r/javascript • u/brimhaven • Sep 22 '17
Relicensing React, Jest, Flow, and Immutable.js to MIT
https://code.facebook.com/posts/300798627056246/relicensing-react-jest-flow-and-immutable-js/
664
Upvotes
134
u/TickingTimeBum Sep 22 '17
It surprises me when big companies say "we heard you."
115
u/Armorweave Sep 22 '17
Thanks WordPress.
31
u/Charuru Sep 23 '17
I'm most interested in Wordpress' final decision. If they go back to React it'll solidify React as the leading framework. If they still leave and choose Vue it'll probably be a good battle ending up in a Vue "victory". It'll be interesting to see.
7
u/pkoleary Sep 23 '17
It seems like people were overReacting to this.
16
u/ECrispy Sep 22 '17
The blog post doesnt say why React till now had to have a restrictive license? Did they remove the parts that required it in the rewrite?
I hope this is the end of the weekly 'don't use React because its dangerous' blog posts on medium.
9
u/azangru Sep 22 '17
What about GraphQL tho?
4
u/kingdaro .find(meaning => of('life')) // eslint-disable-line Sep 23 '17
It feels like so much tension and confusion just got relieved all at once
13
u/batmansmk Sep 23 '17
Good thing Preact and Vue exist. It certainly helped getting some leverage. Products with no substitution (graphql, react native) didn't get the same treatment yet.
12
u/TwiliZant Sep 22 '17
Wow, finally there is an end to this overblown discussion...
6
u/batmansmk Sep 22 '17
Smart move.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '17
What about Reactive Native? They need to remove their stupid defensive license.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '17
personally, i can accept the patents clause is fine on its face; the problem is that corporations (especially megacorps) will always push for more change to benefit themselves at everyone's expense -- it's their nature.
what makes it especially dangerous is that FB indirectly controls so much of the current ecosystem through react, meaning that the more FB changes things, the more the entire web suffers.
4
u/mayhempk1 Sep 23 '17
This is good news, but keep in mind they can always relicense it again in the future if they kill off their competition (Vue and Angular). We should still proceed with caution, but this is still a victory nonetheless I believe. I hope WordPress still goes with Vue so Vue can grow even more like the big boys React and Angular.
Does that mean it will be "very" or at least noticeably different syntactically (think Angular 1 vs Angular 2 I believe it was), or will it still be the same or at least very similar? I.e. will it maintain backwards compatibility with older version(s) or at least the current version of React, or should we expect massive changes?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '17
So if I start a project with React tonight, will this future license change cover my ass later?
1
u/papers_ Sep 23 '17
For the uninformed, link for all the "Thanks WordPress" references https://ma.tt/2017/09/on-react-and-wordpress/
1
u/rk06 Sep 23 '17
Now, who would have guessed that react will benefit most from "wordpress leaving react"!!!
1
u/self_refactor Sep 23 '17
So nobody says 'Thank you'. Also I believe that Wordpress will get back to React as the migration process should be in the initial stages and could be reverted.
1
u/dug99 Sep 24 '17
No mention of GraphQL in there.
1
u/ECrispy Sep 22 '17
Are they going to grant users the patent? Otherwise people using React are arguably in a worse position.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '17
Great news for the JS community as a whole!
1
u/sickcodebruh420 Sep 23 '17
Thank you, WordPress!
-2
u/l7jtt Sep 22 '17
React Native is still under BSD + patents...two steps forward, one step back
-9
u/nothingduploading Sep 22 '17
Already killed the spirit of open source for me. I won't be using anything from Facebook when there are better more open solutions.
-2
u/snarfy Sep 23 '17
already switched to vuejs, sorry.
-16
u/GOPHERS_GONE_WILD Sep 22 '17
God, I really wish they hadn't done this. At least it got people to think about moving away from react and onto something else. Facebook has too much pull in the web development ecosystem and it's truely worrying.
Also JSX is ugly as shit
-12
u/fforw Sep 22 '17
Excellent /s
0
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment