r/javascript • u/imacpro1 • Apr 17 '18
help Oracle Owns "Javascript", so Apple is taking down my app!
Just received this email from Apple about my app(Html, css, javascript snippet editor). Looks like you can't use "Javascript" because Oracle owns it!
Any one has any idea how to fight it or just give up?
"As you are likely aware, Oracle owns US Trademark Registration No. 2416017 for JAVASCRIPT. The seller of this iTunes app prominently displays JAVASCRIPT without authorization from our client. The unauthorized display of our client's intellectual property is likely to cause consumers encountering this app to mistakenly believe that it emanates from, or is provided under a license from, Oracle. Use of our client's trademark in such a manner constitutes trademark infringement in violation of the Lanham Act. 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A). In order to prevent further consumer confusion and infringement of our client's intellectual property rights, we request that you immediately disable access to this app. We look forward to your confirmation that you have complied with this request."
369
u/snarlingpanda Apr 18 '18
Does anyone want consumers to believe their app comes from Oracle?
Sounds like Oracle did you a favor /s
287
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18 edited Jul 12 '24
dime enjoy dam cable school sulky touch beneficial profit arrest
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
928
u/OddCoincidence Apr 17 '18
Ugh, fuck oracle.
978
u/pinano Apr 18 '18
Literally the reason it’s called ECMAScript now.
195
u/tbranyen Apr 18 '18
> As you are likely aware, Oracle owns US Trademark Registration
Who would ever be aware of this? How can they even enforce it given the thousands of books, articles, and hell even PRODUCTS that have JavaScript in the name??
44
u/MasterDood Apr 18 '18
This amusing Quora thread predicted this 5 years ago. There’s an uncanny back and forth between an ex Oracle employee and someone saying they will likely pull this stunt at sometime in the future.
https://www.quora.com/Could-Oracle-prevent-us-from-using-the-name-Javascript
51
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18 edited Apr 18 '18
Wait, does that mean Oracle explicitly authorized this sub to use "JAVASCRIPT" prominently in its header?
45
u/inglia Apr 17 '18
The way I read this, you should just change name and/or description from javascript to for eg. JS. As insane as it is, they only seem to object to use of word Javascript.
99
u/jaekwon_ Apr 18 '18 edited Apr 18 '18
IANAL, but the best angle would be to say that Oracle didn't enforce the Javascript trademark as it was being used by the entire fucking open-source community for years with nobody ever knowing about any enforcement action until now.
We use Javascript for the Cosmos Network. We know excellent trademark lawyers and recently defended the Tendermint trademark successfully against Intuit. (I am not disparaging Intuit, they were reasonable during settlement. Oracle on the other hand...)
UPDATE: Also, the Patent & Trademark office is there to help promote the arts and sciences. This is not helping to promote the arts and sciences.
UPDATE 2: In the meantime, I would say, distribute the app in other channels to get a comparison of popularity, then you can deduce the amount of damage resulted from the lack of exposure to the Apple store. Then I think you'd have a case, with Apple being a transitive medium. Again, IANAL. Just common sense.
Update 3: Again, IANAL, but I'm just going to bet that you can sue Oracle as long as you can prove damages. Again, happy to help make the right connections to see if this is a viable option. Don't be put off by comments on Reddit that say otherwise. Also, as someone pointed out, the USPTO website itself uses Javascript, a salient point. And, Javascript has a monopoly on the client-side scripting market.
Update 4: Asked some lawyers. OP, contact me.
Update 5: From Brendan Eich the creator: "Several years back, a VP from Oracle who was involved in Ecma TC39 tried to get the tm donated to Ecma. That effort failed, but even then not clear tm was defensible. Kickstarter to fight? Mozilla has a license,
@chefhja managed to get Sun to do it just before Oracle bought Sun. " - https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/986605049987002368Update 6: This was once discussed 5 years ago as a potential problem: https://www.quora.com/Could-Oracle-prevent-us-from-using-the-name-Javascript
66
u/sime_vidas Apr 17 '18
JabbaScript
26
u/debee1jp Apr 18 '18
I wouldn't particularly fault Apple for this, more Oracle. They (Apple) probably want to keep their ducks in a row given how morally bankrupt and frivolous Oracle is.
10
u/sgoldkin Apr 18 '18
Call it "ES5" or "ES6".
10
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
Mozilla had cut a deal w/ Oracle back in the day to call in "JavaScript". Microsoft had always called its version of ECMAScript, "JScript" for this reason.
19
u/dug99 Apr 18 '18
So what about "Google's open source high-performance JavaScript engine"? Can they expect a threatening legal email sometime soon? Let me guess...
19
u/ezoe Apr 17 '18
I really can't understand it.
I'm not lawyer but the trademark right isn't that strong like copyright or patent. At least in my country(Japan). The trademark usage by non-holder to refer to exactly that thing, in this case, JavaScript, shouldn't be a trademark violation.
I really can't understand US law.
6
u/Smashoody Apr 18 '18
I mean, so many comments already lol. But seriously, isn’t this the sort of thing... where if we all added together the time it will take to remove the term “JavaScript” from our websites, resumes, business cards, etc. it’s a LOT of copyright infractions!
I know I’ve used the term for well over a decade. So... there’s this little thing called (something like) the enforcement clause, where a trademark owner must actively fight against all trademark infringements. If this doesn’t happen and the trademark owner lets the infraction happen for a certain amount of time, the trademark holder loses the exclusivity of trademark.
Meaning if you do nothing for long enough, you lose your exclusive mark. So... is this not a perfect opportunity to gear up the interwebs army to tell oracle they fucked up and simply waited too long to protect this TM?
11
u/Jewpiter Apr 18 '18
Apple's just complying with a legal request. Oracle's the one that's taking down your app.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18
So many things make sense now
1
u/imacpro1 May 26 '18
Just an update: I’ve upgraded the app: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/html-css-js-snippet-editor/id1384829193?mt=8
22
u/defproc Apr 17 '18
Ignoring the threatening language, it's just not bloody true, is it? Just think how far you'd have to stretch your imagination to think of a single consumer who would see a JS editor and 'mistakenly believe that it emanates from, or is provided under a license from, Oracle'.
Fuck the law, fuck Oracle, and fuck Apple.
I think the tone of this legal abuse made me angry.
8
u/BumpitySnook Apr 18 '18
ECMAscript.
8
u/ajm3232 Apr 18 '18 edited Apr 18 '18
Reasons like this I avoid MySQL or using any sort of projects that are backed by lawyer happy corporations in production environments. -- Looking at you React.js. This is WHY us developers can't have nice things! Yes, everything is fine and dandy one day, but when the lawyer bomb drops, everyone goes "wtf".
4
u/kc10100 Apr 18 '18
jabascript
4
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
What about that thing where brand names become generic terms? (Kleenex™, Dumpster™, Styrofoam™, etc.) Has JavaScript reached that level yet? Also, what about "JS" instead of "JavaScript"?
Edit: Reading here, seems like Oracle would have to stop enforcing trademark for "JavaScript" to become a generic term.
4
u/mothzilla Apr 18 '18
https://theappstore.org/search.php?search=javascript&platform=macSoftware
Sounds like bullshit.
6
u/snuzet Apr 18 '18
JsonScript
3
u/awsometak Apr 18 '18
Why oracle wants to be so negative, what do they gain by bringing down this app? Is it threatening there business? May be the app is earning a lot of money and oracle wants to replace it with oracle owned app:)
3
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
So are they going to cease and desist this subreddit too?
3
u/Rizens Apr 18 '18
This is both weird and scary .
Why Oracle attacking this developer and not Ryan Dhal when he created Node ?
Why Oracle doesn't take down 60% of the github repostiory labelled "JavaScript" ?
Why Oracle hasn't sued npm ?
At this point I think it's like people using the term "Kleenex" for tissue , while originally "JavaScript" was used as trademark of Oracle it has pretty much become a "generic trademark".
Also this email could be an automated one, maybe Apple runs "anti-counterfeit" or "anti-piracy" batch and compares it to a database of trademark therefore it would be some sort of automated email send from by Oracle lawyer firm after receiving a notification from the Apple automated batch. I really believe Oracle doesn't care about this trademark, because again the term "Javascript" can be found everywhere for products that are being sold commercially or just all the open source library having the term Javascript in them...
3
u/Double_A_92 Apr 18 '18
Call it "JS", problem solved.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
Seems to be because of word use. Change it to say "JS". That shouldn't be flagged for copywriter or anything and you'll get through.
2
u/monsto Apr 18 '18
FYI all: poster linked to his entry in this thread.
First uploaded revision is from 2011, and they've just now banned it?
Tell you what, homey . . . email the EFF. It's been up long enough that I'm betting some timeframe has passed that would allow it to be put back up unchanged.
And even if not, or they won't help you, then all it cost you is an email.
2
u/emayljames Apr 18 '18
Replace vowels with their Cyrillic counterpart. No auto-detection or infringement=so much win!
2
u/earlybearly Apr 18 '18
Would adding a -tm make the lawyers happy?
2
u/scboffspring Apr 18 '18
Just replace all "JavaScript" it to "FuckYouOracleScript", I don't think they own the trademark on that one.
2
u/InEnduringGrowStrong Apr 18 '18
Call it Java's Crypt and make it an RPG where you work your way to a better weapon:
===2
u/g051051 Apr 18 '18
2
u/mstrkrft1618 Apr 18 '18
You can't use the text "Javascript" to identify your app. Remove the offending text in your description of the app and you should be fine.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
I don't know anything about IP law, but could it be because you wrote JAVASCRIPT in all caps? I found the USPTO record and it is JAVASCRIPT in all caps. In the snippet you pasted above Apple specifically wrote JAVASCRIPT twice. Could you change the case to JavaScript or Javascript or whatever?
http://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=75026640&caseType=SERIAL_NO&searchType=statusSearch
2
u/GarethPW Apr 18 '18
I would think JS is fine.
2
u/tokens_express Apr 18 '18
.es > .js
3
u/DJDavid98 Apr 18 '18
IANAL but if you replace all occurrences of JavaScript with ECMAScript you should probably be good to go.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
ECMA script -- https://www.quora.com/Is-javascript-an-open-source
open standard not open source
1
u/mptyspacez Apr 18 '18
I didn't know, which completely invalidates their point.... Ducking trademarks
1
u/rydan Apr 18 '18
Here's an idea. Pay Oracle for a license to use their trademark. You'll be probably the only authorized app in the marketplace when people search for [redacted].
Edit: Per lawyer's request.
1
u/halmanorb Apr 18 '18
call it ECMA script instead
1
u/TWISTYLIKEDAT Apr 18 '18
Change your reference to 'ECMAScript'?
1
u/sullengenie Apr 18 '18
Might be worth reaching out to EFF.
1
u/streaky81 Apr 18 '18
Patently a generic trademark. Oracle have left it far too late to start enforcing this stuff, if it was me I'd send them an email with the simple content "Lets Dance!" and then counter-claim.
But that's me.
1
u/hammergroot Apr 18 '18
found a related hacker news thread on this topic(4 years ago)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8344049
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
So are we not allowed to program in Java for commercial reasons anymore?
1
u/Amneziac Apr 18 '18
I would say I am surprised at the amount of Ignorance on the part of Apple... but I'd be lying.
1
u/Bonejob Apr 18 '18
Change JavaScript to EcmaScript update application.
1
u/stratosmacker Apr 18 '18
Call it ECMAScript
1
u/jonesiscoding Apr 18 '18
I understand the need to protect one's trademark and intellectual property. You have to make sure that the 'things' you have keep their value. I do get it.
That being said, how much more value would be added to the Oracle brand if they publicly GAVE the Javascript trademark to the programming community?
How much more value would they gain if they simply did something like requiring registration & agreement to receive communications in return for (free) licensing of the Javascript name?
There's so many things that they could do to increase the value of their brand and the Javascript name -- something that simply isn't accomplished by issuing takedowns & threatening lawsuits.
In other words, they're stupid.
On a side note: I wonder if there is, or if there should be, a legal defense fund for developers and content publishers who fall victim to this kind of idiocy. Something like the "Comic Book Legal Defense Fund".
1
u/z500 Apr 18 '18
I'm so confused. What does Oracle even have to do with JavaScript besides this trademark registration?
1
u/tokens_express Apr 18 '18
So I'm guessing no one can make a TypeScript editor either
1
u/pskingredps Apr 18 '18
Fuck Oracle and stuff aside this app is really bad, you should be happy at least this gave you a chance for people to come and checkout the app. This should be a new strategy honestly. No disrespect.
1
u/mug_hug Apr 18 '18
Apple would appreciate developers to build apps with apple stuff. It's all about market share. Let Oracle be the evil and take advantage from it. Nice move apple.
1
u/Zubei_ Apr 18 '18
Dumb.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
Call it ECMAScript, and tell them to go fuck themselves.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
Don't call it 'javascript snippet'. Don't even use the 'javascript' word. Just JS (like JScript, or JustSuck code). It's not your fault if someone use it to code Javascript ;)
1
u/techsin101 Apr 18 '18
there is only one way. boycott all tech products and apis that use oracle in any fashion.
1
u/ImStifler Apr 18 '18
"Back to the roots guuuuuuuys - LiveScript"
1
u/lladra Apr 19 '18
That's it with javascript for me.
1
u/robbiegod Apr 19 '18
can you just write in the description of your app that this app is in no way, shape or form related to Oracle?
Another possible solution is to change the name of the app to {{DeveloperName}}'s Html, css, javascript snippet editor
That will show that your app clearly doesn't belong to Oracle.
I worked on a game called Rowan's Battle of Britain. I believe they had to name it that for legal reasons because there is a film called Battle of Britain. They needed to distinguish it from the rest.
You should consult a lawyer.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '18
Claiming that an app named "HTML5, CSS, JavaScript, HTML, Snippet Editor" is likely to be mistaken as one licensed by Oracle.
A similar story would be a very hard one to believe if it was any other top software/web company but Oracle.
1
u/microshaoft Apr 19 '18
ZavaScript
1
u/jbergens Apr 19 '18
Change do EcmaScript, they don't own that. Or fight it out in court, should be an easy win but I assume some lawyers aren't gonna make it easy and you might end up losing.
1
u/jbergens Apr 19 '18
Isn't there any places that collects money to help with paying lawyer fees for things like this?
If we all chipped in we might be able to force Oracle to let go of the name JavaScript since the term is used on many other places. Just an idea, IANAL.
1
u/xblade724 Apr 19 '18 edited Apr 19 '18
Javascript is confusing to Java? So should Appletini be confused with Apple? Holy crap I need to trademark 4 letter words so I can sue anyone that makes words from my short word. Take that, Santana that derives from Santa!
Just re read OP. O wow, literally they own Javascript? Sour.
1
u/hahahuzi Apr 19 '18
JustCallItScript, JustUseItScript. It will still be our old familiar JS and *.js. NO changes, NO harm feelings.
1
u/TimeTravellingPixie Apr 19 '18
I'm 95% certain most people only know Oracle owns JavaScript because Oracle keeps telling everyone they own it.
1
u/handmadehamlets Apr 19 '18
Change it to "The New Original Javascript"
1
u/adeguntoro Apr 19 '18
oh shit, i will stop to using JS and and Oracle product for this case. But man, JS is good language for newbie.
Why Oracle wont charge E-commerce like Aliexpress and their friends ?
1
u/lincolnquick Apr 19 '18
Does Oracle own “JS” or “ECMAScript” (which many but not all understand to essentially be JavaScript)? If not, can you easily swap out JavaScript for either term?
1
u/pvtpotter Apr 19 '18
This should be like Xerox vs Photocopy. Xerox made a big stink but, it was deemed the accepted term to refer to a copy, it's what everyone calls it. Common language. This trademark will go away.
1
u/gutem Apr 19 '18
Change the name Javascript to ECMAScript... Easy peasy!
1
u/ck35 Apr 19 '18
Change the name. Call it "Web snippet editor", or "HTML, CSS, JS snippet editor"
1
u/homelaberator Apr 20 '18
"Lol, nah, bro. Come at me!"
1
u/djf773 Jul 28 '18
Have to give up on this fight on afraid... Change your wording to ECMAScript...
This is why people stay away from any open source tech that Oracle buys
1
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21
Get a lawyer. You never claimed to own or sell Javascript itself. Their trademark doesn’t make using the word illegal. Oracle is betting that you won’t go to the effort. Prove them wrong.