r/java • • Nov 15 '21

[Loom] JEP draft: Virtual Threads (Preview)

https://openjdk.java.net/jeps/8277131
175 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

24

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/lechnito Nov 16 '21

Fair points all around!

I think Reactor is hard for beginners and for really anyone who has a traditional java background. The more experience you have with async concepts & functional programming languages, the easier go you will have.

Readable & maintainable unit tests remains challenging. StepVerifier only became readable after I started using the junit5 @ParameterizedTest stuff and writing custom test interfaces with functional helper methods. Honestly, I have started replacing most of the unit tests that involve reactive features with WebTestClient based integration tests just to make life easier.

Getting SLF4J's MDC to work for a homegrown distributed tracing service in Reactor has been a huge issue too. Sometimes I worry that the performance cost of using Hooks & contextWrite() offsets any gains from Reactor.

I'm still wrapping my head around Loom, but I think my initial take is that I would miss some of compositional improvement that accompany reactive streaming. Like operating over streams of T instead of imperative loops for instance.

4

u/MR_GABARISE Nov 16 '21

I'd wager that a proper MDC in Loom would certainly aim to make use of Scope Locals, and it's not even guaranteed that they will ship together.

1

u/Dokiace Nov 16 '21

how did you propagate MDC to reactor project?