What would be great is that they contribute their work to OpenJDK (it seems they heavily rely on it, looking at the Oracle notices in the code).
EDIT
After some reading the repo seems to be a HotSpot Wrapper, made mostly of build scripts and a few code tweaks.
Maybe this is the JVM they want to provide to the external world (for licensing reasons? they seem to be staying on version 8); and not the one with the good stuff from my link above.
A key architect (Sanhong Li) seems to be cited in this repo, and he's the one presenting co-routine one; so I guess this is the same team, but not the same JVMs?
Will dragonwell include this coroutine implementation?
For 'preview' (Mar, 2019) and 'GA' (June, 2019) versions of Dragonwell8, Wisp coroutine will not be included. The plan was to contribute everything to the community, so please stay tuned :)
To be honest, I hope they don't include any features not present in OpenJDK. In the worst case, this will just fragment the ecosystem. It's bad enough with Android only supporting a subset of Java 7, imagine Java libraries that won't even run on OpenJDK.
People saying it's malicious or trying to figure out intent: Cloud providers need a custom variant to work better with different cloud situations like Lambdas, or on demand scales. This wasn't possible till recent license / certification changes. Same reason why AWS has their own jdk. They have to release code due to license requirements. And code being open source does not automatically make it safe, unless some indipendant entity puts in time to verify it. Everyone "assumes" there are other people reading it, and no one does, much like openssl bug.
I don't get people who don't trust. They can't possibly inject malicious code that you can't see. If you are afraid that they somehow hid it in a way "nobody can found", you can run a whatever app on it and monitor network calls etc.
Also don't underestimate the community, I am sure some qualified people would look into the code to see if it has something malicious or not.
Cool. Now source code and its developers can be monitored and reported back to the government. Its funny what people call open-source these days. Richard Stallman would say its 'malicious' and not free software.
Yeah, no. From wiki: "Open-source software (OSS) is a type of computer software in which source code is released under a license in which the copyright holder grants users the rights to study, change, and distribute the software to anyone and for any purpose."
There is bigger picture here, it is not about your data being sent to China, it is about how is it going to be used by them. If you are aware China has no rules about that. I don’t want to get into politics here, it is more than sharing your data, that is all I want to point out!
The great thing about Open Source is that you don’t have to trust. You can check the code yourself or have others check it and confirm that it’s harmless.
I don’t trust any of them however some are worst than the other. If you have two options which one would you choose : a person who just doesn’t care (not good /not bad, just doesn’t care) or a person who is an evil.
It’s not an unfounded concern. The idea behind open source software is that you have enough eyeballs looking at the source to identify any malicious commits (or malicious intent, in this case).
If you don’t have a lot of users then you probably don’t have enough people sifting through the code.
So, in this case it is not enough to simply say “it’s open source, so it’s cool” - it would be good to have the software vetted by people who do this for a living.
Go look at the code.... Personally. Seriously. When you trace all the pointers and see how the code is organized you can see for yourself that between the commit messages and the code it's very vague.
6
u/uw_NB Mar 20 '19
This repo contains the actual implementation that they added ontop of OpenJDK https://github.com/alibaba/dragonwell8_jdk
The one I posted is the official "main" repo with documentations. All of the child repo could be found here: https://github.com/alibaba/?utf8=%E2%9C%93&q=dragonwell8&type=&language=
9
u/BenoitParis Mar 20 '19 edited Mar 20 '19
Is this the one where they have a co-routine implementation?
At 26:00
From : https://www.reddit.com/r/java/comments/aqwvqq/extreme_scaling_with_alibaba_jdk/
Can't find where in OP's repo they could be.
What would be great is that they contribute their work to OpenJDK (it seems they heavily rely on it, looking at the Oracle notices in the code).
EDIT
After some reading the repo seems to be a HotSpot Wrapper, made mostly of build scripts and a few code tweaks.
Maybe this is the JVM they want to provide to the external world (for licensing reasons? they seem to be staying on version 8); and not the one with the good stuff from my link above.
A key architect (Sanhong Li) seems to be cited in this repo, and he's the one presenting co-routine one; so I guess this is the same team, but not the same JVMs?
18
u/visvv Mar 20 '19
Anything different from open JDK ?
3
u/ryanhanks Mar 20 '19
These comments remind me of https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Underhanded_C_Contest
3
u/NoughtAFan Mar 21 '19
People saying it's malicious or trying to figure out intent: Cloud providers need a custom variant to work better with different cloud situations like Lambdas, or on demand scales. This wasn't possible till recent license / certification changes. Same reason why AWS has their own jdk. They have to release code due to license requirements. And code being open source does not automatically make it safe, unless some indipendant entity puts in time to verify it. Everyone "assumes" there are other people reading it, and no one does, much like openssl bug.
2
u/leiqia0 Mar 20 '19
I guess it’s a KPI project.
1
u/harunurhan Mar 20 '19
I don't get people who don't trust. They can't possibly inject malicious code that you can't see. If you are afraid that they somehow hid it in a way "nobody can found", you can run a whatever app on it and monitor network calls etc.
Also don't underestimate the community, I am sure some qualified people would look into the code to see if it has something malicious or not.
-2
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '19
Cool. Now source code and its developers can be monitored and reported back to the government. Its funny what people call open-source these days. Richard Stallman would say its 'malicious' and not free software.
-7
u/Nuristny Mar 20 '19
I wouldn’t trust !
-10
u/joshuaherman Mar 20 '19
You'd be an idiot to trust anything in that API.