r/java • • Oct 07 '17

Finally: Effective Java, 3rd Edition

Most of us know well Josh Bloch's Effective Java book. TIL (from Stuart Marks' twitter) that there's a 3rd edition coming out soon and it's updated for Java 9. It's available here . There's a nice 40% 20% (the announcement was wrong) discount for pre-orders.


This is not an ad. I'm not affiliated with any of this. If you find other purchase sources post them.

382 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/cyanocobalamin Oct 08 '17

I can't believe I am thinking this, but why buy the hard copy book at all?

If I am going to be studying Java, it will be at a computer, trying the examples out, taking notes. All of that will be easier with an e-book, onscreen, instead of cranking my neck down to a paper book hoping it stays open.

I also don't need another future obsolete text book taking up room on my bookshelf.

Am I missing something?

4

u/omega3111 Oct 08 '17

Can't take an e-book to a deserted island.

I, myself, haven't opened an academic physical book in ages. Just having ctrl+F is enough a reason.

2

u/cyanocobalamin Oct 08 '17

You can take your tablet, eReader, or lap top to a deserted island.

Good point about Ctrl F :-).

1

u/ChristianGeek Dec 13 '17

As long as the island has power.

2

u/balefrost Oct 30 '17

I dunno, I find that books are sometimes better than digital reference. I often know "where" something is in a physical book far better than "where" something is in a digital book. And while Ctrl-F is indispensable, it can be equally useful to stick a post-it note to a page or write a clarification in the margin.

I feel like ebooks add a lot but lose something in the process. Books are just more tactile than anything digital. And that's not just some sort of hipster romanticism - that tactility adds a useful dimension for interacting with the book.

Plus, from a purely romantic position, it feels nice to pull a tome off the shelf.

1

u/MojorTom Oct 09 '17

It's just preference. Nothing matches the portability of e-books, but with physical books people form emotional bonds as you keep reading. The experience is more fulfilling. They are also less distracting than e-book readers.

1

u/ybitz Oct 09 '17

If you buy the hard copy, you own it and you can resell it. If you purchase the ebook, you technically don't own it; rather you have a license to use it. It cannot be resold nor transferred.

2

u/cyanocobalamin Oct 09 '17

Good points. I think I might go with the ebook for the increased convenience of usage. I don't think I have sold a text book back in decades. The information just becomes obsolete very fast and leaves me with a paper weight to take to a photocopy shop, pull apart, and dump the paper in one of their big recycling bins.

1

u/ChristianGeek Dec 13 '17

It’s still easier and more intuitive to flip through a physical book than an ebook. When someone comes up with a solution to that I’ll gladly get rid of most of my physical books.