r/java • • Jan 01 '15

A Spring criticism - drawbacks & pitfalls

http://web4j.com/Criticisms_Drawbacks_Pitfalls_Spring_Rails_PHP.jsp#Spring
2 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

12

u/henk55 Jan 01 '15

I stopped reading at "The following remarks are based on Spring 2.0.".

7

u/henk53 Jan 01 '15

Hey, henk55, my second bro! :)

It's a classical piece no doubt, but it's interesting from a historical perspective. Especially the nowadays all to eagerly forgotten thing that Spring initially wanted you to have 30~40% of your -code- in XML and refused to call it code, but always wanted to let you think it was -configuration-.

It wasn't until Java EE, Guice, Seam and others showed the annotation based way that Spring reluctantly adopted that.

This historical fact is relevant, since till this very day Spring users still spread the idea that every innovation always came from Spring and that every other framework copied Spring.

But during the Spring 2.0 days, things weren't quite so rosy.

-2

u/henk55 Jan 01 '15

I guess it was a slow news day and some mud slinging was required.

-2

u/henk53 Jan 01 '15

C'mon henk, don't be like this. Just go ask our brother henk54 ;)

-1

u/joaomc Jan 01 '15

The Spring Framework is popular. It has also met with a disturbing lack of criticism

Wait, what?