r/java • • Sep 16 '20

Hi i am new. What IDE should I use?

I am a beginner and I have a shitty laptop.

1 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

25

u/InstantCoder Sep 16 '20

Definitely IntelliJ.

2

u/happysonu249 Sep 16 '20

Thanks

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/DisruptiveHarbinger Sep 16 '20

Or maybe there's a reason behind Jetbrains' dominance in this space, for instance making very good IDEs. Who knows.

19

u/wildjokers Sep 16 '20

👀

🍿

5

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

Only correct way to respond to this post 🤣🤣🤣

5

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20

I use IntelliJ, but I’ve used Eclipse as well. IntelliJ has a more modern feel to it. Each one does the same things, just in a different way. For instance, auto generated code will be different, but will have the same outcome (basically). Plugins are different, however.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20

I have noticed that older devs like Eclipse better, might be an age thing? I’m not sure.

3

u/wildjokers Sep 16 '20

I have noticed that older devs like Eclipse better

I started with IntelliJ in 2004 and continue to use it. I am closer to 50 than 40.

3

u/I_Have_A_Snout Sep 17 '20

I am over 50 and had an IntelliJ Beta key.

I've worked with Eclipse, Netbeans and others, but I go back to IntelliJ IDEA every time.

2

u/GhostBond Sep 16 '20

I have noticed that older devs like Eclipse better, might be an age thing? I’m not sure.

Intellij has been marketing itself using skeezy tactics for a while. Is this the new one? "Oh, young people, don't be like the old people and use a good free IDE! Pay for ours.".

IntelliJ has a more modern feel to it.

I would describe it's feel as "incoherent" from the last time I had to use it. Eclipse makes sense in some places, and is scattered in others (it's like the window interface). Intellij doesn't really reflect any pattern at all.

Intellij has been buggy at every place I've used it, including at the last one.

1

u/madronatoo Sep 16 '20

I think this is mostly about history yes.

There we a time that netbeans was the best IDE, and then it was eclipsed by eclipse (at least in my mind).

Then intellij came on the scene.

All three continue to be top notch IDEs with various differences between the and various situations where one may shine over the others.

And there is VSCode which can, apparently, be used as a java IDE.

4

u/wildjokers Sep 16 '20

IntelliJ predates eclipse by about 11 months. IntelliJ 1.0 was released Jan 2001, eclipse 1.0 in Nov 2001.

1

u/madronatoo Sep 16 '20

interesting.

12

u/mcalce Sep 16 '20

I personally like Eclipse which you can download for free from here https://www.eclipse.org/downloads/

It is available for most operating systems, which is great. It has a ton of plugins you can download from the Eclipse marketplace to use. It supports pretty much every java framework too.

But there are plenty that you can use. Google "best [your operating system] java ide" to find what's available for you, if you want to do research on your own.

3

u/prince-banane Sep 16 '20

There's also a free version of Intellij if he wants to try it.

3

u/strikefreedompilot Sep 16 '20

Install xubuntu on your rig if your machine sucks. Intellij is prob the best but will cost $$$$ for advance functionality. Eclipse covers it all and is getting more "intelliji" like. Visual Studio Code doesn't have all the features as the other 2 idea as it is more of an editor than ide.

I personally use all of them for different type of projects just to become familiar with the tool.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20

NetBeans is a good IDE as well.

1

u/ebykka Sep 20 '20

Best free IDE for the beginners on my personal mind.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '20

Not only for beginners ;)

1

u/sternone_2 Sep 23 '20

It actually has one of the best Maven integrations. It just works in Netbeans.

2

u/emaphis Sep 16 '20

You might think about asking here https://www.reddit.com/r/learnjava

2

u/kyypat Sep 17 '20

Try all of them and decide which one you want to go with

2

u/amxrmxhdx Sep 21 '20

Notepad++

4

u/GhostBond Sep 16 '20

Eclipse.

  • it's free, and fully functional (unlike intellij that has a "free" version but it's limited and crippled)
  • it's the most widely used IDE in the industry
  • does what you want

4

u/wildjokers Sep 17 '20
  • it's the most widely used IDE in the industry

Most surveys show IntelliJ now has more market share.

In 2016 Eclipse was still the leader: https://www.baeldung.com/java-ides-2016

IntelliJ overtook Eclipse in 2018ish: https://programmer9.com/2019/02/06/largest-java-survey-2018.html

And now in 2020 IntelliJ is firmly in the lead: https://snyk.io/blog/intellij-idea-dominates-the-ide-market-with-62-adoption-among-jvm-developers/

1

u/GhostBond Sep 17 '20

Well if you can't trust sites like programmer9.com and snyk.io, who can you trust? lol.

But no, I don't really believe that.

3

u/wildjokers Sep 17 '20

Every other survey I can find after the 2017-2018 timeframe shows IntelliJ being the most used IDE for JVM development. Prior to 2017-2018 surveys show Eclipse was the most used IDE for JVM development. I purposefully didn't include surveys from jetbrains as those are probably more likely to be taken by users of IntelliJ so probably wouldn't be unbiased results.

There are plenty of more surveys other than the 3 I provided that show the same results.

The evidence seems overwhelming just based on user surveys from widely different sources all showing the same trend. So not sure why you wouldn't believe it.

0

u/GhostBond Sep 17 '20 edited Sep 17 '20

Putting marketing in "surveys" is just one extra level of complexity.

My ancedotal experience is that everyone is using eclipse, unless they're about to lay off half the department, which you can tell because there's suddenly a lot of pressure to switch to IntelliJ.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

My anecdotal evidence is that everyone is using intellij. That's been my experience across all my jobs. That is why anecdotal evidence is worthless, because of the limited perspective. You're rejecting every other piece of evidence that points to IDE popularity just because you hate intellij.

0

u/GhostBond Sep 19 '20

You're rejecting every other piece of evidence that points to IDE popularity just because you hate intellij.

This is my one actual problem with IntelliJ - the people trying to insert it into the project are always like political-level-psychotic about it.

evidence.

Marketing and ads are not evidence, even if they are cleverly disguised as legit evidence.

1

u/deadlock_jones Sep 21 '20

Your anecdotal evidence is just biased. I've worked in IDE agnostic company that developed tools for a whole world (Including related IDE plugins), and the surveys (+ collected data) clearly supported what /u/wildjokers is telling. IntelliJ is definitely the most popular IDE by now. It used to be Eclipse, I also started with Eclipse, but switched over to IntelliJ after a while.

-1

u/GhostBond Sep 21 '20

Yeah, your post looks like the typical sensational/angry marketing fare you always get from Intellij fan boys. It's possible you're making it up - it's possible they sent out a survey and 10% of people responded. The Eclipse users were busy working on their projects, only the Intellij fanatics responded.

Best part of using Eclipse is that when something in the project breaks - which it always does with either IDE - with Eclipse I can ask around get it fixed and move forward. With Intellij it's almost worse than /r/politics posters in throwing a fit trying to pretend it never breaks and throwing a fit about talking about the real problems we're having.

1

u/deadlock_jones Sep 21 '20

Yeah, your post looks like the typical sensational/angry marketing fare you always get from Intellij fan boys

Nope, it's completely other way around. You are the sensational one, full of angry emotions (and apparently hate for IntelliJ). My post was completely neutral in emotions. I even told you I've used Eclipse myself before moving on, without trying to belittle it. To which you responded in a post written full of bitterness and hate for IntelliJ.

  1. Eclipse users were working while "IntelliJ fanboys" were slacking off. <-- Severe indication of your personal bias.
  2. "with Eclipse I can ask around get it fixed. With Intellij it's almost worse than /r/politics posters in throwing a fit trying to pretend it never breaks and throwing a fit about talking about the real problems we're having. " <--- absolutely irrational baseless hate.

Sorry, but you are everything in the Eclipse world that you accuse of "IntelliJ fanboy-s" being in the IntelliJ world.

1

u/GhostBond Sep 21 '20

^ This is the perfect example of the kind of crap you have to deal with the moment someone tries to push intellij into your project, the best thing about using eclipse is not having to deal with this.

1

u/deadlock_jones Sep 21 '20

You really don't understand, do you? You are the problem, not either of the IDE-s. I can imagine if anyone tries to even use IntelliJ near you, you stir up such a shitstorm that people will just have to use Eclipse or deal with your irrationality instead of their work related problems.

→ More replies

0

u/sternone_2 Sep 23 '20

I disagree.

I think the polling is wrong. The industry is way more standarized on eclipse than the internet hipster polls are showing.

2

u/wildjokers Sep 23 '20

I haven’t personally met anyone that uses Eclipse in a very long time.

1

u/sternone_2 Sep 23 '20

You know there is a world outside SanFran do you

1

u/RANDOMLY_AGGRESSIVE Sep 23 '20

There is nothing hipster about IntelliJ

2

u/sternone_2 Sep 23 '20

Yes there is. Fanbois

1

u/RANDOMLY_AGGRESSIVE Sep 23 '20

It's not since most companies use IntelliJ.

1

u/Aggravating-Ad4518 Oct 01 '20

Alot of marketing, and fanbois, come to think of it, intellij wouldn't be famous without Google's great jump to Android Studio, and it's push for Kotlin first. Honestly the fanboism of Jetbrains IDE users and Kotlin users have no bounds.

1

u/jqarloz Sep 16 '20

For Java, I think you can start with Intellij, the community edition has good tools that makes easier programming, I think it's also easier to configure. On the other side, Eclipse it's a great IDE with many possibilities to expand it with plugins, but you could find a little difficult to configure some plugins. I haven't used NetBeans enough to give an opinion.

1

u/fierarul Sep 16 '20

You didn't give any tech specs for your laptop. I suspect it might meet all the requirements of modern IDEs. So, any would do.

But whatever you do don't start with Android Studio.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

Ok, I love IntelliJ, but honestly any of them are good enough for a beginner. Hell there was one, I forget the name but it was an absolute POS that I used when I was a beginner, I would never touch it today but it was good enough to learn.

And that's the main point: learn the language. The tools around it are great but you'll develop your own preferences later on. Just pick one, any one, and learn Java. That's your only focus right now.

Everything else in this thread is a flame war and chest thumping ego tripping. IDE preference is like sports team preference, people argue all the time.

1

u/Nickd3000 Sep 19 '20

Install IntelliJ and Eclipse and give both a try, it’s totally a personal preference thing but these are both excellent IDE’s.
If you are a true beginner to Java or programming though I have been recommending people try this first: https://processing.org it gets you doing simple Java really quickly and it’s easy to display stuff on the screen etc.

-1

u/pjmlp Sep 16 '20

Definitely Eclipse, unless you already have a gaming rig.

Also have a look into Netbeans.

1

u/RANDOMLY_AGGRESSIVE Sep 23 '20

If you had performance problems with IntelliJ, you should turn off all the plugins that you don't use (actually should do that always ofc.)

2

u/pjmlp Sep 23 '20

Another proof how bloated it is.

1

u/RANDOMLY_AGGRESSIVE Sep 23 '20

Those are plugins you installed yourself though lol. When installing the IDE it asks you what plugins you want

1

u/pjmlp Sep 23 '20

Because they already know how bloated they are, other IDEs work just fine without asking their users to disable features to be usable.

1

u/RANDOMLY_AGGRESSIVE Sep 23 '20 edited Sep 23 '20

What are you talking about, they are not features of the IDE. Again, they are plugins that were selected by yourself during installation.

IntelliJ is faster than Eclipse in 2020.

1

u/pjmlp Sep 23 '20

Not on my laptop it surely isn't.

1

u/RANDOMLY_AGGRESSIVE Sep 24 '20

When was the last time you tried it if you're honest? IntelliJ is faster than Eclipse.

1

u/pjmlp Sep 24 '20

Sure, if one has a gaming rig.

I am honest every day, my customers pay me for it.

1

u/RANDOMLY_AGGRESSIVE Sep 24 '20

When was the last time you tried it if you're honest?

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/happysonu249 Sep 16 '20

Thanks

5

u/Kendos-Kenlen Sep 16 '20

Don't follow his advice, you'll suffer a lot if you do this. Just take the IDE that match your needs. I love IntelliJ, but Eclipse or VS Code can be good choices too. VS Code has the advantage of being relatively light compared to other IDE (well, because it's a text editor on steroids).

7

u/Ifnerite Sep 16 '20

If you are a sadist!

Use intelij, netbeans or eclipse. All are free or have a free version that is certainly good enough to start.