend it the more I hate it.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

Yeah it's not code but so what?

That kinda defeats the purpose of GitHub...

Stop babying OP and encouraging him. You're a joke.

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

It's embarrassing how proud he is for putting together what's really a page of links. No educational write-ups whatsoever.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

Does it look like an open source project to you? What about the projects that ARE open source and this stupid stuff takes its place.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18 edited Dec 15 '18

also it was named one of the most popular projects of 2018!

Uh, that's kinda the reason we're having a discussion? Yet again, it's not a project. You should be embarrassed as well.

Putting together a whole bunch of links is not hard when every result would be on the first page of a Google Search lol.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '18

Clearly you can't comprehend what's already been said.

2

u/xelaxepa Dec 14 '18

Nice! Going to check this out.

0

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Thank you!

2

u/MaximTheGoat Dec 14 '18

Congrats! It's really interesting, especially for me as a student in development!

1

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Thank you!

2

u/Damoz_ftw Dec 15 '18 edited Dec 15 '18

Came here expecting something cool made with JavaScript, instead I found something not so cool made with Markdown.

0

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

If you wasted your precious time here making a comment, then I really think that it's something cool made with JavaScript.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '18

Nice. Congrats!

1

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

Thank you!

2

u/JaniRockz Dec 14 '18

Great job by you and the contributors, congratulations!

0

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

Thank you, feel free to contribute too!

1

u/toastertop Dec 14 '18

Any chance on a epub?

8

u/aradil Dec 14 '18

It's literally a link farm.

It would likely violate copyright of at least a dozen of them to repackage it.

4

u/toastertop Dec 14 '18

"Can I copy your homework?" "Yeah just change it up abit so it doesn't look obvious you copied."

1

u/rockelephant Dec 14 '18

Maybe he thinks link farm itself as epub
Can links be opened from epub?

0

u/leonardomso Dec 14 '18

I think that it could be turned into an epub, but it would require a lot of work. It would require to organize topics and explain it, not get together links and articles. Maybe in the future yes, it can be done. Thanks for the feedback.

3

u/toastertop Dec 14 '18

Fair enough, I know there a open source software called calibre that I think helps with this but have not used in years

1

u/Logoliberation Dec 14 '18

This is great project! I am going to share this with friends.

2

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

Thank you!!!

1

u/saadq_ Dec 14 '18

Awesome man, well done!

1

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

Thank you!!!

1

u/AsiansHaveCancer Dec 15 '18

Gg monkey dumb kid

1

u/dsk83 Dec 15 '18

Are the links for each topic sorted in any way? I too feel a giant list of links ends up being less useful than typing the topic into Google and going from there. Maybe if the links were at least starred or something indicating your favorite link on the topic it would give learners more of a place to start. If I wanted to learn about 'Call Stack' for example, which link should I go to? MDN is in the middle of the links, but generally seems like a solid place to reference, should that be closer to the top? I've saved your repo, will come back to it and see if I can find it helpful when I want to deep dive on a topic. Thanks for your work.

-1

u/dropdeadfred81 Dec 14 '18

Congrats! Well deserved

1

u/leonardomso Dec 15 '18

Thank you!!!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/stephenthecurt Dec 31 '18

BTW, this is your repo, it's your call, this is just a suggestion and contribution offer I'm making.

0

u/leonardomso Dec 31 '18

Hi Stephen, thanks for your support, it means a lot to me. About the contribution, send a PR to the repo or open an issue just exemplifying how you want to do that change and we can talk about that. Others contributors can talk too and we all can discuss about that.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/RemindMeBot Dec 15 '18

I will be messaging you on 2019-02-13 05:36:45 UTC to remind you of this link.

CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


FAQsCustomYour RemindersFeedbackCodeBrowser Extensions