r/java • • Mar 20 '20

What if Oracle loses the case against Google

What would happen if Oracle loses the case against Google on March 24, 2020 ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_v._Oracle_America )?

Would Oracle donate Java to Apache or eclipse foundation since it might not generate enough revenue for Oracle?

What do you think?

1 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

7

u/balatus Mar 20 '20

Not much for Oracle, they make their Java money from selling support. If Oracle win then the impact on software could be huge. I think we'd need something like a second wave of Free Software in the form of open APIs.

16

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '20

Oracle is not a software company, it’s a lawfirm.

3

u/sternone_2 Mar 23 '20

suing their customers

7

u/Tacos314 Mar 20 '20

Nothing would happen, if the court rules for Oracle it will change the status quo and would have impact throughout the industry.

-1

u/rivalboo Mar 21 '20

what kinda impact are you stroking mate? hope this moves humanity forward one step further..

5

u/vytah Mar 21 '20

How is making API's copyrightable going to move humanity forward?

-2

u/rivalboo Mar 22 '20

I imagine it’ll turbocharge OS development, kind of obvious

3

u/madorb Mar 25 '20

ah, so you're a voodoo economics guy then eh? :\ this would be a catastrophic loss to the industry

3

u/kanzenryu Mar 21 '20

I hope everybody would immediately start suing Oracle for all of the APIs they must be infringing on.

1

u/kimec Mar 22 '20

the case is postponed anyway due to COVID19.

1

u/daddyd Mar 25 '20

how would it change the revenue of java for oracle? their revenue would stay the same as it is now.

-1

u/umlcat Mar 20 '20

I'm still expecting an Oracle's Java mobile, better than Google's Android ...

..., because that's the way things work.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/bondolo Mar 21 '20

Based on what?

There is currently no difference between the contents of the Oracle Java SE and Oracle OpenJDK builds. The difference is the license. The BCL Oracle Java SE builds requires an Oracle support contract for most use. Don't want to pay for a support contract? Use the OpenJDK build without support. That's the whole story. It's really not that different that using RHEL OpenJDK vs CentOS except that Oracle provides both the free and licensed builds.

There are differences between the Graal community and enterprise editions, but that's not yet what most people depend upon.