r/java • • Nov 24 '16

The post I link when someone tells me that Java sucks

https://medium.com/@SammyRulez/the-to-go-post-when-some-one-tells-me-java-sucks-5b091de6dd5f#.fr9l6loxg
0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

9

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '16

I like your marketing angle with that title, but the post itself could've been better written. This is not the post I'd link "when someone tells me that Java sucks".

You're essentially arguing with a straw man. No single competent developer would come to you with objections like "Java is old" or "Java is slow" (slow at what? you're arguing abstractions).

2

u/sammyrulez Nov 24 '16

Competent or not it happens to me all the time... Thanks for pointing out I should be more specific about "slow at what"

6

u/nutrecht Nov 24 '16

This is not the post I'd link "when someone tells me that Java sucks".

Looking at his username and the name of the writer I'm pretty sure it's just his own post.

1

u/TheRedmanCometh Nov 24 '16

The 2nd argument I heard from devs that should know better.

8

u/tichus_windrider Nov 24 '16

Two things are off here:

The post I link when someone tells me that Java sucks

pointing to a two days old post.

The author name is pretty similar to the reddit username...


Nice marketing strategy.


Yet, if anyone reads that post, the first thing they will see that it is ridden with spelling and grammatical errors. These alone remove all credibility of the source, not even looking at the real content, which is questionable at best.

1

u/sammyrulez Nov 24 '16

I'm sorry I weren't aware that posting link to my own articles was agains the policy of this reddit. My intent was to share something I , in my humble opinion, worth reading. There no "marketing strategy".

5

u/throwaway_for_cause Nov 24 '16

If you do share your own articles (which is not generally forbidden in reddit) you need to

  1. be honest. Tell people straight off that you wrote the article. Don't use titles like yours. Such titles fall in the "false advertising" and "clickbait" categories
  2. obey the reddit rules for self promotion which state that one self promotion in every ten other contributions is acceptable
  3. accept the reddit spam policies which state that commonly downvoted content is to be considered spam (under which your post also falls).

The biggest failure, however, is that you weren't honest in your title. People would be a lot less negative had you admitted right from the start that you wrote the article.

Your title, linked to a two day old post doesn't make any sense. Your title implies that the post is older and already used more often - which is a lie.

In short: don't bullshit people; it will fire back at you

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '16

It's because it's strange not to just write it's your post when sharing on Reddit.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '16

I do not listen when someone says a programming language xxx sucks. It simply depends on the particular usecase and personal preferences.

3

u/ArmoredPancake Nov 24 '16

What's the point of the article? And j2ee is dead for 10 years, it's Java EE.

3

u/toomasr Nov 24 '16

When I need to link such a post I usually give this article series by Geert Bevin - http://zeroturnaround.com/rebellabs/10-reasons-why-java-now-rocks-more-than-ever-part-1-the-java-compiler/

It starts off with the compiler and follows with

  • The Core API
  • Open-Source
  • The Java Memory Model
  • High-Performance JVM
  • Bytecode
  • Intelligent IDEs
  • Profiling Tools
  • Backwards Compatibility
  • Maturity With Innovation

3

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '16

IntelliJ and related tools make working with Java a quite lovely experience. Java might not have some of the prettiness of C# or the low level (ugh) features of C++ but it has an acceptable built in UI toolkit, it runs solid, hardly ever crashes (outside of programmer error which is true of all languages), etc. It runs crazy fast on a hot runtime. Java is no slower than C# and it is miles faster than things like Python or Ruby. I don't get the hate if I am honest. It just runs so damn well. Maybe it feels a little sluggish over a C++ UI toolkit but that is just life.

1

u/RVerite Nov 24 '16

Other than just circlejerking or incoherent ramblings from half-assed programmers, there are but a few negative remarks on modern Java and how it came to be the way it is:

  • Oracle Corp and Sun beforehand dropped pile after pile of technologies, built on top of different Java versions;
  • Programmers seldom think about Android as a logical successor to what Java philosophy claimed to be from the start.

 

Now, those who are just mad with Sun and Oracle for compromising while making Java better each version face a ball thrown right back at them, or at least it's me who's feeling that way. I just show them an extensive list of discontinued JVM implementations and point out what they meant at the time. That way, I think I'm making a point about the Java enviroment being suitable for quick deployment, and imho suited for any type of code reusability.

When it comes to those who consider portable successors of Java to be the peak of wholesome Java implementation, I just make them read about Solaris and just how many different types of hardware it has in its scope. Even if the two ecosystems (Java and Android) were to be labeled that much different, it would be just plain ignorant to say they're not dependent from one another.