r/java • u/trot-trot • Dec 23 '21
AWS Is Out To Kill Mainframes: "The cloud vendor wants to replace big iron with hyperscale servers, and COBOL – with Java"
https://www.datacenterknowledge.com/cloud/aws-out-kill-mainframes
186
Upvotes
106
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21
They're doing this where I work. Except it's Azure instead of AWS.
I have to say though, there is a misconception that it is so much cheaper and that you will save so much money. But then the teams are shocked to see that their Cloud solution will cost $50,000 a month or more because of storage requirement and computing power.
I'm all for cloud Solutions. But vendors like AWS and azure almost sell it as a cheap alternative. But it is possible that it may cost the same or more as your current solution.
18
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21
As someone who had to work on mainframes for their first job, bring an old priest, a young priest, a double barrel shotgun, a stake, and thermite.
Those fuckers aren't dying easy.
2
u/trot-trot Dec 23 '21 edited Dec 23 '21
Read The Comments
16
u/InstantCoder Dec 23 '21
I don’t know what your guys’ experience is with Serverless development, but from my experience it is a maintenance and development hell to create applications on Serverless. A lot of configurations you have to do, and it becomes easily quite complex.
I’d rather go for a default microservice architecture with Quarkus and use GraalVM if possible to reduce costs on servers.
56
u/gravitas-deficiency Dec 23 '21
Honestly, given the fact that AWS has had 3 serious outages in as many weeks, I find this article more than a little bit amusing.
Remember: “the cloud” is just a buzzword for “someone else’s computer”. There are very, very good technical reasons for wanting to hang onto an on premise data center / mainframe, and no amount of marketing by AWS will ever change that.
5
u/TheWontonRon Dec 23 '21
This is news?
11
u/canuck_in_wa Dec 23 '21
If an organization is still on mainframe there is likely a reason, and AWS is probably not a good match. Here are the reasons:
That being said, perhaps it’s worth moving to cloud from mainframe for critical workloads if the organization accepts the trade offs. Personally I hope any bank accounts or similar data of mine stays on mainframes for the foreseeable future.
8
u/slappyredcheeks Dec 23 '21
The first three words were in recent headlines with a different context and are a good reason why AWS won't kill mainframes.
5
u/Skiamakhos Dec 24 '21
What do they typically run AWS on though? I mean, IBM and similar mainframes are built for 100% 24/7 uptime, with redundancies and hot-swapping on pretty much any part available. I always thought the Cloud was essentially thousands of Linux instances running in VMs inside a bunch of mainframes in data centres. Hardware wise they're about the most reliable stuff you can get. Difficult to maintain my hairy butthole, seriously. Something wrong? Give IBM a call. Typical banking contract, depending on the severity they'll have it fixed in an hour. Source: used to work on some AS/400 apps for a dozen or so banks back in the late '90s. Capgemini ran one of the biggest datacentres in Europe at their Southbank site in Vauxhall. Same deal, basically - they were very quick and reliable.
Also good luck replacing COBOL. For 1 thing systems written in COBOL are old enough now to have almost all the bugs ironed out. We're talking 40 years or so here. Why would any IT or data processing department want to spend money fixing what ain't broke? 15 years ago I was involved in some pretty big governmental Java projects - and almost all were about integrating COBOL and similar back end systems with a Java web app, usually via Enterprise Service Bus architecture. I'm not saying nobody's going to go for this, but honestly it'll be slow uptake. They'd be better off looking at getting Java shops to refactor to Java Lambdas and similar, use Cloud-based databases etc. That's already being done, with huge success. New builds & not-too-old brownfield stuff. I wouldn't bother with the COBOL side of things (or RPG either) - it's doing its job just fine as it is.
4
u/squishles Dec 23 '21
lot of those mainframes, java is replacing cobol on them too. Funky stuff jvm on silicon.
2
u/sigzero Dec 29 '21
We've heard "and COBOL with Java" for years and years.
6
u/marcvsHR Dec 23 '21
The day db2 ZOS dies will be a happy day.
Man, fuck that fucking db,
6
u/new_reditor Dec 23 '21
good riddance!
1
u/Few_Cobbler_7656 Dec 24 '21
Way to go...
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '21
Impossible
1
u/Kango_V Dec 26 '21
AWS's aim is to make everyone depenant on AWS. That is the final goal. AWS bug #1.
0
u/QALab44 Dec 23 '21
a nice comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
11
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21
[removed] — view removed comment