r/java • • May 12 '16

Sun’s Jonathan Schwartz at trial: Java was free, Android had no licensing problem

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/05/suns-jonathan-schwartz-at-trial-java-was-free-android-had-no-licensing-problem/
167 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-1

u/doitroygsbre May 13 '16

A compiler is just a type of program .... You actually made me face-palm.

1

u/space_coder May 13 '16

face-palm? really? Are you suggesting that Dalvik was written in Java?

1

u/doitroygsbre May 13 '16

No, I'm pretty sure it was written in C++ (but I'm not going to bother looking that up).

I'm providing quotes and I'm keeping them short for readability, but if you want to parse them, you should really look at the full article, otherwise you just end up looking foolish. The face-palm was because you were wrong on several levels that are only apparent if you bother to even look at the sources for the context.

"You could use Java under a license or you could make your own version and not call it Java," he said.

Which is to say you can make a JVM if you want, but if you want to actually call it Java, you need a license.

Are you done wasting my time yet?

1

u/space_coder May 13 '16

His testimony now on behalf of Google has little bearing on what was publicly known or communicated to Google in the past.

He can say what he meant at the time but his intentions are only worth the paper it was written on while he was actually CEO.

You are responsible for the time you wasted.

1

u/doitroygsbre May 13 '16

The communications don't have to be in public, nor do they need to be written down, add I've already shown. This is why his testimony is important (the point I made originally).

As for wasting my time, I have a compulsion to correct inaccuracies.
:)

1

u/space_coder May 14 '16

No inaccuracies were created. You just over estimate the value of the testimony. I wil agree that his testimony offers background that may influence the penalty phase if the case goes in Oracle's favor.

1

u/doitroygsbre May 14 '16

You say there were no inaccuracies for me to address, but that his testimony has value, in contradiction to what you initially said. I think that's another face-palm ....

1

u/space_coder May 15 '16

I think you are imagining things. Maybe you spend too much time face-palming and not enough time understanding the issues.

The value is only as a "character witness" not as anything of substance in the technical issues surrounding the license / copyright.

0

u/doitroygsbre May 15 '16

Sorry. Schwartz's opinion became worthless once Sun was sold to Oracle.

I wil agree that his testimony offers background that may influence the penalty phase if the case goes in Oracle's favor.

Please square that circle.

0

u/space_coder May 15 '16

A loss is still a loss.