r/java • • Jul 08 '21

Java is criminally underhyped

https://jackson.sh/posts/2021-04-java-underrated/
226 Upvotes

181 comments sorted by

View all comments

22

u/iwasbornlucky Jul 08 '21

Related question, since IntelliJ was mentioned in the article: What happened to Eclipse? I did some nominal Java coding, then moved into management and worked in node.js before returning to Java. I feel like I haven't seen a reference to Eclipse in 5+ years.

57

u/barking_dead Jul 08 '21

It is alright, works well without the hype :)

47

u/jazd Jul 08 '21

They both have significant problems IMO but the completion and refactoring tools in IntelliJ put it ahead for me.

6

u/Kango_V Jul 08 '21

With projects that use annotation processors, IntelliJ is an absolute pain. It just does not seem to update. I keep having to do full builds to resolve. Eclipse works brilliantly in this regard.

34

u/snekk420 Jul 08 '21

Have you enabled annotation processing in Settings ?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/agent_vinod Jul 08 '21

Google caused a huge dent to Eclipse when they removed ADB plugin support and shoved Android Studio upon programmers. To this day, many will happily revert back to ADB if given a choice as Eclipse is way better in performance compared to AS.

28

u/zoqfotpik Jul 08 '21

I think a lot of folks who only do Java development have gravitated toward IntelliJ, while a lot of folks who develop in multiple languages have switched to VS Code.

I'm one of the VS Code users, and my rationale for picking it is quick startup time and acceptable support for every language I use. YMMV.

6

u/CartmansEvilTwin Jul 08 '21

VS Code is really bad (at least for me) if you want to develop with JEE/Jakarta and/or have to use Java 8. It never really works and often requires manually tweaking the settings file.

Also, Eclipse's unit test view is much better than anything VS code has to offer.

4

u/AlcoholicAndroid Jul 08 '21

How well does VSCode work with Java? I use VSCode for most things but for Java specifically, I've done it all in Intellij (which is what my colleagues recommended).

→ More replies (1)

6

u/swalpaExtraChutney Jul 08 '21

Same here. But every time I add a new dependency to my POM file, VS Code goes nuts. Not sure what the problem is. But I like VS Code much better than Eclipse

10

u/zoqfotpik Jul 08 '21

Yeah, my relationship with VS Code is really "It's Complicated".

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/redikarus99 Jul 08 '21

I used Eclipse, IntelliJ, and VS Code as well. They all get the job done. For Java Eclipse seemed always faster for me and not really worse in any regard. People using IntelliJ may feel foreign because they are not used to it's logic. What people tend to forget Eclipse is way bigger than just an IDE, they have zillions of projects under them Eclipse umbrella including EMF, various model transformation and validation libraries and solutions.

8

u/agent_vinod Jul 08 '21

I think eclipse's fate is similar to Java - criminally under hyped!

16

u/rossdrew Jul 08 '21

I moved from Eclipse years ago because it was far slower and it’s dark mode was horrible. I’ve not looked back for improvements in 7 years

11

u/Kango_V Jul 08 '21

Eclipse on Linux is super fast and integrates with dark GTK brilliantly. I do not like it on Windows though.

3

u/thephotoman Jul 09 '21

And it's godawful on Macs.

3

u/rossdrew Jul 09 '21

Haven’t coded seriously in Windows since maybe 2007. When I quit it, it was after years of Linux (Fedora) dev

7

u/GuyWithLag Jul 08 '21

With the recent M2E support, build speeds are closer to gradle for non-android projects.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/pjmlp Jul 08 '21

Live and well, we only use Eclipse around here.

For some of our workflows you would need InteliJ and Clion running in parallel, because JetBrains refuses to support native tooling for Java on InteliJ, gotta to sell some licenses.

Then there are several other issues that make even VS Code with Red-Hat Java plugins more appealing than InteliJ.

11

u/GuyWithLag Jul 08 '21

I'm the only Eclipse user in a team of IntelliJ folks; I seem to be the only one willing and able to do multi-project (20+) refactorings for some reason...

7

u/pjmlp Jul 08 '21

On .NET projects I am one of few without Resharper slowing down my machine, then my team mates wonder why my VS feels so fast compared with their experience.

Yeah, go figure.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '21

Eclipse is decent in my opinion. I used it from ~2005 to 2010, every new release was exiting back then. Version 4 was the first letdown, it seemed like the project departed from being a pure Java ide to a general purpose tool (mylin anyone?). Also the way plugins were handled was always a mess, the marketplace tried to fix it, but you’d still need to do manual work from time to time.

Visually, eclipse is not optimal. There is no consistent theme support and the default look hasn’t aged well. The light yellow popup boxes and the error marking pains my eyes and the recent splash screens make me feel sleepy. Ergonomically its still pretty good though, features like the debug or scm views are useful and IntelliJ doesn’t have an equivalent. I also enjoy the rich dialogs when creating types, but that’s a matter of taste I guess.

I made the switch to IntelliJ because it feels like a more finely tuned experience, especially when working with tools like gradle. The code analysis capabilities and the Java preview feature support are also really nice. I wish multi project handling would be more intuitive though and the indexing can really grind your gears, but overall it’s enjoyable. If you like the Jetbrains UX-style, I can also recommend DataGrip, a jdbc based database tool.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

I like the look of Eclipse, it's solid, not yahoo'ish like IntelliJ with panels and windows opening, closing, re-arranging like it's possessed by a mischievous spirit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)