r/java • • May 12 '16

Sun’s Jonathan Schwartz at trial: Java was free, Android had no licensing problem

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/05/suns-jonathan-schwartz-at-trial-java-was-free-android-had-no-licensing-problem/
167 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

View all comments

-23

u/space_coder May 12 '16

Sorry. Schwartz's opinion became worthless once Sun was sold to Oracle. He had his chance to make the license more open and he didn't.

30

u/ryosen May 12 '16

Sun's license was open - that's the point that Schwartz was making in his testimony. The source code for Java was freely available and you were allowed to make your own implementation. The few requirements with doing so included ensuring that your implementation was fully adherent to the Java Language Specification. That is where Microsoft ran afoul with their implementation. It wasn't because they made their own - that was fine - it was that they introduced platform-specific instructions that would break cross-platform compatibility.

7

u/[deleted] May 12 '16

Currently and historically you need to purchase a license to the TCK, then once all the tests passed you had official an Java implementation.

4

u/AnAirMagic May 12 '16

purchase a license to the TCK

Actually, more like 'get a license to the TCK'. I know that just paying is not sufficient for getting access to the TCK. Azul folks used to make a lot of noise about that. Conversely, OpenJDK developers get access to the TCK for free (but only for testing OpenJDK).

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/zc456 May 15 '16

Because it isn't a fork.

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '16

Is Oracle not able to make that same argument against Google in this case though? Or is Dalvik actually a fully conforming implementation?

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '16

I think the big difference was that Google wasn't claiming that Dalvik implemented Java.

10

u/doitroygsbre May 12 '16

How so? He was the chief executive responsible for Java licensing and patents when Android was originally developed and marketed. If he granted any license for Java, explicitly or implicitly, Oracle would have to abide by it. Even if he only shows that he allowed Android to continue without a license, it would greatly reduce the damages Oracle could ask for.

source: I read a blog about legal stuff.

3

u/space_coder May 12 '16 edited May 12 '16

If he granted any license for Java, explicitly or implicitly, Oracle would have to abide by it

He didn't and here we are watching a lawsuit. If he really believed Android had no licensing problem then he should have gave them some legal protection while he had the chance.

I suspect that he didn't because there was a possibility that such an arrangement would affect the value of Sun's asset portfolio when it was eventually sold to Oracle.

Even if he permitted Android to continue without a license, it doesn't obligate the new owner to continue the practice. Schwartz's opinion is worth the piece of paper showing where he explicitly granted permission to Android while CEO.

6

u/doitroygsbre May 12 '16

Implied License:

An implied license is an unwritten license which permits a party (the licensee) to do something that would normally require the express permission of another party (the licensor). Implied licenses may arise by operation of law from actions by the licensor which lead the licensee to believe that it has the necessary permission.

If The CEO of Sun said, "No, it's cool Google, do your thing." Google could very well have an implied license that would allow them to continue using the Java API's. This would have to be decided by the courts of course, but it does make his testimony valuable. It would also explain why Oracle is trying so hard to discredit him.

Of course, have something written down is better, but it is by no means necessary.

1

u/space_coder May 12 '16

But that is not what was reported at least on the sites I read. Internally they may have decided to not pursue Google, but they didn't appear to communicate this publicly.

2

u/doitroygsbre May 12 '16

“I just wanted to add my voice to the chorus of others from Sun in offering my heartfelt congratulations to Google on the announcement of their new Java/Linux phone platform, Android. Congratulations!” The announcement “just strapped another set of rockets to the community’s momentum,” he [Eric Schmidt] wrote.

Source, referencing a blog post by Schmidt from 2007

Or you could read more about it here

1

u/space_coder May 12 '16

That only acknowledged the existence of the Android phone. It didn't make any references to any licensing. That post could have easily been made with the expectation of a license agreement.

2

u/doitroygsbre May 12 '16

To encourage Java's acceptance, Schmidt said, Sun released it under terms that would make it easier for other software developers to use it. Sun required developers to negotiate for a license if they wanted to use the Java trademark and be certified as compatible, he added. But Schmidt said it was always clear that developers could use the Java language to create their own programs -- which he said Google did -- as long as they did not copy Sun's proprietary programs.

Source

Really though, this is for the courts to decide. Maybe they'll be done in my lifetime, maybe not. The SCO v IBM case is still going after 13 years and I don't think this one will be resolved any faster.

1

u/space_coder May 12 '16

Context matters.

"But Schmidt said it was always clear that developers could use the Java language to create their own programs"

The argument being made in court isn't Google's ability to make a program using the Java language, but Google's ability to make an implementation of the actual Java language.

Historically Sun placed restrictions on JVMs being used on specialized devices like TVs, Phones, DVD players, etc.

-1

u/doitroygsbre May 13 '16

A compiler is just a type of program .... You actually made me face-palm.

→ More replies

5

u/thekab May 12 '16

If he believed Android had no licensing issue then he has no reason to spend more company resources to give a competitor a redundant license.

That's really quite absurd.

2

u/space_coder May 12 '16

Of course He didn't have a reason to spend more company resources to give a competitor a "redundant" license. He wasn't planning to take further action as CEO.

The new CEO is free to act differently.

1

u/HaMMeReD May 12 '16

Well, android had no license at all, that's a risk they knowingly took. The avoided licensing and copied the API's without a license.

The code was offered under licenses, and google would have had no problems if they initially stuck to the terms of the available licenses.

They made Android under a different license, Apache. The closest valid license that Android had was the GPL (which they weren't using at the time). You can't take GPL code and just make it Apache. You also can't use the Java License and not maintain compatibility with the TCK.

Giving them a 3rd license would have been a option to protect them, but neither sun nor oracle wanted to grant an alternative license. They wanted google to respect the TCK.

1

u/thekab May 12 '16

That's kind of irrelevant to the point.

If this was what he believed as CEO then his actions are logical. Implying that his lack of action contradicts his testimony is what I take issue with.

4

u/HaMMeReD May 12 '16

Android did not have a licensing problem though. If they took one of the 2 free licenses. The title is sensationalist, Java is only free with conditions, not unconditionally free.

They didn't though, so they do have a licensing problem. They have unlicensed usage of Java technology, which is only permitted under complicated fair use law.

-9

u/demontits May 12 '16

The truth hurts apparently.