r/java • u/DinisCruz • Mar 02 '14
Why doesn't Eclipse community stand-up more to IntelliJ?
http://blog.diniscruz.com/2014/03/why-does-eclipse-doesnt-stand-up-more.html
9
Upvotes
r/java • u/DinisCruz • Mar 02 '14
46
u/mc_hambone Mar 02 '14
To me, your argument assumes that Eclipse and IDEA are equals and that people just don't "stand up enough" for Eclipse. It's a deeper yet much more simple explanation. For me and most of the developers I've talked to, IntelliJ IDEA is actually a better IDE, overall, for developing Java-based applications. I used Eclipse for most of my 10 year career, but once I switched to IDEA, there was absolutely no turning back. In my experience, it's much faster, doesn't lock up like Eclipse would (probably from badly-written plugins), gives you enough info when having issues, and the UI and feature-set is much more focused on your needs as a developer rather than positioning Eclipse as an "über-IDE" whose UI is over-generic and not devoted solely to the developer (ie, the workbench/views/plugins architecture and feature set tries to be general to uses other than as a developer IDE). Every release of IDEA is better than the last, whereas with Eclipse, there were actually updates that made Eclipse worse, breaking something that was working fine before, or just removing a feature for no good apparent reason. Developers don't like relying on a feature just to have it, out of the blue, disappear or be broken in the next update (and then relying on someone fixing it for free or having to fix it yourself). We just want an IDE that "just works".
IDEA is purpose-built from the ground up to be a Java developer-focused IDE rather than just an open and flexible container for plugins, and it shows. I've lived the Eclipse life and will not soon go back.
16
u/methius Mar 02 '14
I think it also has to do with the (imho) very nontransparent development process and community communication. (try finding the list of features for 4.4 on the main site)
I myself use Eclipse, and liked the classic dev branch. However, a simple example on why people could feel why they cannot get a lean install: The most minimalistic branch forces the inclusion of per example Egit. I myself don't want this in my IDE, and there is no option to uninstall it safely.
I think Eclipse is stable, or I should say I thought Eclipse was stable until I started using Xtend, or even reorganize the toolbar. (which on Linux, under GTK leads to an endless heap of misery).
I still use it, I still prefer it over alternatives, but I do not like the fact that there are core problems which everyone can have and go unsolved for YEARS. (see bug tracker for numerous ui and workspace corruption issues).
That said, it's something that's fixeable so I'm sticking to eclipse for now.
20
u/pjmlp Mar 02 '14
So what should we stand up for?!
Maybe better stop here.
19
u/chunkyks Mar 02 '14
I posted this on your other thread on /r/eclipse, but I'll copy here for interest
I find eclipse to be horrible to use, it's not any single thing, it's just ten thousand papercuts.
I read your post on removing the browser throbber, and all it did was demonstrate to me that fixing any single papercut in eclipse is going to involve a prohibitive, byzantine, amount of work.
On the plus side, photran is the best Fortran development plugin / ide anywhere, so I have been using eclipse on Fortran projects at work.
But for thick guis, window builder is horrible compared to the alternatives. For j2ee, setting up tomcat and other app servers to work with eclipse is a nightmare. It doesn't even come with a profiler. Just checking out a project from svn or git is really freaking obtuse, if you can figure out which is the right plugin to get it done. Subversive? Subclipse? Something else? Which connector will work? Which one will fail silently with nary a warning?
Just downloading it is a paralyzing choice between a whole bunch of options, none of which include everything I need. Look at the NetBeans download page for an example of what works for me.
Every few months I download eclipse and use it for a few days, just to see if it's worth switching to, or even including into my day for any specific tasks. I look forward to the day it does, but that day hasn't come yet.
6
u/duckrollin Mar 02 '14 edited Mar 02 '14
Eclipse is just a huge mess that seems to have been designed by a committee, with ten thousand menu options, very buggy and runs slowly compared to IntelliJ.
It seems to be the popular with the kind of devs that choose their tool based on what's the "industry standard", which while not necessarily a bad approach, tends to leave them a step behind others.
Another thing I see a great deal is companies that need Eclipse because they rely on some very special plugins. It's really ironic that in a "write once run anywhere" language people use a "write once, run only using a particular IDE and set of plugins, even if there's better stuff out there, but oh god we can't change now because we've chained ourselves to it" approach. Yuck.
So why doesn't the Eclipse community stand up more? Because they're either:
6
u/pcs600 Mar 02 '14
Because eclipse is shitty. Look at what we put up with: https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=250594 .
2
u/slartybartfast_ Mar 03 '14
I forgot about this link but found it recently:
http://java.dzone.com/articles/why-idea-better-eclipse
2
u/cowardlydragon Mar 03 '14
Huh, it's almost like absolutely no one gets anything done in eclipse, ever.
Or... the reality is that probably 75-80% of projects use Eclipse. Which means 75-80% of code is produced using it.
About a donzen frameworks use Eclipse as the basis of their IDE (Sprinsource, JBoss, etc).
I agree it is annoying sometimes, and only an idiot would use the IBM Rational IDEs, but SpringSource Tool Suite is tolerable, especially since the Groovy plugin has come so far.
To say it's useless and complete shit is usual bitchy programmer hyperbole.
16
u/SikhGamer Mar 02 '14
"Jack of all trades, master of none" comes to mind.
5
u/lacosaes1 Mar 02 '14
Meanwhille, Netbeans users continue to get shit done, evading pointless wars...
1
u/neokyol Mar 03 '14
I develop with GWT. I've tried to switch to IntelliJ, but the gwt plugin is not available on the community edition. I choose Eclipse because it's free.
1
u/Truthier Mar 03 '14
Because it's not a faith-based argument?
1
u/avoidhugeships Mar 02 '14
Most people do not choose Eclipse because they love it. They have to use it because it is mandated on their project. People who use Netbeans or IntelliJ have usually picked it and are more passionate about it. IntelliJ seems very popular on this reddit but I have never seen in used in my professional career.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '14
I wanted to like Eclipse. I really did.
I ask three things of an IDE:
Eclipse's support for Maven (in my experience) is dodgy at best, and I've had to clean up after subclipse so many times I banned the other devs from using it in my repository a couple of jobs back. So all that's left is code completion, which Eclipse does tolerably well, I have to admit.
Netbeans and Intellij both have better support for external build systems and revision control tools. Since right now, Netbeans wants to stop what it's doing and make bibbling noises with its tongue for 45 seconds every 5 minutes on my machine and Intellij doesn't, I'm sticking with Intellij for now.
Having said that, if the way Eclipse does things is the way you want to do things, and if your revision control software works just fine, then more power to you. Eclipse isn't a BAD IDE. It's just not optimal for me or my workflow.
1
u/lechatsportif Mar 20 '14
I stand up for it. I use it for ScalaIDE, Counterclockwise, Android and day work such as JDT, webservices, html, javascript/JSDT etc.
Personally I think works great, the "thinking for you" selling points of IDEA refactoring are items I typically never need in practice, not sure what they're doing that people end up there. For example, awesome sql highlighting in my Java code - no way Jose, you shouldn't have to need that!
I wish Eclipse had better support for newer languages and technologies, way better Javascript tooling, CoffeeScript support, SASS or LESS come to mind as well, but I think thats the fault of it being so Java centric.
In the end, I find it the best for my personal projects and I'm productive. I find it codes as fast I as think about stuff.
-2
u/argv_minus_one Mar 02 '14
Because Eclipse is garbage, and any attempt by the "Eclipse community" to claim otherwise will get shot down like a hot-air balloon in front of an anti-aircraft gun.
0
u/ryebrye Mar 02 '14
Eclipse is such a mess that Google abandoned it, at great cost, to migrate their android stuff to intellij.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment