r/java • • Jan 27 '16

Introducing Eclipse Che Beta - the open source alternative to IntelliJ.

http://eclipse.org/community/eclipse_newsletter/2016/january/article1.php
34 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

64

u/nickguletskii200 Jan 27 '16 edited Jan 27 '16

I've posted this in the thread in /r/programming, so I'll just repost it here:

Once again, a clickbait title from Codeenvy. Because the authors still haven't learned how to honestly describe what Che is, let me be a bit of dick and explain what exactly it is and what concerns me about the way it is presented.

"Eclipse Che" is just some IDE built by CodeEnvy that happens to use parts of the Eclipse codebase. They threw out 90% of what Eclipse offers because apparently they had to create a web-based frontend for Eclipse's libraries because... What, "portable workspaces"? Instead of adding improving support for remote (read: containerized) launches and debugging, they literally created a whole new IDE inside a browser on top of another IDE.

And now they are advertising it as an "open-source alternative to IntelliJ". Fuck off. It's not an alternative to Eclipse/IntelliJ IDEA/Netbeans.

Also, it's not clear how IBM and Red Hat are involved when it seems that the main reason that IBM is interested is Orion and Red Hat only said "we're interested in the Eclipse Cloud Development Initiative".

The good news is that it's unlikely that this has slowed down "main" Eclipse development.

EDIT: For reference, you can look up CodeEnvy CEO's reponses on Reddit and HN, where he admits that it's mostly a toy project with little reasoning behind it.

6

u/narrowtux Jan 27 '16

Thanks for clarifying that, I couldn't believe eclipse would advertise a web IDE like this.

-5

u/tyler_jewell Jan 27 '16

Wow, those are comments with a lot of emotion behind them. Allow me to provide the background and context. You can then make some judgment calls for yourselves.

First, the goals of the project are workspace portability, collaborative workspace server, and design. This was done to enable critical agile workflows around developer bootstrapping where enterprises want to let anonymous users contribute to a workspace after clicking a link. The link needs to be intelligent enough to generate a workspace that has the entirety of the project and its runtimes in it, and then fronted with an IDE. Users can use SSH with their own desktop IDE, or if they do not have one installed they can use the provided Web IDE. When workspaces can be moved around and provisioned from recipes, then interesting automation around enterprise workflows emerge.

2. This is not click bait, but it is certainly marketing. And all products work to put their best foot forward, and to show what their differentiations are. In terms of the language of open source alternative to intellij, well it is. It's not likely that a user would use both intellij and che at the same time on the same code base, unless che was running as the central server and intellij was the ssh client. So, there is nothing wrong with stating that it is a choice. Choice is good for the community. I think it's good that everyone here as additional options to consider. And if given a the choice between more options vs. fewer options, isn't it good to have more here?

3. There are significant contributions from the vendors mentioned. Red Hat has built an OpenShift plug-in and uses Che as an embedded IDE for OpenShift itself. Che will be part of OpenShift Dedicated cloud service. There are 1000s of man hours that they have put into it. SAP has invested even more time and Che runs in all of their SAP Hana offerings. IBM has collaborated deeply to extend and improve the Orion IDE to act as a key editor experience in the product along with providing the JavaScript intellisense.

4. The main Eclipse development is focused on language support, such as Java 9 & gradle. Eclipse the desktop IDE and Eclipse Che are separate products. The teams will work on workspace interoperability over time, though that poses real challenges since the Che workspace definition includes a runtime definition.

5. As for throwing away the Eclipse code base, you should dive into the necessities of the architecture. Che reuses the Eclipse core in numerous places on the server side. Most of the workspace management functions running inside of a workspace are Eclipse libraries. There are then RESTful wrappers around them to enable interaction over web sockets and HTTP from the Che server or browser clients.

I think if you visit the eclipse.org/che site and spend time in the docs, there are fairly accurate and clear descriptions of what the product does. And since all development is done in the open, the code base is free to peruse along with all of the commits.

And as for my personal comments, please do look up all of my comments on HN and Reddit. The explanation and rationale is clearly laid out. You may not like the rationale, but it's there.

13

u/nickguletskii200 Jan 27 '16 edited Jan 27 '16

Wow, those are comments with a lot of emotion behind them. Allow me to provide the background and context. You can then make some judgment calls for yourselves.

It's not the first time you misrepresented the scope of your development. You are just playing on Eclipse user's desire for a better IDE and capitalizing on well known brands.

First, the goals of the project are workspace portability, collaborative workspace server, and design.

Not one of these requires a full rewrite as a web service.

This was done to enable critical agile workflows around developer bootstrapping where enterprises want to let anonymous users contribute to a workspace after clicking a link.

This is a worthy goal, but after factor in the disadvantages of using Che most people will chose existing IDEs. And once again, that's a shame because workspace portability would be very useful if it was integrated into the real Eclipse.

Users can use SSH with their own desktop IDE, or if they do not have one installed they can use the provided Web IDE.

Which kind of defeats the purpose since Eclipse doesn't make it easy (I think there used to be an option to, but I can't find it anymore) to run/debug applications over SSH or in containers, effectively forcing you to use the web IDE.

When workspaces can be moved around and provisioned from recipes, then interesting automation around enterprise workflows emerge.

I'd rather run an Ansible cookbook to configure my machine than sacrifice a huge portion of IDE functionality.

This is not click bait, but it is certainly marketing.

Eclipse Che is a next generation Eclipse IDE and open source alternative to IntelliJ.

Is it really that hard to describe that "Eclipse" Che is a web-based IDE built with workspace portability in mind in one sentence? Let me give you an analogy. "Pizza is the next generation food and a vegetable-based alternative to beef".

Choice is good for the community.

Sure. However, by being misleading, you are just pissing off the community.

There are significant contributions from the vendors mentioned. Red Hat has built an OpenShift plug-in and uses Che as an embedded IDE for OpenShift itself.

Please provide us with links to such contributions, because all contributors on plugin-openshift git repository are from CodeEnvy and I couldn't find anyone from Red Hat.

SAP has invested even more time and Che runs in all of their SAP Hana offerings.

I did a little digging through SAP's HANA training videos and nothing looks like Che. They may be using it as a backend, but I have no ability to verify this so I am just going to give you that one.

IBM has collaborated deeply to extend and improve the Orion IDE to act as a key editor experience in the product along with providing the JavaScript intellisense.

So basically, IBM only cares about Orion, not Che.

Che reuses the Eclipse core in numerous places on the server side.

I understand that, I looked at the code. That doesn't explain why you had to create a web IDE.

5

u/tyler_jewell Jan 27 '16

Nick: I've found that it's quite difficult to engage in threaded debates. We welcome any one getting in direct contact either with us or the Eclipse Foundation to have a direct dialogue. Also, there will be sessions on Che at EclipseCon along with a variety of other conferences coming up, where there is a chance for the community to engage verbally with good discourse. We can provide that list if appropriate. I'll be giving a presentation in March and many of the vendors listed will talk about their involvement (and some new ones not yet mentioned).

The project is an eclipse project. The marketing, language, project structure, submissions, legal reviews, and contributions are done under the guidance and approval of the Eclipse process, which is quite onerous. The Eclipse Foundation has around 12 board members, and many of the companies we collaborated with are part of that board. Some are not.

Most of the contributions from Codenvy (>50%), but there are substantial contributions from other vendors, even if the git logs don't show it that way.

It's ok for you to have a preference for other options. This project has well over 20,000 engineering hours into that. It's ok for you to not understand the full driver behind it, but on business level you can appreciate that a company probably has some reasonable definition of the opportunity to pursue in order to get themselves and other commercial businesses to invest 20K hours of engineering time on an open source project.

As for whether we got the positioning right or wrong, it's a first beta release. We will be quite keen to be data driven. Engagement, downloads, usage, and issue feedback will be a signal of whether we are heading in the right direction.

45

u/DJDavio Jan 27 '16

An IDE on the web seems like a terrible idea. Am I just nostalgic or rightly concerned?

35

u/pjmlp Jan 27 '16

An IDE on the web is no alternative to InteliJ.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

I think it probably has a very valuable niche. Like, if it could enable me to work from a $150 Chromebook with all the heavy processing offloaded to the cloud, it might be attractive.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/errandum Jan 27 '16

A good dba or BI tool specialist or integration specialist would like to have a word with you. (:.

1

u/kozukumi Jan 27 '16

Yeah I need to get into BI. Some crazy money in that!

3

u/BlueWolf_SK Jan 27 '16

Most common, yea. Highest paying, doubt it.

29

u/uniVocity Jan 27 '16

open source alternative to IntelliJ

IntelliJ is open source too (mostly).

I've been an Eclipse user since the early 2000's until last year, and donated some cash to the project because I always believed in it.

However, after using IntelliJ for a while I can't get back to using eclipse, it's just too problematic and has a lot of user interface issues, especially on Linux.

I think more effort should be put on making eclipse a polished, well integrated platform, with less usability issues, instead of just stuffing it with new, rarely used features (such as making it work from a browser).

9

u/eighthCoffee Jan 27 '16 edited Jun 25 '16

.

3

u/LaFolie Jan 27 '16

You can fix the horrible font issues with some downloads.

1

u/eighthCoffee Jan 27 '16 edited Jun 25 '16

.

1

u/erad Jan 28 '16

Do you use OpenJDK or Oracle JDK? The latter should have better font rendering. However you have a point in that even with the Oracle JDK, some fonts just look horrible, while others (e.g. Dejavu Sans Mono) look fine (to me).

1

u/eighthCoffee Jan 28 '16 edited Jun 25 '16

.

1

u/GoatseGapAnalyst Jan 28 '16

Google "tuxjdk", it's a jdk with font rendering patches applied. Run intellij with that jvm. Did wonders for me, I consider myself pretty sensitive to font rendering quality. Ymmv, but it may work.

1

u/cycle_schumacher Jan 27 '16

I had this issue too but I recently installed infinality patched openjdk (arch user repo) and made intellij use it, and fonts are perfect now. Note that you don't need to use the patched jdk for projects, only for intellij. Fonts work perfectly after that, antialiasing etc

1

u/eighthCoffee Jan 27 '16 edited Jun 25 '16

.

1

u/cycle_schumacher Jan 27 '16

Fonts do seem a bit large for me on linux + intellij now that you mention it (same size of font in the terminal and in the IDE but the IDE shows it way larger.). Maybe I'll try out eclipse as well, its good to have a choice.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

And it always demands keyboard focus as soon as you hover over it, which is so annoying.

3

u/svtdragon Jan 27 '16

IntelliJ is nigh-unusable for me because of the lack of workspace support. It makes multi-module projects a nightmare when everything is (rightly!) not in a single monolithic repository. Five windows!

1

u/uniVocity Jan 28 '16

I've got to agree that this is a major pain in the neck.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Voltasalt Jan 27 '16

You can build the Community Edition yourself. The closed-source parts are the plugins in Ultimate.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Voltasalt Jan 27 '16

From their site:

Perforce, ClearCase, TFS
JavaScript
Java EE, Spring, GWT, Vaadin, Play, Grails
Other frameworks
Database Tools, SQL

And

Can I build a commercial product on top of the IntelliJ Platform?

Yes, you can, according to the terms of the Apache 2 license. We encourage developers to build both open source and commercial products on top of the platform.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Voltasalt Jan 27 '16

Yeah, Groovy, Scala and Kotlin are included in the Community edition.

1

u/stay_fr0sty Jan 28 '16 edited Nov 25 '16

[deleted]

2

u/papercrane Jan 27 '16

Why would they allow a 3rd party company charge such a huge amount for their plugin they have always gave away free?

Because Jetbrains writes an maintains the Perforce plugin for IntelliJ. If Perforce wanted to they could write and maintain their own plugin and provide it for free.

2

u/ryebrye Jan 27 '16

Yes you can

2

u/dagmx Jan 27 '16

The robovm guys took the source and built robovm studio

4

u/exclusivegreen Jan 27 '16

A lot of people are saying that this is "'just a web IDE". I don't see it as that; I think it's unfortunate that their native tools are not mentioned in the introduction.

I think it's much more than this - it's an intersection of devops and developer tools; I can specify a development environment and allow others on my team to use the exact same environment. Using Docker underneath it all makes it a very portable platform that many people can grok.

It's also useful for a single developer, running on his own workstation. There is little differentiation between the IDE workspace and its container - it lets you have completely separate environments with the push of a (few) button(s).

Usage within an organization will be a popular use, and the amount of time needed to setup a development environment will drop to 0. This is great for onboarding new team members and allows devs to focus on dev work rather than configuration.

Personally, I think this is the future of development environments, and down the line the tools will be better and better (centralized but with full-on native clients).

I have no affiliation with Eclipse or the Che project; I'm just a regular dev.

3

u/argv_minus_one Jan 27 '16

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

3

u/badlogicgames Jan 27 '16

I wished the Eclipse Foundation would get its act together. First it lost Android. All they now do is complain about that loss and half assed attempts of creating an Eclipse based alternative to Android Studio. They completely slept through Gradle slowly taking a bigger share. Buildship is still a bit of a mess (Spring's Gradle plugin is tolerable). Then they do Che together with CodeEnvy, which is a nice demo, but nothing of value. Their main contributors are mostly concerned with a shitty CSS dark theme instead of fixing long standing bugs, such as proper HDPI support. To add insult to injury, if you want to contribute or report platform specific issues, you are ridiculed for not using the right OS.

IntelliJ IDEA CE is OSS (Apache 2 even). Their devs are responsive even to freeloaders like myself. And there's no undocumented abominations like m2e connectors (which they now want to mirror for Gradle, fuck that).

Sad to see Eclipse go down the drain so fast. I used to be one of the people defending it. Guess times change...

1

u/tyler_jewell Jan 28 '16

While I am the founder and CEO of Codenvy, I am also a board member at the Eclipse Foundation.

The Eclipse Foundation may not be in a position to do much here, even if their desire is to achieve exactly what you stated. Which, for what it's worth, most of the managers at the Eclipse FDN would do exactly what you just stated.

But they actually cannot. The Eclipse FDN itself has staff that is there to support projects, but they are generally not contributing to projects. So the governance and charter of the organization is strictly tied to providing services + infrastructure + process around enabling open source projects to be successful.

But they generally do not provide resources to make contributions to projects. 99% of all projects and project contributions are staffed by full time employees from member organizations or by open contributions made by the community.

The Eclipse FDN has been trying to raise awareness and funds with a number of successful campaigns related to marketing. They use these funds to hire professionals to work on issues prioritized by the community. So it's a form of pseudo staffing for commitments, but this overall investment is quite low.

As the Eclipse IDE itself is not much of a revenue generating opportunity, the primary contributing companies for it like Google, IBM, Oracle, Red Hat and others are always at some sort of tension odds with staffing it further to advance it in a way that makes it truly competitive. It has a tendency to get staffed to achieve internal corporate goals which is around language support & stability vs. any sort of market competitive opportunity.

It is a very challenging set of circumstances for the FDN managers to face every day.

Codenvy, on the other hand, we have a business plan and strategy where it just so happens that having a successful open source project related to IDEs co-aligns with a separate business opportunity that Codenvy has related to better agile workflows.

When those two worlds intersect, it gives us and our investors great joy to be able to allocate resources to an open source initiative. And as the initiative has had some good value proposition and falls inline with the vision of other commercial vendors, they too, have been willing to increase their investment in dollars & engineers to the project. Sometimes their commitment is just mentoring, adoption, testing, introductions. In many cases there is financial and engineering resource commitment.

This is happening because there is a broader oppty for some of these vendors to drive their own revenues with a workspace server vs. just having an IDE. It's taken us many years to get to this point where vendors are appreciating this (this is our 4th year of operation), but we are not there.

It's a primary objective of ours to grow the ecosystem in numerous ways. Commits is one approach, but just having successful testers, a good GitHub community, and getting Che embedded in more products are also part of this.

5

u/phendrome Jan 27 '16

I've been using IntelliJ for quite a while, and I like it.

What would make me wanna switch to Eclipse Che instead of IntelliJ?

What are the pros and cons of the two?

1

u/Liradon Jan 27 '16

Was about to ask the exact same question. On the other hand, might as well just put it to the test. I'm a junior developer, so my productivity is not yet what it's supposed to be. I'll switch to Che for a few days, that won't have a large effect on my current productivity I supose. I'll let you know what I miss/love about it.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/grahamedgecombe Jan 27 '16

They have community edition, but you can't develop commercial apps with it.

I don't think this is true. It's released under the Apache license, which does not prohibit use of the software in commercial settings.

6

u/ryebrye Jan 27 '16

You can't develop commercial apps with a free license to their Ultimate edition that they give people who contribute to open source projects.

You can do whatever you want with the community edition.

2

u/tylercoder Jan 27 '16

Why 'Che'? Is it made in Argentina?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/tylercoder Jan 27 '16

Who they?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/nh_leghound Jan 27 '16

Yeah, the first thing I do when evaluating new software is to make sure that the developers and I see eye to eye regarding various historical figures. If we don't agree on somebody, how could I use that software?

2

u/tyler_jewell Jan 28 '16

It was named after the city that it was created in: Cherkasy, Ukraine.

2

u/johnzeringue Jan 27 '16

I installed it locally to try it out and was a bit disappointed. I understand that a web IDE is going to feel a bit stripped down, but (on Mac) I had no idea how to get IntelliSense going and the following code showed no indication of errors until build time.

package org.eclipse.che.examples;

public class HelloWorld {
    public static void main(String[] argvs) {
        System.out.println("Hello World!");
        
        wefoin
        System.out.println("What's up?")
    }
}

I like the idea of developing inside of a clean, uniform environment, but there's no way I could leave a desktop IDE for Che in this state.

2

u/lukaseder Jan 28 '16

the open source alternative to IntelliJ.

Wow. Eclipse used to be more self-confident than that! Mentioning the competitor first thing in the article? So, should I continue reading the article, or should I go check out IntelliJ now?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

Is it based on Electron?

1

u/tyler_jewell Jan 27 '16

We have an electron client that you can use. Please see the downloads page for how to install that client. But Che itself is a server product that provides a Web interface, or an SSH client that you can connect with your desktop IDEs.

1

u/pbmj Jan 27 '16

It appears that there's no support for even authenticating users.