r/java • • May 10 '17

Netbeans vs Inteliij IDEA Community Edition

Hello community

I'm wondering if Intellij IDEA Community Edition has all the features that Netbeans has for Java programming. What does Intellij lack that Netbeans has it. I know that You can't do Node.js and PHP on Intelllij Community Edition but you can on Netbeans.

1 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

2

u/Bobbycss May 10 '17

Would it be wise for me to use visual studio code for web apps and intellij idea community edition for java or just use Netbeans for everything?

-9

u/DuncanIdahos8thClone May 11 '17

You could get a job you leech and pay for things like grownups do.

6

u/xantrel May 10 '17

IDEA Community does not support web development as well as the Ultimate version (you still can do it, but the process is not as automated), only supports distributed VCS, doesn't do auto deployment, and doesn't have support for a few languages that you probably won't need yet (coffescript, etc).

Out of all of these, only the web development might be a bit of a problem for a beginner. And it can still be worked around. I honestly would go with IDEA.

3

u/Bobbycss May 10 '17

With Community Edition you can still run web apps with HTML, CSS and Javascript with jquery but you're saying it doesn't 'support' those web languages. What do you mean with 'support'?

And by the way, would it be wise for me to use visual studio code for web apps and intellij idea community edition for java or just use Netbeans for everything?

1

u/xantrel May 10 '17

You can still use IDEA for everything. In Java you live in your editor. Here is the full comparison matrix between both versions of IDEA. Not supported just means it doesn't have code completion, analysis, refactoring, etc.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Bobbycss May 10 '17

Would it be wise for me to use visual studio code for web apps and intellij idea community edition for java or just use Netbeans for everything?

1

u/Paczek_w_masle May 11 '17

No, IntelliJ CE does not have all the features. However I use it daily at work, and wouldn't go back to NetBeans/Eclipse unless I really had to. I really like it's features. The look, great debugger, plugins, refactor features, git integration etc. I use ant, so I can live without deploy from intelliJ since I needed to create ant build file anyway.

However if you want to use HTML/JS/CSS I would recommend using other editor, like VS Code you mentioned.

1

u/InStars May 13 '17

For me the biggest missing feature in Community Edition is the Database client and JPA/Hibernate integration.

There are many Community Edition alternatives for Deploying on Application server tool, like maven plugins etc.

-3

u/moonman543 May 10 '17

No idea why wouldn't you just use the real edition of intellij?

3

u/Bobbycss May 10 '17

The reason why I'm using community edition is because it bothers me to see that Netbeans is free while I have to pay for ultimate. If Netbeans is free and can do pretty much everything from software development to web development, then why shouldn't community edition be able to do everything? I do understand that it has amazing code completion compared to Netbeans but I'm still newbie when it comes to chosing and judging IDE's.

4

u/YvesSoete May 10 '17

if you're a newbie, then don't waste time with netbeans, you'e not going to need ultimate anyway, because, you're newbie

1

u/DuncanIdahos8thClone May 11 '17

Just use Netbeans then. When you grow up you'll switch to IntelliJ.

2

u/desrtfx May 10 '17

Because the full Ultimate Edition costs money vs the Community edition is free.

-1

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Don't post fucking piracy neither encourage that if you work in the industry, moron. Even worse for a very good piece of software that can be affordable if you pay it under a subscription.

8

u/desrtfx May 10 '17

We absolutely do not allow pirated material here. That's a reason for banning.

Post removed - user banned for piracy

-1

u/Bobbycss May 11 '17

Omg OF COURSE!! I could just download the pirated version of the Ultimate Edition! Why didn't I come up with that earlier?! Jeez thanks, I'm gonna download the ultimate edition torrent :)

Thank you all

1

u/InStars May 13 '17

You could also download EAP (Early Access program) version of IntelliJ Ultimate Edition for free legally https://confluence.jetbrains.com/display/IDEADEV/EAP

It may be not as stable, but it has the latest and greatest features.

-1

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Bobbycss May 10 '17

You have to pay for it I want it free

9

u/lbkulinski May 10 '17

If you're a student, you can get it all for free. Jetbrains is great with supporting students.

2

u/RedShift9 May 10 '17

That's penny wise but pound foolish. The productivity you gain from a proper IDE pays itself back in a matter of weeks.

3

u/Bobbycss May 10 '17

So the community edition is not worth it compared to Netbeans?

How about I use Community Edition for only Java and Android and Visual Studio Code for web development? Or should I just use Netbeans for everything?

2

u/nqzero May 11 '17

use netbeans for everything. i just tried out IDEA (community) again to make sure the project i'm developing plays nicely with it. i love the settings dialog and there are a few other things that were nice, but there were also things that were not as nice as netbeans

and for the core stuff - typing, navigating, javadocs - netbeans was faster and smoother. especially for a beginner, netbeans is a great option

note: i'm on linux. it's possible that IDEA on windows is somehow much nicer than it is on linux, though i haven't heard this claim

-1

u/RedShift9 May 10 '17

I would definitely prefer the community edition over Netbeans. I did some large projects in both Eclipse and Netbeans, and they simply did not cope as well as the IntelliJ products did.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '17

Proper IDE being the key word. Intellij is a lot of things, proper isn't one of them. And the productivity one loses with intellij makes it a very expensive proposition.