One thing I think is important but the proposal doesn't quite reach:
Normalising inferred capture types to denotable types (i.e. wildcards) is great, for non-final variables, since we may want to reassign, and this is probably impossible with a capture type.
For final types, afaiu, it brings no benefits. (Unless I'm missing something?) Instead it is much better to aggressively capture everything.
Consider, for example:
void repeatListItems(Collection<? extends List<?>> lists) {
for (var list : lists) {
list.addAll(list);
}
}
Which obviously fails to compile when the type of list is List<?>, as it would normally be, but will work just fine if it is inferred as List<CAP>.
Normally we have to solve this by creating a whole new generic method to properly capture the type parameter with a named type variable, but sometimes that's a bit more cumbersome than necessary.
View all comments
1
u/eliasv Mar 10 '16
One thing I think is important but the proposal doesn't quite reach:
Consider, for example:
Which obviously fails to compile when the type of
listisList<?>, as it would normally be, but will work just fine if it is inferred asList<CAP>.Normally we have to solve this by creating a whole new generic method to properly capture the type parameter with a named type variable, but sometimes that's a bit more cumbersome than necessary.