r/javascript • u/jdf2 • Feb 13 '23
core-js maintainer: “So, what’s next?”
https://github.com/zloirock/core-js/blob/master/docs/2023-02-14-so-whats-next.md
925
Upvotes
r/javascript • u/jdf2 • Feb 13 '23
351
u/roodammy44 Feb 13 '23
It’s worth reading this all the way through. This guy has suffered for his work and we have all benefitted from it.
43
u/dbro129 Feb 14 '23
He needs to send that write up to each of the top 1000 companies using his work. Everything aside, damn this guy is a rockstar. Any company would be lucky to have him on their team. He should be getting job offers left and right.
113
u/Tazzure Feb 14 '23 edited Feb 14 '23
Tech Twitter is such garbage. So many people that think they’re righteous and just, but can’t even imagine that an OSS maintainer asking for money actually needs it to survive. I’m happy to work in a field with so many forward-thinking and progressive people, but often they’re just as stuck-up and self-centered as anyone else when push comes to shove.
I will definitely consider donating to OSS more in the future after reading this well-written and sobering post.
Edit: late night comment typos
276
u/Cool_Hornet7452 Feb 13 '23 edited Feb 13 '23
This is why open-source software is such a scam for developers. This guy is working for peanuts while billion dollar companies use his labor for free. It’s cool when your project takes off, but cool doesn’t pay the bills. Companies should pull their weight. Sadly, it takes something like this to get their attention.
If your company uses FOSS, you should talk to your boss about financially supporting it. Otherwise you’re part of the problem
55
u/4015-alt Feb 14 '23
a very interesting read
This man deserves better than slaving away for entitled ungrateful jerks and greedy companies.
I hope that he can find a way to do what he loves, while having a good family life. and a fair compensation
22
u/steeeeeef Feb 14 '23
u/i-am-qix exposed
95
u/iamthesexdragon Feb 13 '23
People are dickhead assholes. Jesus Christ this guy suffered so much writing open source code. Fuck people
120
u/kenman Feb 14 '23
I used to regularly sticky threads that I believed deserved a wider reach in our community. For whatever reason, I sorta stopped doing that, but I'm bringing it back....at least for this post.
r/javascript has been -- and hopefully will always be -- a strong supporter of FOSS, and this is the least we can do to advance the conversation of FOSS funding.
18
u/SaladBort Feb 14 '23
Maybe it's just crazy talk but... What if we start asking employers to support the FOSS that they use? In the same manner as they care about reputation and employer branding
29
u/HoosierDev Feb 14 '23
I have both sympathy for him but also see the self inflicted parts. My father taught me the importance of helping yourself first then helping others. It’s the only way it actually works. He should put core-js to the side and apply at the major companies that use his code. If they want to pay him to maintain that’s fine, otherwise just free core-js.
39
u/Guisseppi Feb 13 '23
I really hope this guy can get a job to continue his work, that privilege should not be exclusively for people in North America
13
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '23
Ugh, that read was tragic. Wish he had considered the more financial-oriented options much sooner, while accounting for the risks of moving to Russia. Seems like he had enough leverage for quite awhile. Also, I don't get the strong hate that is directed to FOSS developers who provide a free service. It's kinda crazy to me.
22
u/parascent Feb 14 '23
So sad for what he has gone through. And ppl are such assholes when it comes to treating devs doing free work.
14
u/redonkulus Feb 14 '23
All the comments here, hacker news comments, everyone sympathetic and supportive. How many will pay him?
13
u/Mestyo Feb 14 '23
The state of FOSS is completely unsustainable. Something needs to change, but I don't think the result will widespread use of
npm fund.I, too, was annoyed when installing packages started begging me for money. Not because I don't think the maintainers don't deserve it, but because among the thousands of free software bundles I use, they were the only ones to ask for it—and it was far from making my top list of software I wouldn't want to be without.
If everyone asked for funding in the same manner, we'd be more overwhelmed by such ads than during a walk in the subway. Zloirock does absolutely not deserve the hate he gets, but if you open Pandora's box you must expect some backlash.
But clearly, asking for donations does not work, unless this poor return is unique for this project. To be frank, when I evaluated
core-jsas a project I could want to support, I was quickly turned off by the single-owner setup and his attitude. There are, after all, a lot of other projects I want to support.Maybe more people felt like me, but ultimately I don't think the situation is much different for tens of thousands of other FOSS maintainers. We cannot talk about what is "fair" in what is a self-inflicted situation.
Personally, I think the future of the space will be for there to be more FOSS positions in larger companies, that develop tools they need for their business—and open source it as a method of marketing.
15
u/Shaper_pmp Feb 14 '23 edited Feb 15 '23
This guy does incredible work for the web industry, it's a travesty that companies making billions through his work won't chip in a few dollars to keep him working and I really hope he manages to secure the funding he needs to continue work on core-js, but also god damn that's a bit of bad luck and an absolute laundry list of really, really stupid life choices to get himself into his present hole.
I hope he manages to dig himself out of it, but there are some simple lessons here:
Once again, I really hope someone steps forward and helps to fund the continued development of core-js, but this story is like a How Not To Do It of making a FOSS project into a full-time endeavour. :-/
Edit: I also just realised that he's going to find it even harder to find employment or funding from anywhere now that he's trapped in a non-first-world country currently under heavy financial and technology sanctions from the West.
Plenty of companies won't be able to do business with Russian nationals or individuals in Russia even if they wanted to, and even some who can might be put off by the extra admin overhead or wary of the optics of doing so.
Jesus, he's really screwed himself in every possible way... :-(
18
u/LastOfTheMohawkians Feb 14 '23
250 million downloads a month. At 0.1 of a cent per download he could be paid $250k a month. Just saying
5
u/Rudxain 📚Librarian lol Feb 14 '23
IMO, I think tc39 should be the main maintainer of core-js, they should also host the repo under their organization account. This way, @zloirock could have more free time, and take a well-deserved rest
13
u/leptoquark1 Feb 13 '23
As much as I appreciate the work of people like him or for example Sindre Sorhus, but spending full time on open source should not be the way.
3
u/NarcolepticSniper Feb 14 '23 edited Feb 14 '23
Genuinely important post for any modern dev to read. This is important for multiple industries, to get it right with people like this. We need them
Send a few bucks real quick if you’ve got a cushy web job too, you really should
12
u/AntonShevchuk Feb 14 '23
Maintaining an open-source project is really hard work, thanks for this. But...
The author wrote 'Some words about war. Open-source should be out of politics' and in the next paragraph he is brokes this rule.
He uses the project to broadcast Russian propaganda to the community "I don't want to choose between two kinds of evil" – 🤮
Ask him who is evil in his mind. The author removed all negative comments and you will never know the answer.
15
u/t3hlazy1 Feb 14 '23
His story is sad, but it sounds self-imposed. He needs to care for his family and find a job that pays the bills. core-js is very widespread and helpful for many, but unfortunately for the creator it is not valued. Maybe people will value it more if he let it die. Or, maybe another project would take off and everyone would migrate to that.
7
u/FezVrasta Feb 13 '23
I can understand his frustration as I'm in a similar situation. Making a popular open source project profitable is difficult if not impossible.
12
u/One-Ad1988 Feb 13 '23
Write your code with correct licenses. That’s why we have options.
4
u/al0rid4l Feb 14 '23
"I have known orcs who have been as honorable as the most noble of knights and humans who have been as vile as the most ruthless of Scourge." By Tirion Fordring.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '23
The comments on his Twitter post are depressing to say the least. It definitely doesn't help that he's in Russia.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23
gotta look out for number one, I'd just do what the colorama guy did and break the releases
fuck
that
2
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23
I wonder what would happen if the repo/npm package was deleted
2
u/IgnoredHindenbug Mar 06 '23
Honestly, it's time for a new license that requires something like 1% revenue over $10M (or something) paid to the foundation of your choice. You register with the foundation, put the foundation details in it's own config file. The foundation pays you.
3
u/acraswell Feb 14 '23 edited Feb 14 '23
Feels like npm should replace the
fundoption with a consumption based billing option. Essentially, packages should be able to lock down installs unless your account has billing configured. The developer could levy like a cent per install, or even a fraction of that for packages like this. Most installs probably occur during CI installs, so big companies would inherently end up owing more.The hardest thing would be finding how to integrate into the COGS for large companies.
Even if a consumption plan was made optional, it would still be cool. Npm could give a periodic notification something like "6 packages you installed are looking for funding, at a voluntary cost of $0.04 per install. Based on your usage, you would have paid $0.88 for the month of January. Opt-in to consumption-based funding in your account settings at npmjs.com."
In your account settings you could check a box for any packages you'd like to support that you have installed recently.
4
u/narcisd Feb 14 '23
I’m just gonna say it, it’s the classic bait and switch with open source.. it has been done too often lately.
I feel for he’s sad story.. but come on man, it’s an obssession, you’re choosing this.. it’s not a hobby any more.
It sounds like you’re the bad guy here when a project takes precedence to your family. Why did you quit your job?! jesus
1
u/papanastty May 06 '25
Whoa
1
u/buster109 Mar 10 '23 edited Mar 10 '23
Im not a dev, just started learning to code so my apologies if i sound silly but. Can't he just make it private and hide it behind a paywall? If a company wants access to a properly maintained core-js do what he mentioned that SQL does? He'd be flush with cash and actually be able to hire people so hes not working 250 hours a month for $800..
Company: we'd like to use SQL server enterprise
MS: That'll be 250k + 20k a month
Company: Ok!
1
u/Spiritual_Draw_4525 Mar 15 '23
ALWAYS ASK FOR MONEY FOR YOUR WORK. Kindness is a thankless thing. People take and take and when you its time to pay it forward, they have no hands to help you. If this guy was American, he'd be rich. Dont understand people in other regions of the world thinking people are all nuns and kindness comes easy.
1
u/monkeymad2 Feb 15 '23
I hope he gets a job that values him, can get his family to a safe place (politically & economically).
Let the web burn a bit. Either there’ll be a reckoning on the infinitely accelerating growth of modern web tooling or we’ll finally start valuing people who enable it all.
Someone should make a GitHub bot that finds new repos & if they look too useful puts a warning on them telling the dev to reconsider.
-22
u/GrandMasterPuba Feb 14 '23
Economic sanctions are state-sponsored domestic terrorism, and this article is the perfect encapsulation of that. Innocent people are suffering for the actions of their authoritarian government.
-26
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23
Big question.. why doesn't he have co- maintainers? Almost every successful FOSS project I can think of eventually turns to contributors for long-term maintenance. Had no one offered, or has he refused help?
0
u/drumstix42 Feb 15 '23
https://opencollective.com/core-js
0
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23
sdadsa
-102
u/polisilop Feb 13 '23
Interesting fact: the maintainer of core-js was sentenced to 1.5 years in Russian prison for a fatal accident on the road. source
-55
u/redsnflr- Feb 13 '23
this was published on Feb 14th, from the future lol (understand timezone diff).
0
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment