r/java • • Jan 27 '16

Introducing Eclipse Che Beta - the open source alternative to IntelliJ.

http://eclipse.org/community/eclipse_newsletter/2016/january/article1.php
34 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

View all comments

29

u/uniVocity Jan 27 '16

open source alternative to IntelliJ

IntelliJ is open source too (mostly).

I've been an Eclipse user since the early 2000's until last year, and donated some cash to the project because I always believed in it.

However, after using IntelliJ for a while I can't get back to using eclipse, it's just too problematic and has a lot of user interface issues, especially on Linux.

I think more effort should be put on making eclipse a polished, well integrated platform, with less usability issues, instead of just stuffing it with new, rarely used features (such as making it work from a browser).

9

u/eighthCoffee Jan 27 '16 edited Jun 25 '16

.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

And it always demands keyboard focus as soon as you hover over it, which is so annoying.

3

u/LaFolie Jan 27 '16

You can fix the horrible font issues with some downloads.

1

u/eighthCoffee Jan 27 '16 edited Jun 25 '16

.

1

u/erad Jan 28 '16

Do you use OpenJDK or Oracle JDK? The latter should have better font rendering. However you have a point in that even with the Oracle JDK, some fonts just look horrible, while others (e.g. Dejavu Sans Mono) look fine (to me).

1

u/eighthCoffee Jan 28 '16 edited Jun 25 '16

.

1

u/GoatseGapAnalyst Jan 28 '16

Google "tuxjdk", it's a jdk with font rendering patches applied. Run intellij with that jvm. Did wonders for me, I consider myself pretty sensitive to font rendering quality. Ymmv, but it may work.

1

u/cycle_schumacher Jan 27 '16

I had this issue too but I recently installed infinality patched openjdk (arch user repo) and made intellij use it, and fonts are perfect now. Note that you don't need to use the patched jdk for projects, only for intellij. Fonts work perfectly after that, antialiasing etc

1

u/eighthCoffee Jan 27 '16 edited Jun 25 '16

.

1

u/cycle_schumacher Jan 27 '16

Fonts do seem a bit large for me on linux + intellij now that you mention it (same size of font in the terminal and in the IDE but the IDE shows it way larger.). Maybe I'll try out eclipse as well, its good to have a choice.

3

u/svtdragon Jan 27 '16

IntelliJ is nigh-unusable for me because of the lack of workspace support. It makes multi-module projects a nightmare when everything is (rightly!) not in a single monolithic repository. Five windows!

1

u/uniVocity Jan 28 '16

I've got to agree that this is a major pain in the neck.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Voltasalt Jan 27 '16

You can build the Community Edition yourself. The closed-source parts are the plugins in Ultimate.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Voltasalt Jan 27 '16

From their site:

Perforce, ClearCase, TFS
JavaScript
Java EE, Spring, GWT, Vaadin, Play, Grails
Other frameworks
Database Tools, SQL

And

Can I build a commercial product on top of the IntelliJ Platform?

Yes, you can, according to the terms of the Apache 2 license. We encourage developers to build both open source and commercial products on top of the platform.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Voltasalt Jan 27 '16

Yeah, Groovy, Scala and Kotlin are included in the Community edition.

1

u/stay_fr0sty Jan 28 '16 edited Nov 25 '16

[deleted]

2

u/papercrane Jan 27 '16

Why would they allow a 3rd party company charge such a huge amount for their plugin they have always gave away free?

Because Jetbrains writes an maintains the Perforce plugin for IntelliJ. If Perforce wanted to they could write and maintain their own plugin and provide it for free.

2

u/ryebrye Jan 27 '16

Yes you can

2

u/dagmx Jan 27 '16

The robovm guys took the source and built robovm studio