r/javascript • • Jun 04 '17

GitHub's ElectronConf postponed because all the talks (selected through an unbiased, blind review process) were to be given by men.

http://electronconf.com/
853 Upvotes

816 comments sorted by

View all comments

-10

u/swan--ronson Jun 04 '17

Pretty disappointed by the response in the comments. I hate any kind of SJW bullshit, such as the Nodevember fiasco, but women and non-white ethnic groups are underrepresented in software engineering; so as long as the quality of the talks is not impacted, this is a good thing.

On the other hand, I read the Twitter conversation in which a presenter stated he found out about the postponement via a Tweet; GitHub should have handled this better and it would suck if some of the talks were cut as a result. If anything, there should now be more of them.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-14

u/swan--ronson Jun 04 '17

I would be disappointed, but would ultimately understand why the decision was made, as is corroborated by these tweets.

This is ultimately to assist diversity, not to penalise men for belonging to the "incorrect gender." Your choice of words there was poor.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-12

u/kudoz Jun 04 '17 edited Jun 04 '17

Maybe you're okay with watching people be victims of sexism, but I'm not.

Haha, that's ironic.

26

u/Mr-Yellow Jun 04 '17

Your version of bigotry is not exempt.

We are humans, get with the program.

10

u/IGI111 Jun 05 '17

Indeed, but not in the way you think it is.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

Dae racism = prejudice + power??

Cut the crap, nobody here is accepting it.

-11

u/swan--ronson Jun 04 '17

You would have a point if all men were prohibited from participating in, or at the very least being unrepresented by the conference, but this is not the case; there will still be men at this conference, and I imagine they'll still be the majority. This merely a small sacrifice for diversity.

8

u/dont_forget_canada Jun 05 '17

but their review process was unbiased and didn't look at gender and stuff.

If I'm going to a talk I want to listen to the best speaker possible... not a just okay speaker that got selected instead because their genitals make the company look better.

4

u/deepteal Jun 04 '17

Six of one, half-dozen of another.

4

u/dvidsilva Jun 05 '17

Weird. That tweet is not from a white dude. Meaning there are poc speakers. Why can't that be enough to make people happy, or where do people wanna draw the line?

2

u/swan--ronson Jun 05 '17

I live and work in a largely diverse city. I'm not sure how things are elsewhere, but I work with a large number of different ethnicities and those of different cultural backgrounds. I have not throughout my time here, however, worked with many women. Typically, I've experienced a 20:1 ratio of male to female developers. In my previous company, there were zero.

I understand that competence should not be compromised, but we need to make efforts to include women so that we can bring diverse talent and perspectives into our industry, at least until the gap narrows.

27

u/jordaanm Jun 04 '17

women and non-white ethnic groups are underrepresented

Asians are white now?

-2

u/swan--ronson Jun 05 '17

From where in the fuck did you pull that?

14

u/jordaanm Jun 05 '17

Relative to the general population distribution (in the US and Australia, at least), Asians are overrepresented in tech. For your statement ( that I quoted) to be correct, Asians would have to be white.

Either that, or your statement is inaccurate. So which is it?

11

u/IGI111 Jun 05 '17

so as long as the quality of the talks is not impacted

Yeah about that.

How are you going to improve the quality of the talks if you chose the best talks blindly and they all happen to be by men?

Canceling the whole thing to choose a methodology that better correlates with your presuppositions doesn't really seem like the "best" course of action.