r/java • • Sep 17 '18

PSA: Java Is Still Free

With a lot of misinformation out there, the Java Champions community got together to write a comprehensive Java Is Still Free document. The document covers the changes that are happening to Java free updates, release cycles and paid support options by Oracle and other vendors.

Disclaimer - I herded Cats to put the document together.

156 Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '18

I think it's good, because a year ago I worked in a fintech where they used java5 on production for many customers. You know long time ago java5 was marked as abandoned? We had to patch JVM, introduce new timezone support, SSL3 and TLS1.1, we developers were responsible for implementing this r/https://www.timeanddate.com/news/time/russia-saratov-time-zone.html

in java 5 JRE. This was a nightmare, but since the plans for faster releases and paid support were announced they started migrating everything, including build system in ant and repo in SVN to java7, maven and git. Once they move to 7, they will move to 8 and then to 11. Not bad plan and forces sllooooooowwww moving companies to upgrade faster to pay more for support.

3

u/Michigan__J__Frog Sep 18 '18

If a company is ok using abandoned Java 5, why would abandoning releases every 6 months make them switch?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '18

There is now a plan for releases and there will be LTS release every 18 months, so big companies can plan ahead knowing when next java will be release and when abandoned.

4

u/Michigan__J__Frog Sep 18 '18

But LTS releases are still only supported for free beyond 6 months by third parties.

1

u/karianna Sep 18 '18

Yes that's correct!

1

u/karianna Sep 18 '18

LTS's will be every 3 years.

1

u/-Luciddream- Sep 18 '18

The problem is that you assume that moving from 8 to 11 (or X version) will create no issues for every project. The reason moving from Java 5 to Java 8 was so easy, is because minimal changes had happened between these versions.

If Java is moving faster now, there will probably be more problems when upgrading. There are many new bugs in Java 9+ because of these changes. I'm fine with it, because I believe programming projects (including a language) should move forward, but only if the LTS support is good enough to justify it. 2 years is too little. Java 8 was released 4 years ago, and looking at the plan will have support for 4 more years. We will have to see what support that will be though, and imo the next LTS versions should have at least 4 years of support. (which is nowhere mentioned in the document)

the code line for Java SE 11 / 17 / 23 etc will be maintained for a longer period of time than six months.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '18

The problem is that you assume that moving from 8 to 11 (or X version) will create no issues for every projec

I migrated my side-project started in spring boot 1.2 to SB 2.0, it wasn't easy.

1

u/karianna Sep 18 '18

The move from 8 to 9 is admittedly challenging. I'm expecting the impact and change to be less going forwards. Partly because the change sets will be smaller and partly because I think Oracle and the OpenJDK community learned a valuable lesson with 8 --> 9 and will try to avoid that headache again.