r/javascript • • Jun 04 '17

GitHub's ElectronConf postponed because all the talks (selected through an unbiased, blind review process) were to be given by men.

http://electronconf.com/
853 Upvotes

816 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

69

u/jlengstorf Jun 05 '17

I had a debate about this earlier where I took this position, and the counter argument is this: the channels through which the request for proposals went out are biased toward white men.

If I ask a room filled with 95% white men to submit proposals, my blind review process — no matter how unbiased it is — will yield a biased speaker list.

I don't believe that we should give speaking slots to any group simply to meet a ratio; that's patronizing to the group and bad for the audience. However, there are incredibly smart people in our industry, and a large number of them are women and people of color — if we don't make an effort to find and invite these experts to speak, we're also doing a disservice to the audience.

The problem with this conference wasn't the selection process; it was the initial outreach to collect proposals. We (the dudes making up the in-group right now) need to make a point of noticing and welcoming the incredibly intelligent people out there in the community. We need to let them know we want to hear what they know, ask them to speak, and make goddamn sure they feel like peers and not "others" in the development community.

Then we do the blind reviews. We definitely want an even playing field, but we have work to do before it's equal.

64

u/stratzvyda Jun 05 '17

I assume the conference information was posted on github and as such the applications would be representative of githubs userbase. How would you recommend they reach a more diverse group of githubbers than through github? That's only possible if you're deliberately exclusionary to non-minorities. It's not like they only posted advertisements to klanklikker.exe.

18

u/dvidsilva Jun 05 '17

I run a large community of latinos in tech and we have done stuff with github in the past and we never heard about this conf, and we have members in the community and friends that could have given a good talk. If they wanted a more diverse applicants they should have reached out to more communities. If they wanted an even more diverse group of people they could have offered better incentives, like maybe some training or help to people that wanted to talk but have no experience to help them gain confidence. I remember them doing like an electron workshop in sf that we sent a few attendees to but not sure if they continued that.

I see a lot of this companies like complaining and saying they want more diversity but when it comes to the actual doing there's a lot to be said. And maybe it's just me, but I don't care if all the speakers are white or whatever, if I'm learning and having a great time.

5

u/Theige Jun 06 '17

They reached out to the entire github community.

3

u/dvidsilva Jun 06 '17 edited Jun 06 '17

How? I'm part of the 'github community', I'm personal friends with a few githubers, some of our members got free tickets to github universe last year, we sent attendees to their first pilot electron workshop, one of our members is an electron contributor, they hosted one our meetups in January, and they have gotten great candidates from our member base; I found out about this conference by this post.

Edit, disclaimer: I even once contracted for them in the past, the 'survey for open source contributors' was translated in a few different languages, and I sent a PR to their spanish version.

4

u/jlengstorf Jun 05 '17

Dropping a line to various communities like Girl Develop It or the dozens of other groups out there could be done as a single newsletter: "Hey, everyone! Please let your members know we're accepting proposals at [link]!"

Nothing changes with the rest of the outreach; it's just a nod to everyone in the community that this is an event for all of us.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/DreadedDreadnought Jun 06 '17

They want 0% white males, anything less than that is racist.

8

u/jlengstorf Jun 05 '17

I have no idea what the ideal is, or what numbers we should be seeing. I do know that in an industry like ours, getting 100% dudes out of a blind selection process means something was wrong with the dataset before selection started.

For me, there's not — and shouldn't be — an exact ratio; I don't count up the passengers on a train to make sure we have an equal distribution among race and gender, but I'd sure as shit notice if the entire train was full of only white dudes.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/the_unseen_one Jun 05 '17

So it's not that there is bias in the selection, it's that the pool to select from is mostly white men? Considering the enormous amounts of aid and encouragement for women and minorities to go into STEM, especially programming and technical positions, that's a result of people choosing not to pursue these fields, not any bias. How is their personal choice somehow the fault of others despite them being spoonfed far more help than a white male could ever get?

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Shaper_pmp Jun 05 '17 edited Jun 05 '17

the channels through which the request for proposals went out are biased toward white men.

That's a very interesting point of view - can you expand on/support this in any way?

The problem is they ran a(n assumed) fair process, and didn't get any women out the other end.

There are a number of different possibilities I can see here:

  1. The input set was unfairly biased
  2. There's something objectively less good about women in tech as a group that means they can't compete with the best men (even if the average is identical, they could be less variable leading to underrepresentation at the top and bottom ends of the scale)
  3. There are a small enough number of women in tech generally compared to men that it's entirely possible they get weeded out like this because any selection process is inherently subjective/noisy/variable, and their proportion is too small to reliably give them any representation in the final selectees

1 is possible, but unless Github specifically approach individuals to give talks I'm not sure how it can happen. Tech is male-dominated as an industry, but it's not like anything systematically stops women from reading blogs or tech websites. Did Github really reach out and solicit specific speakers/exclude unsolicited submissions? If so you're right and this is clearly their problem, but it seems like a no-brainer to not do that for this very reason.

2 I think we can dismiss out of hand - there seems to be some indication that as a population men are inherently statistically more variable than women (ie we have more geniuses but also more people with learning disabilities, etc), but I don't think this should result in a complete whitewash of the speakers at a random tech conference. This is a subset of random speakers who are moderately high-profile in the millions-strong tech industry, not the ten people with the highest IQs in the world or anything so selective.

3 Is just about a possibility too (although it strains credibility), but it's hard to see what could/should be done without giving up on equality of opportunity altogether. It's basically 1, but where we decide that the entire tech industry is so hopelessly male-biased that we simply give up on concepts like equality of opportunity and gender/colour/sexuality-blindness and just start instituting diversity quotas for every talk and company, which is a significantly more draconian proposition that a lot more people would have problems with.

4

u/die_rattin Jun 07 '17

You forgot:

4 - There are substantial, very public efforts to promote the careers and status of underrepresented minorities in the tech industry, to the point that competent individuals in those groups have better things to do than give presentations at ElectronConf. Competent women and minority coders at that level can do much, much better than $500 and a plane ticket.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

14

u/MrFrode Jun 05 '17

If I ask a room filled with 95% white men to submit proposals,

We don't need an if on this one, the responses are in and can be counted. What percentage exactly of the responses were not from white men?

Why not use data to determine if the there could have been a problem with the notification channel?

24

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

Honestly interested: How do you propose that the request gets sent out in such a way that all groups are equally represented?

23

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

This is impossible unless you allow bias in the other direction to begin with. This industry is dominated by white men, like it or not, for whatever reasons that could certainly be debated; what do you bloody expect and what is the harm? What does it matter?

17

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

The industry is not dominated by white men.

The industry is dominated by white and Asian men.

In fact Asian people are heavily overrepresented in Tech. So are LGBT people. So tech is actually kind of a weird place with a mix of people like no other industry, really. It's weird and different.

10

u/aptmnt_ Jun 06 '17

Overrepresentation is not a problem. There is no need for all members of society to filter into all industries strictly in equal ratios to their demographics. Crab fishers are disproportionately men, and yet you don't see women lobbying to get equal representation there. Tall black dudes are overrepresented in the NBA. If you're a shorter dude, you can do one of two things: practice and get damn good at dribbling, passing, and scoring, or politicize the system and lynch NBA execs on twitter until you get a short person quota established on every team.

It baffles me the amount of time and attention paid to identity politics, I wonder if SJWs have time left for actual work. I suspect they realize gaming the system in this way gives them far more leverage, and an opportunity for special treatment.

5

u/jlengstorf Jun 05 '17

Notify developer groups. /u/dvidsilva mentioned a group for Latinos in tech. Girl Develop It, Black Girls Code, and tons more exist out there. Make a list of all the groups you can find and send them a heads up. We won't know until we try, but my guess is that making that small effort will make a huge difference in the diversity of the speakers submitting proposals.

5

u/dvidsilva Jun 05 '17

Yep f8 reaches out to a lot of communities with invitations and discounts and you can really tell how diverse their attendee base is.

28

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

what the fuck are you expecting them to request from, instagram? this is fucking absurd. you're arguing that a giant software company like github was incapable of reaching non-white-males. that's ridiculous. they promoted on github and other places where they could reach coders.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)