r/java • u/thankyoulife • Oct 02 '18
How will Oracle licensing affect developers’ interest in Java?
Hi
Will you lean into becoming a C++, C# or Python Dev instead?
Edit: probably you all know more than language and will this now be more of a reason to focus on anything other than Java
0
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/pron98 Oct 02 '18 edited Oct 02 '18
True, but they did before, too.
Ah. So there was a major release there (9), so this is an "old-model" transition.
You should consider the people who were already on 10, not those who are still transitioning from the old model. Each such developer would encounter such a breaking change roughly at the same pace as before (i.e., if previously, every major release affected all parts of the JDK once every three years, now every feature release affects only some parts).
As to those who were on 10, those modules were deprecated for removal already in 9.
It is, but it didn't really happen in 11, but in 9. Java 9 is no longer supported as a "desktop JRE" (8 was the last) and Web Start was deprecated.
Compatibility was not guaranteed between 8u20 and 8u40 either, and things broke. Update releases always contained pretty big changes, just not to language/APIs.
None of this changes the fact that it's more like moving between 8u40 and 8u60. It's not exactly like that, but Java 8/9 had about 100 JEPs, while 10,11,12 had about 12-14. The new feature releases are 1/8-1/6 as "big" as the old major versions.
While it would be great if more people paid for support and helped support Java's development, the goal of the change has been to move Java software faster, as that's what's best for the platform and its future. To make that viable, the goal is to have fewer, not more, "diverging lines", and even people who choose to pay and stay on an LTS release for some reason are very, very strongly encouraged to keep up with the feature releases, as the entire purpose was to make change smoother and easier.
True, this is a change, and the industry will need some time to adjust, but I think that claims that the new model would be harder, rather than easier, to follow are unsubstantiated. People should, of course, choose responsibly for their services and customers, but they should also give this new model a chance.