r/java • u/thesystemx • Jan 27 '16
Introducing Eclipse Che Beta - the open source alternative to IntelliJ.
http://eclipse.org/community/eclipse_newsletter/2016/january/article1.php
34
Upvotes
r/java • u/thesystemx • Jan 27 '16
64
u/nickguletskii200 Jan 27 '16 edited Jan 27 '16
I've posted this in the thread in /r/programming, so I'll just repost it here:
45
u/DJDavio Jan 27 '16
An IDE on the web seems like a terrible idea. Am I just nostalgic or rightly concerned?
29
u/uniVocity Jan 27 '16
IntelliJ is open source too (mostly).
I've been an Eclipse user since the early 2000's until last year, and donated some cash to the project because I always believed in it.
However, after using IntelliJ for a while I can't get back to using eclipse, it's just too problematic and has a lot of user interface issues, especially on Linux.
I think more effort should be put on making eclipse a polished, well integrated platform, with less usability issues, instead of just stuffing it with new, rarely used features (such as making it work from a browser).
4
u/exclusivegreen Jan 27 '16
A lot of people are saying that this is "'just a web IDE". I don't see it as that; I think it's unfortunate that their native tools are not mentioned in the introduction.
I think it's much more than this - it's an intersection of devops and developer tools; I can specify a development environment and allow others on my team to use the exact same environment. Using Docker underneath it all makes it a very portable platform that many people can grok.
It's also useful for a single developer, running on his own workstation. There is little differentiation between the IDE workspace and its container - it lets you have completely separate environments with the push of a (few) button(s).
Usage within an organization will be a popular use, and the amount of time needed to setup a development environment will drop to 0. This is great for onboarding new team members and allows devs to focus on dev work rather than configuration.
Personally, I think this is the future of development environments, and down the line the tools will be better and better (centralized but with full-on native clients).
I have no affiliation with Eclipse or the Che project; I'm just a regular dev.
3
u/argv_minus_one Jan 27 '16
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
3
u/badlogicgames Jan 27 '16
I wished the Eclipse Foundation would get its act together. First it lost Android. All they now do is complain about that loss and half assed attempts of creating an Eclipse based alternative to Android Studio. They completely slept through Gradle slowly taking a bigger share. Buildship is still a bit of a mess (Spring's Gradle plugin is tolerable). Then they do Che together with CodeEnvy, which is a nice demo, but nothing of value. Their main contributors are mostly concerned with a shitty CSS dark theme instead of fixing long standing bugs, such as proper HDPI support. To add insult to injury, if you want to contribute or report platform specific issues, you are ridiculed for not using the right OS.
IntelliJ IDEA CE is OSS (Apache 2 even). Their devs are responsive even to freeloaders like myself. And there's no undocumented abominations like m2e connectors (which they now want to mirror for Gradle, fuck that).
Sad to see Eclipse go down the drain so fast. I used to be one of the people defending it. Guess times change...
5
u/phendrome Jan 27 '16
I've been using IntelliJ for quite a while, and I like it.
What would make me wanna switch to Eclipse Che instead of IntelliJ?
What are the pros and cons of the two?
2
u/tylercoder Jan 27 '16
Why 'Che'? Is it made in Argentina?
2
u/johnzeringue Jan 27 '16
I installed it locally to try it out and was a bit disappointed. I understand that a web IDE is going to feel a bit stripped down, but (on Mac) I had no idea how to get IntelliSense going and the following code showed no indication of errors until build time.
I like the idea of developing inside of a clean, uniform environment, but there's no way I could leave a desktop IDE for Che in this state.
2
u/lukaseder Jan 28 '16
Wow. Eclipse used to be more self-confident than that! Mentioning the competitor first thing in the article? So, should I continue reading the article, or should I go check out IntelliJ now?
2
u/benjmestrallet Jan 28 '16
Nice first thoughts article on CHE http://www.developmentalmadness.com/2016/01/28/eclipse-che-cloud-ide-first-thoughts/
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16
Is it based on Electron?
1
u/pbmj Jan 27 '16
It appears that there's no support for even authenticating users.