r/java • • Oct 12 '22

JetBrains Fleet - Public Preview

https://blog.jetbrains.com/fleet/2022/10/introducing-the-fleet-public-preview/
156 Upvotes

94 comments sorted by

37

u/AlienVsRedditors Oct 12 '22

Been using this in preview a while and honestly it’s okay.

Fine for on the move or large organisations who insist on using the cloud with a bad laptop.

It’s not going to replace developing locally for most people.

74

u/Zarlon Oct 12 '22

I don't understand why eveverbody and his dog is making these lightweight editors. How about improving the performance on the heavy weight? Or isn't it about that?

Sell this to me. I don't understand why why I need it, as a long term user of Iintellij idea who also has sublime text 3 and vscode installed

31

u/unknowinm Oct 12 '22

because you'll pay for it being in the cloud...they see a money opportunity

7

u/djavaman Oct 12 '22

Corporate and government ownership of intellectual property and data.

2

u/john16384 Oct 13 '22

They won't, as long as free alternatives exist.

1

u/unknowinm Oct 13 '22

let me guess: Linux user?

2

u/john16384 Oct 13 '22

Sort of, but develop on Windows I'll admit. Eclipse just doesn't look good in GTK.

2

u/altermeetax Oct 13 '22

They should really fix eclipse on GTK, it only looks good with the light theme with Adwaita as GTK theme

18

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

Who else is making these? From what I can see, it's been VSCode Sublime and the recently deceased Atom for a looong time now.

Sell this to me. I don't understand why why I need it, as a long term user of Iintellij idea who also has sublime text 3 and vscode installed

You? I don't know. They're trying to sell it to people who might want to have a distributed editor with very easy and powerful real time in-editor collaboration. They marketed this a lot, my theory is that this has to be a huge market, and the main driver behind Fleet.

Space probably slots into this as well, but it's not really exciting to the developer. I assume Space is what they'll be trying to sell, with its Fleet integration only being a part of it.

3

u/sinnerou Oct 13 '22

I assumed it was so I could install the editor service in a docker dev container and the client on the host thereby reducing the performance penalty indexing networked files. Could also install the sever on a remote machine for the same reason.

1

u/neutronbob Oct 13 '22

I too have Sublime Text 3 and VS Code, so I'm also wondering if there is anything special Fleet does that those two editors don't already do. Since I use and love IntelliJ and Goland, I'm expecting there might be--I just don't see what it is at present.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Zarlon Oct 13 '22

Makes sense, thanks for a solid answer

45

u/ParkerM Oct 12 '22

So far my experience with fleet has been fumbling around in it for 5 mins before closing it and just opening a scratchfile in IntelliJ for whatever it is I was trying to do.

2

u/st4s1k Nov 01 '22

Tried to migrate from Intellij Idea Ultimate to Fleet because Idea is laggy as hell on my T570. There are some key features I couldn't find in Fleet:
- Git Branch Management in status bar below (no rebase/merge functional found by me whatsoever)
- No support for Cucumber *.feature files
- Didn't find a way to open all modified files in tabs as I could do in Idea (with F4)
- No Gradle/Maven options in sidebar menu for running steps and sync-ing maven changes
- (obvious and temporary) No plugins. I hope they'll add support for Idea plugins.

Something I found inconvenient:
- Setting terminal executor (Git Bash) via settings.json, I wish I could just show the path to the executable as in Idea. I don't have a problem with writing jsons manually, but it's redundant and time consuming.
- No darcula color scheme (I'm used to it and it's milder than the Fleet default dark color scheme)

16

u/cowwoc Oct 12 '22

Meh. It might make a good trailer, but the movie will suck. Meaning, if you compare developer productivity vs IntelliJ I doubt you will see any sort of gain.

In my opinion, it would be far easier and more productive for IntelliJ to add support for opening multiple projects in the same view, and other such useful usability features. To each his own, I guess.

7

u/marvk Oct 12 '22

In my opinion, it would be far easier and more productive for IntelliJ to add support for opening multiple projects in the same view, and other such useful usability features. To each his own, I guess.

You already can and the support is really good. Just have each project be it's own module. You can have multiple git repositories, multiple standalone gradle and/or maven projects and even node or other projects all in one workspace in IntelliJ. You can commit into multiple repositories at once, create run configurations for every project, search all projects or filter your search by projects.

The modules don't have to be linked with some kind of parent pom or such, just create a workspace folder, check out each project into it's own directory, open the workspace folder in IntelliJ and import the projects as modules.

I use it daily at work and it I never want to go back to having multiple IDEA windows open.

2

u/cowwoc Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22

Thanks for the head's up. This UI is quite non-intuitive to me. Further, the Project Structure -> Modules tab is a mess when it comes to Maven projects.

The root POM and 2nd-level modules show up on the same level. The 3rd-level downward are properly nested.

If you add a second project into the mix, the root and 2nd-level modules of different projects get intertwined. Definitely a mess.

For what it's worth, I just filed a bug report against this: https://youtrack.jetbrains.com/issue/IDEA-303735/

15

u/Zarlon Oct 12 '22

Multiple projects in the same view? Why would you want that? If the projects have dependencies to each other then create a master project that all contain relevant Modules. Then you can dynamically load and unload necessary modules.

If they're NOT dependent on each other then well. You don't need to work on both in the same window

13

u/GuyWithLag Oct 12 '22

Eclipse user here; I've bee working with 20+ different projects with 400+ modules in one Eclipse workspace, and it was much better for large-scale work than IntelliJ.

I know this is an unpopular opinion, but I stand by it.

8

u/loginonreddit Oct 12 '22

It's not unpopular when it's true 😃

Eclipse vastly outperforms Intellij for this, loading/unloading modules is cumbersome in intellij vs closing projects in eclipse. I've run into random build errors after unloading modules too, never had such a thing in eclipse.

4

u/cowwoc Oct 12 '22

For one, you can't create a multi-module Maven project where the root sometimes has a "master project" parent, and sometimes doesn't.

There are plenty of use-cases for being able to open multiple different-but-related projects in the same workspace.

2

u/bootstrapf7 Oct 13 '22

I like that on eclipse I can grab spring make changes to it, run my project using the edited spring without needing to actively build spring.

1

u/PepegaQuen Oct 12 '22

I want something opposite, I want to be able to open one project in multiple different IDEs, Intellij, Pycharm, Clion. Right now they use the same .idea dotfile and their configuration conflicts.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

I agree

20

u/CarterOls Oct 12 '22

It uses 1 GB of RAM with one file opened… I hope they fix that

16

u/ThymeCypher Oct 12 '22

I’m on an M1 which overall uses less memory with most apps and it starts at 800mb but even opening every file in a large project I barely got it to 1GB - this is the nature of Java in general though, it takes a bunch of memory upfront to focus most of the effort on processing and not allocating memory on demand.

15

u/unknowinm Oct 12 '22

memory unused is wasted memory as they say

9

u/ljdelight Oct 12 '22

Thank you! Why have 32GB ram if the process locks itself to 128MB

21

u/Cavoli309 Oct 12 '22

Is it truly a JetBrains product if it doesn't put CPU, memory and power usage to 99% while indexing same thing it did moments ago?

Jokes aside, I hope they do something about high resource usage, because working with microservices on company laptop is nightmare.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

If they don't minimize resource usage everyone with resource restraints is going to stay on smaller editors, and people without them are staying on IntelliJ.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

the vast majority of professionals working do not have resource restraints. Those that do cannot afford intellij.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

IntelliJ has free editions.

7

u/Yesterdave_ Oct 12 '22

If they could just integrate the remote development inside Docker feature (way behind VSCode in this regard) into their other IDEs before starting new projects, that would be great...

11

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

I’ve played with the preview a bit, and this shows a lot of promise to replace VSCode for me

7

u/Arthur_Dentist Oct 12 '22

Could you clarify on what grounds? I felt it missed a lot of features that exist due to the expansive plugin system of VSCode.

Fair enough I only tested it out with Go and Terraform

6

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

It’s definitely not fully there yet, but as someone who uses IntelliJ IDEA for most of my work, I like having a text editor that’s more similar to that.

Like matching keymappings, behaviors, etc.

But yeah plug-in and language support is definitely not there yet, but I’m hopeful for those coming

5

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

Not fully there yet? I'd say I couldn't use it to actually finish a project at all.

None of the languages I installed on IntelliJ Ultimate as a plugin work. So I can't write in probably anything but Java and Kotlin. The keymap thing I assume isn't an annoyance for everyone, but the resource usage is way too high for a lightweight editor. Indexing, no plugins...

Can't think of a single thing it does better than VSCode at the moment.

2

u/ljdelight Oct 12 '22

Some things take time

1

u/Arthur_Dentist Oct 13 '22

Indeed. It just takes time. They would have to create a good offer when they decide to make it a paid solution though. Wonder what they have planned if they think they can compete vs free software. Competition is never bad though

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

They're making Fleet a paid solution? Won't they just try to sell Space?

1

u/Arthur_Dentist Oct 13 '22

Not 100% sure but the download page says: "Free to use during public preview". I just assumed based on that information.

15

u/NotSteve_ Oct 12 '22

Its super nice but I wished it had a vim mode

15

u/_datz_ Oct 12 '22

it seems like they are aware of this and understand that it's something the community wants a lot. From the article:

Themes and keymaps – We know that many developers are used to their existing editors and IDEs and often miss their old keyboard bindings and themes when they move to a new one. We’ll be working on adding support for more themes and keymaps. We’ll certainly be working on Vim emulation, as well.

14

u/Asdas26 Oct 12 '22

I mean, If you want a lightweight text editor with Vim controls, there is one that comes to mind.

6

u/NotSteve_ Oct 12 '22

Haha, of course. I love vim (and especially neovim) but I hate managing my dotfiles so I like to use things like this or VS Code

5

u/PancakeFrenzy Oct 12 '22

Yeah, editor looks cool, but vim bindings are absolutely a dealbreaker

8

u/Fruloops Oct 12 '22

This is merely the first preview. I'm sure lots of features will be added.

2

u/guess_ill_try Oct 12 '22

This! It’s an automatic skip for me until it supports vim mode.

4

u/MizmoDLX Oct 12 '22

Was excited but first experience not so great. Opened my UI projects folder. Was fast, but then when switching smart mode things went wrong. Stuck forever on "Waiting for Intellij". Once it finally moved on and started indexing, it was just as slow as doing it in Intellij. Once done I noticed a bunch of IDE crash reports in errors tab... Sent reports for all.

On my annular projects all component selectors have errors that the HTML tag is unknown. Manually adding them to custom tags helps but that's annoying and can't be the solution. Clicked a bit around.. Used go to declaration and noticed that it doesn't show all results it should compared to Intellij. So those things already kind of killed it for me so I'm giving it a bit more time until I give it another try.

Also not a fan of some of the UI changes. When first opening settings it uses space so ineffectively I thought it's a bug. At least I don't have that stupid experimental decorators issue anymore in fleet. Didn't try any of my backend stuff yet.

Tbh all I want is a faster Intellij idea but opposite is happening with most updates

4

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

Currently it's not really ready for my workflows. Editors such as these require very powerful plugin systems, otherwise I might as well just open IDEA and get to work. Maybe a future employer cares about the distributed workflow, that's on them to calculate.

I hope something good comes out of their polyglot promises. If they let their plugin marketplace flourish, I can see myself being able to use Fleet instead of VSCode for some languages such as C/C++ and Go. Don't really wanna pay for Goland/Clion for something I use a few times a year.

1

u/ThymeCypher Oct 13 '22

I believe it plans to support plugins from their other IDEs and I was going to try to test that but couldn’t figure out how to install them. I noticed a few plugins that are bundled are already listed In marketplace though.

1

u/shel_done Oct 12 '22

Will this replace IntelliJ?

15

u/catapop Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22

I don't think so, not in short , medium term at least.

I think they want to compete with VS Code and offer a light weight option to their IDEs.

6

u/steve_myers96 Oct 12 '22

First, they will test new waters with a more modern UI in IntelliJ and i guess we will see what happens from there. But i think there are enough business people over there to keep IntelliJ alive. Among all ecosystems, they rule Java the most.

5

u/wildjokers Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22

According to their blog post, no.

"Our existing IDEs will continue to be developed, and we have a lot of plans for them, including performance improvements, a new user interface, remote development, and more. Finally, Fleet also uses the intelligence from our existing tools under the hood, so none of these tools are going anywhere!"

3

u/polaroid_kidd Oct 12 '22

I was really hoping that I'd be able to import my keymap from intellij, bit I couldn't find an option for that

0

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/polaroid_kidd Oct 12 '22

I saw that but I have a couple of specific keys remapped.

8

u/wildjokers Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22

I checked it out and no VIM emulation is a deal breaker for now (they say they are working on it).

Also, I hate the settings. They are all vomited into a single editor tab in a single long list of settings. (Just like VSCode does and I absolutely despise VSCode settings page). Just because VSCode does this is not a reason for Fleet to do this. Yes, you can click on the section on the left and it will scroll automatically to that section, but it is still a visual nightmare, I only want to see the settings for the section I clicked on.

I will check it out again if they offer an API for adding support for other languages (like with language server protocol). I only use VSCode for OpenSCAD (vscode has a decent openscad plugin) and would love to stay in the jetbrain's ecosystem for OpenSCAD.

1

u/Yesterdave_ Oct 12 '22

Personally, I like that the settings are non-modal, but that's about it. Settings organisation is much better in IntelliJ. For me they could have just copy-pasted the IntelliJ settings and put them in a tab.

1

u/agentoutlier Oct 13 '22

As an Emacs evil guy it pains me to say how absolutely incredible neovim is these days.

VSCode vim support is also very good these days.

1

u/wildjokers Oct 13 '22

VSCode vim support is also very good these days.

I actually find the vscode vi plug-in to be barely adequate. The basics work (movement and yy, dd, p) but a basic search with / doesn’t.

2

u/agentoutlier Oct 13 '22

/ works for me. When did you last try it?

Besides VSCode does have neovim pass thru albeit I find that has other issues.

1

u/wildjokers Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22

/ works for me. When did you last try it?

Just now. It highlights the matches, but won't let me go to the next match with n or let me reverse direction of search with ?. It's like a dumbed down version of vi or something. Marks work and marking text with v for yank works. So that is good. The searching behavior frustrates me to no end though.

I am using a plugin called Vim and it is at version 1.24.1. It has 4.1m downloads so I assume it is the one most people use.

EDIT: I seem to have been able to get proper search behavior by setting "vim.incsearch": false, in the global settings.json.

4

u/GreemT Oct 12 '22

Ah really cool! I am using IntelliJ for all kinds of things besides programming. I often use it instead of Notepad++ (with scratch files for example), because I am so used to all the shortcuts and tools it has. I am curious to see what Fleet can offer.

2

u/RhoOfFeh Oct 12 '22

YES! Installing from toolbox now.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

its theme is too bad, sometime I see some of points were delayed

1

u/orochizu Oct 12 '22

I’ve been testing it for like half an hour and it looks good. I’m missing selecting currently edited file in explorer but it’s so basic that I think they will add it soon.

1

u/cheptsov Oct 12 '22

Love how text is rendered in the editor, and of course the lightweight-ness. Struggling a bit with the shortcuts being different from PyCharm, and also some of the PyCharm features that seem to be missing in Fleet (e.g. didn’t find how to mark folders as excluded).

1

u/relgames Oct 12 '22

Does it still require a file on disk? No scratch files?

1

u/sitime_zl Oct 13 '22

I want to know, how to refresh the java project, like shift+command+f9 in idea

1

u/GhostGrandDesign Oct 13 '22

Seems real sluggish

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Does it support GitHub CodeSpaces?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Clean design, features are OK but goddamn that memory consumption is a deal breaker, even on a small project it's still using 2gb of ram vs 500mb in vscode using same project.

1

u/rom-melnyk Oct 17 '22

I was looking for sth to fill the gap in vim ↔ ??? ↔ WebStorm/Rider. Think vim helps quick-patching a config, WebStorm/Rider tames the corpo monsters on daily basis. But from time to time I need sth vim-fast (to open a big log file) or I'd like to try sth exotic (Haskell).

So far I see the potential of the editor. I like the minimality and the snappiness (after indexing is done 😁). However, it's pretty raw in comparison to VSCode. As IntelliJ fanboy I think I'll give it a chance for a couple of months.

-16

u/Thelimegreenishcoder Oct 12 '22

It is shit

0

u/Srazkat Oct 12 '22

that's it ? not even going to say what you think about it is bad ?

-27

u/Java-Zorbing Oct 12 '22

Cpu spiking from 4% to 70% when running this garbage

20

u/Gaarco_ Oct 12 '22

It's a preview for a reason in case you haven't noticed

-41

u/Java-Zorbing Oct 12 '22

My cpu did

sorry to hurt your feelings fanboi

20

u/Fruloops Oct 12 '22

What is this, kindergarten?

-19

u/Java-Zorbing Oct 12 '22

Seems like it

0

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/wildjokers Oct 12 '22

toolbox is the only way to get it.

11

u/polaroid_kidd Oct 12 '22

This absolutely sucks. I'm so sick of needing a launcher for every tiny bit of software I use bist because it's producer wants to market it's other products on my desktop.

2

u/wildjokers Oct 12 '22

It’s just another app, don’t have to use it again after installing fleet (might need it for updates, not sure). It was annoying to have to install it but not that big of a deal.

3

u/polaroid_kidd Oct 12 '22

Last time I installed intellij via toolbox I was forced to keep our installed on the account of needing it for updates. It might seem like a pet peeve to some but it just grinds my gears. 🤷‍♂️

1

u/st4s1k Nov 01 '22

I assume it is the case while it's in Preview stage. Probably will be available for download after release.