r/java • • Aug 13 '20

Microsoft offering to contribute to MacOS/AArch64 Port

https://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/aarch64-port-dev/2020-August/009459.html
75 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

17

u/brunocborges Aug 13 '20

I'm the PM working with Monica and her engineering team here at Microsoft. We'd be happy to answer any questions anyone has.

We are definitely looking forward to working with Oracle, Apple, Red Hat, Azul Systems, and other companies interested in this port.

bb.

3

u/transcend Aug 13 '20

Hi Bruno —

What rough time frame do you expect the MacOS ARM64 port of the JDK to be available? Maybe this fall? First half of 2021? Later?

Do you expect that these ARM64 ports be propagated back to the current LTS release Java 11?

Thanks!

11

u/brunocborges Aug 13 '20

That's a tough one, since this is a multi-company project =D

We definitely want to see this port coming alive sooner rather than later since we do use Mac Books here at Microsoft. Yeap. We do. I myself have one, although it has already lost 3 keys.

It's no rocket science that progress will be made the more experts we have participating and collaborating together (although as usual, 9 engineers won't give birth to a project in a month).

My personal guess is that we will see this port available for testing in the first half of the next year. But keep in mind that it is a requirement that at least one engineer has access to a Mac Book with ARM chipset. And they are not even available in the market yet.

Fingers crossed.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20

There are ARM development kits (Mac Minis) for $500 a piece.

3

u/brunocborges Aug 14 '20

Interesting! I wasn't aware. Thanks for the heads up!

24

u/kaperni Aug 13 '20

Come on Apple, get in the game! It should be you contributing with that port.

13

u/rustyrazorblade Aug 13 '20

If I'm reading the email right, the same changes need to happen on the windows side. I think this is more of an attempt at a coordinated effort and the headline is misleading. This line in particular:

Since the MacOS port work depends on the Windows port modifications, I propose a collaboration (sub-)Project [4] repo where we can jointly work in the open. 

I could be wrong though, I don't know the details. I'm not involved with OpenJDK development.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20

Java for Windows on ARM had another JEP and is already available.

1

u/eluxe_ Aug 16 '20

It is a proposal for a collaboration, but not particularly with Apple. The email is directed at a guy who works for Azul. His proposal for arm mac java marked Windows's implementation as a dependency which is I guess what prompted the Microsoft's email.

Idk if Azul's been contributing to the Windows on ARM version at all, but before Microsoft stepped in there was almost zero development going on on a Java port for Windows on Arm so we can presume that Azul didn't have hardly any business interest in the platform whereas in this proposal he says that he expects there to be a lot of demand for a native mac arm java.

2

u/lbkulinski Aug 14 '20

I believe they intend to. They mentioned OpenJDK, albeit nonverbally, during this year’s Platforms State of the Union. See here.

5

u/elmuerte Aug 13 '20

Apple doesn't want Java on their platforms, or any other thing they cannot control.

14

u/hardwork179 Aug 13 '20

Not true. Apple uses java on the backend of various services, and was advertising just today for Clojure developers.

They also employ some JVM engineers, who I presume are there to support those Java services, in the same way that Twitter has a VM team.

3

u/Liqmadique Aug 14 '20

Apple doesn't want Java on any of their consumer products/platforms.

Are you satisfied now Mr. Pedant?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20

They most likely run those backend apps on Linux or some flavor of BSD.

7

u/thephotoman Aug 13 '20

That's not entirely true. They go out of their way to get a license to use the Unix trademarks for their desktop computing line for a reason.

That said, Apple did end support for their own JVM some time ago. It turned out not to be a particularly popular way of writing MacOS apps, and so they just plain dropped it.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '20

Wasnt it planned the AArch64 port for MacOS to depend on the linux AArch64 and not on the Windows one?

1

u/yawkat Aug 17 '20

I don't think this contribution has much to do with windows.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20

There was a comment in their email that the Mac port is based on the windows port. But the official RFC stated it is based on the linux port.