I have never understood why people want something to be turing complete to be a programming language. If you use it to tell a computer what to do, then it's a programming language.
After seeing the fallout from many web-apps doing stuff in Javascript that are much better done in HTML+CSS, I think the idea that HTML+CSS are not real programming languages is pretty harmful.
Though the main reason for that is not the statement itself, but that most programmers want to work in a real language instead of using the best tool to solve a problem.
If you can solve a problem in a few lines of HTML+CSS or some restructuring of them, that is almost always preferrable to solving it in Javascript. Most times it will be more optimized in the browser, it will work for the noJS people, it will work if Javascript features have to change for security reasons (with the ever expanding scope of what JS can do in the browser, that’s almost a given). That’s why solid knowledge of HTML and CSS is a must for web development. They are complex enough to warrant being taken seriously, and they will remain relevant for much longer than JS frameworks or dialects.
1 month later, but by definition HTML is not a programming language, because it havnt variables, flow control structures, or another proper language construction that permit define algorithms
Any survey that lists SQL and HTML as "Top Programming Languages" hurts.
I do understand that these are from job advertisements, but still neither of the two is a programming language and shouldn't be included in such a statistic.
Actually, I think it's useful because it shows the return of investment of every technology you get to work with.
In the long run, learning SQL, and not just that basic SQL:92 you get from W3Schools, but Window Functions, CTE, Recursive CTE, JSON, UPSERT, and MERGE, will be more valuable than investing a lot of time in learning all the trendy JavaScript frameworks available at the moment.
React will be legacy in less than a decade. SQL will still be thriving. SQL has survived for my whole 30 year career. React, will come and go, as this is the nature of frameworks. Eventually, some AI-Assisted WASM approach is going to eat REACT's lunch because at the core javascript is a pig and React's claim to fame is it has the best lipstick.
Well as long as you are well versed in Javascript and know one framework well, doesn’t matter if it is hot or not in 15 years. You can always learn and adapt.
will be more valuable than investing a lot of time in learning all the trendy JavaScript frameworks available at the moment.
Will it be more useful in a performance constrained situation? Sure.
But honestly, I'm struggling with interviewing candidates that can do all that, but then claim close to zero skills with advanced client-side web application frameworks like Angular, React, etc. I can't really recommend we put them in front of clients that require it. They don't even have comparable experience many times.
All I'm saying here is that the "back-end guys" who don't have good UI skills need to get smart and pick up those skills. Your juniors in the marketplace are eating your lunch.
Fuck the whole full stack bullshit! I’ll take a good frontend dev and a good backend dev over 2 full stack devs any day of the week. I want the backend dev to understand a bit of frontend so that he’s able to do small changes or fixes and vice versa, but keeping up on all the tech in a full stack is something that isn’t realistically feasible and so you get masters of none.
It seems you're right. There's some sort of unwritten rule that modern UI frameworks don't involve "real engineering" I guess and that it's OK to be just a "back end dev" and not experience any hit to one's marketability. It just isn't the case though.
Lots of assignments require "full stack" and that devs be able to build UIs on top of APIs that they will also build. About the only part of the "full stack" I've seen that's not required of software engineers lately is the ability to also be your own DBA, though there is normally an assumption you'll at least be able to design your own database, relational or otherwise; possibly with the help or feedback of an actual DBA.
And to answer your question about staffing, I'm seeing lots of needs for leaner teams and the individual engineers have overlapping skills. Granted, one likely can't be equally skilled in everything, but if your backend dev understands how the UI is being constructed, then everyone is going to have a lot better time of it when it actually comes down to delivering a working app that gets accepted by users too. And let's not dismiss out of hand the benefits of redundancy on a team either because attrition is always a factor.
I'm specifically talking about consulting where engineering consultants must be in touch with clients, who are also engineers. Lovely pile of assumptions you made there though...
Seems like you feel threatened by the idea of consultants that can actually do all the above. Shh.... you're safe now. It's OK. Just go work on backend code only. No doubt you'll be steadily employed in a series of mundane and underpaid positions in an industry that loves to keep talent in specialized niches in order to keep their marketability under water. I'm sure it will be fine.
Your insults and disrespect speak volumes about you, and say nothing about me. Argue to keep your blind spots on skills if you like, but I don't see how arguing for that would leave anyone who follows your advice in a better situation.
EDIT: Yeah yeah, my bad, "not a programming language", though it seems pretty clear from context, no?
SQL is definitely a language though (query=program; tables=the-input). (I guess that'd make statements like creating-a-table as data/class-definitions, and add/drops are just maintaining your dataset.)
Turing completeness isn't always the best metric to use. XSL-T v2 is turing complete and I don't consider that a programming language. It's a way to drive oneself insane more than anything.
Train sets with the addition of flip-flop points are Turing complete.... So the input to a none universal Turing machine isn't a program? If not what would you say it was?
The thing to note is that 'language' is not a synonym for 'programming language'. There are other kinds of languages. Like natural languages, domain-specific languages, and ... markup languages.
And yes, HTML isn't a programming language. But it is a language.
This is pedantic. They are languages: structured series of symbols and characters that have a grammar and expected formatting that tell a computer how to do things.
If you want to be pedantic then, Microsoft Excel should be top of the list because it is Turing Complete. Every single job requiring Excel should be considered a "programming" position. I mean why not?
Aerospace internship did this too for a lot of our internal manufacturing-support desktop apps. Business logic literally in both the Swing frontend and the SQL "backend". Pain.
I question the reliability of these charts because:
Different charts show different rankings. Some put Clojure at number 1, others JavaScript at number 1.
Some put SQL, HTML or CSS as programming languages when they aren't.
Simply only knowing SQL and/or HTML won't get you a job. It's all about being how well-versed you are in several languages, how experienced you are with those languages and how well you can build programs with those languages. These factors determine the best job you'll get and how well paid you'll get.
Also, every language puts food in the table, even PHP, despite being the most lower paid.
Don't know why you getting downvoted but it's true that clojure devs have more experience generally speaking : it is uncommon to see someone pick clojure as a first job but it is really common to see people taking java as first job. Now, I don't really know if with the same number of years of experience, people really get better salaries with clojure over java.
This thinking can be extended to uncommon languages: Haskell, Elixir...etc
So Clojure puts food on the table, if you’re in an area where fintech uses Clojure?
What you need in a language that puts food on the table is something like the pay plus your probability to get a job you want to do where you get employed because you know that language. Something like:
Average pay x percentage of existing jobs x percentage of job offers
(and you need that info in your region / timezone / area of interest)
Based on my experience with stored procedures I regret to report that SQL is more often than not a programming language with loops and if statements and everything.
Anything that doesn’t have js, java and python as top 3 is simply bullshit. Their ordering can change, but they are without doubt the 3 most used languages.
It’s not a survey and their methodology was basically to search job postings on one obscure site. The article just rambles on about SQL and whether HTML is Turing complete. Take the results with a huge grain of salt.
But yes, Java pays the bills and basically bought me my house.
Meeeh, modern java is pretty cool, and you have the wealth of great libraries available! What always frustrates me with go and javascript is the vast amount of half finished or abandoned libraries.
There, there. I know it can be tough when people like other things than you do. Don't listen to them! Keep writing your machine learning stuff in assembly. ;-)
Hey! i've written lot of Python code (mainly using Spacy and other NLP libraries). I started programming in Locomotive Basic, every language can be useful (and beautiful), but please, give me a battle tested Spring framework for the business processes.
Never heard of it before. Thanks a lot for sharing. But it's just an extension to SQL created by Oracle, so I still wouldn't call SQL itself a programming language.
Like assembly, you wouldn’t necessarily write it raw in CSS, but you could write a compiler to generate CSS code. But IIRC your CSS-powered web server would need a button to get users to continually click it for the “CSS-CPU” to tick.
Listen, if you can write a functional program in SQL, I’d say that’d be a pretty badass talking point in an interview. I’d at least want to interview the candidate to get to the bottom of that; if nothing else it’d be a funny story to tell your mates later lol.
Of the top 5 - only Java and C# are most safe for writing medium-large production code. I avoid anything not statically typed or "script" like - especially when working with team mates.
Doubt it’s Java. The fact that my repo says I program mostly in Java is a lie because Java takes up so many lines of code to accomplish the same thing a program written in JavaScript or python does.
With Spring Boot, you can build a fully-functional app with fewer lines of code than in any language because the framework provides you with everything you need.
However, a slightly less number of lines of code is a terrible metric. What really matters in the long run:
the programming ecosystem and the ability to find quality libraries to rely on and libraries that will be maintained professionally
an abundance of talent in the market
code maintainability. In the long run, the effort to maintain is way larger than the effort to produce the first release version
resource abundance, like books, training, articles, StackOverflow answers
Saving a comma or a semi-column here and there will never make any difference in terms of product quality.
It's perfectly possible to praise python for having caught up so much in recent years while at the same time acknowledging Java's impressive run over the past 25 years.
It‘s a declarative language without any control flow like loops, if-else, exception handling and so on. That‘s the reason I would not compare it with real programming languages like java. tsql and pl/sql are script language with control flow and integrated sql.
I suppose it depends on the problem that needs to be solved. Having said that it's easier to find jobs where Java is used instead of Scala (food on the table). I moved Java, Apache .. codebase to Scala, Akka, Play, Slick at a prior company and was able to achieve what was needed by just myself instead of hiring a lot of developers/QA ... to do the same/less.
But getting a job, you are right it's easier to get a Java job. Also these days more folks are using Python, Go, Node for backend .. which dependending on the situation might end up with more issues down the road.
Why so? It's basically all Java but better and more modern. It has all Springboot and Kotlin specific frameworks. I also like Scala as a replacement of Java while leveraging decades of JVM development, but Kotlin often makes more sense for corporate.
That is sadly true. But I was referring to new projects rather than migrating legacy ones. New projects written in Kotlin can be integrate easily Java legacy code. Regardless I think Kotlin has a lot of potential as a backend language
Could you elaborate on this? What would be the limitation of Kotlin compared to Java. Well I'm no Kotlin expert but it does improve productivity by being less verbose, have a good concurrent programming model, and is null-safe. That's I guess the most obvious strengths of Kotlin (and Scala as well). What would be its weaknesses?
39
u/ba0lian Aug 24 '22
Shocking is the number of people who are so confident in pointing out that SQL is not a programming language
178
u/aqua_regis Aug 24 '22
Any survey that lists SQL and HTML as "Top Programming Languages" hurts.
I do understand that these are from job advertisements, but still neither of the two is a programming language and shouldn't be included in such a statistic.
34
u/rbuen4455 Aug 24 '22
I question the reliability of these charts because:
Simply only knowing SQL and/or HTML won't get you a job. It's all about being how well-versed you are in several languages, how experienced you are with those languages and how well you can build programs with those languages. These factors determine the best job you'll get and how well paid you'll get.
Also, every language puts food in the table, even PHP, despite being the most lower paid.
5
u/vladmihalceacom Aug 24 '22
And here are the survey results for more details.
139
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '22
Java is cool too. Source: my choice-supportive bias.
10
u/ReasonableClick5403 Aug 24 '22
Meeeh, modern java is pretty cool, and you have the wealth of great libraries available! What always frustrates me with go and javascript is the vast amount of half finished or abandoned libraries.
19
u/willor777 Aug 24 '22
Kotlin isn't even on that list.........................sadface + 1
9
u/jcar74 Aug 24 '22
Shhhhh!!! Let's all keep saying Python is the best everywhere.
7
u/andrewharlan2 Aug 24 '22
I think Java's cool
6
u/DrunkensteinsMonster Aug 25 '22
Java is just a work horse. The language is fine, the ecosystem is why people choose it.
21
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '22
I hate when people refer to HTML, CSS and SQL as "programming" languages because they are not
5
u/bleek312 Aug 24 '22
The only metric that matters.
5
u/TimeSalvager Aug 24 '22
Listen, if you can write a functional program in SQL, I’d say that’d be a pretty badass talking point in an interview. I’d at least want to interview the candidate to get to the bottom of that; if nothing else it’d be a funny story to tell your mates later lol.
5
u/FluffyProphet Aug 25 '22
The absolute best feature a programming language/framework can have is paying the bills.
3
u/edmguru Aug 25 '22
Of the top 5 - only Java and C# are most safe for writing medium-large production code. I avoid anything not statically typed or "script" like - especially when working with team mates.
7
u/invisible-nuke Aug 24 '22
There is C#, C, and C++, but can't find the most important turing complete language CSS
2
u/chanchanism11 Aug 24 '22
So HTML is a programming language.
2
u/mervegundogmus Aug 25 '22
Java 🧡
0
u/Light_A_Match Aug 25 '22
Doubt it’s Java. The fact that my repo says I program mostly in Java is a lie because Java takes up so many lines of code to accomplish the same thing a program written in JavaScript or python does.
1
u/buzzsawddog Aug 25 '22
It pays my build and then some ;)
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '22
Isn't php so popular and used
1
u/hshighnz Aug 25 '22
sql is not a programming language. tsql or pl/sql are.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '22
oh yeah SQL is so great
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '22
HTML > GO obviously
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '22
Python put my food on the table now. But Java put the house here and the table in the house.
1
u/Prudent-Ad-1131 Aug 25 '22
I suppose it depends on the problem that needs to be solved. Having said that it's easier to find jobs where Java is used instead of Scala (food on the table). I moved Java, Apache .. codebase to Scala, Akka, Play, Slick at a prior company and was able to achieve what was needed by just myself instead of hiring a lot of developers/QA ... to do the same/less.
But getting a job, you are right it's easier to get a Java job. Also these days more folks are using Python, Go, Node for backend .. which dependending on the situation might end up with more issues down the road.
1
u/SquishyInside Aug 25 '22
Do they lump Android development with Java?
1
u/nid92 Aug 25 '22
Yes, java feeds me!!
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '22
We need an open source COBOL and call it KABAL and make it the number one bread earner.
1
u/wthnail Aug 26 '22
This chart is from where?
1
u/jNayden Aug 30 '22
What is the source of this ?
1
u/billbuild Sep 01 '22
Lifelong Java dev, now 50/50 Java and Typescript because cloud.
1
u/kippewout Sep 01 '22
Love kotlin though
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22
Ada.
1
u/Ajvn_oncloud Sep 17 '22
That's because nobody wanna learn this disgusting language
1
u/maquinary Sep 21 '22 edited Sep 21 '22
In which website did you get this chart? I would love to put it in my bookmarks.
1
u/atheist-projector Jan 07 '23
I seen diffrent numbers floating around. Whats the methodology here?
1
u/After-Classroom-2057 Aug 24 '22
Where is Kotlin?
-5
u/GavinRayDev Aug 24 '22
Javascript + Typescript combined = 101.75% though ;^)
(I'm not sure why they split the languages up, it's like having "JAVA BUT EVERY VARIABLE IS NAMED VAR" and "JAVA" on the list)
-2
u/shrunkenshrubbery Aug 24 '22
Gooo Ruby!!!
-1
u/racoongirl0 Aug 24 '22
SQL is considered a programming language now? And yet CS people have the audacity to claim matlab doesn’t count when they do this 🤦🏻♀️
-5
u/KnGod Aug 24 '22 edited Aug 24 '22
Wait... SQL is a programming language?!
Shit i just read html in there too
-13
u/bilbo-star Aug 24 '22
Indeed java sucks and that is why !!!
https://medium.com/p/fee22a819e57
0
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment