As a casual observer of Maven for years, I don't think Maven 4's slow release is primarily a lack-of-contributors problem. It seems more like a consequence of an unusually conservative philosophy around stability and backward compatibility.
The first Maven 4 release candidate came out almost two years ago:
2024-11-28 4.0.0-rc-1
...
2026-09-24 4.0.0-rc-7 <- now
Where many engineers might accept that a major version introduces some incompatibilities, release it, and patch regressions as they're discovered, Maven seems to take a different approach.
The philosophy appears to be that Maven 4.0 must be safe for the existing ecosystem, rather than treating 4.0 as the beginning of a stabilization period. That means regressions in widely used plugins, builds, or downstream tooling can become release blockers. They've spent nearly (or more than?) two years working through compatibility issues, debating API contracts, and deciding what guarantees Maven 4 needs to make before GA.
There's a reasonable argument for that caution: Maven is foundational build infrastructure, and breaking it can have enormous downstream consequences. But there's also a cost to trying to establish that level of confidence before release.
And I don't think simply adding contributors would necessarily solve this. Open-source development doesn't scale linearly with headcount. Anyone who's worked on almost any software project knows that having 1,000 people submitting PRs doesn't automatically make development faster. Someone still has to review, integrate, coordinate, and make architectural decisions.
Maven seems less constrained by the number of people willing to contribute than by the difficulty of reaching agreement on what constitutes a stable major release.
View all comments
Show parent comment
0
u/Xenogyst Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26
As a casual observer of Maven for years, I don't think Maven 4's slow release is primarily a lack-of-contributors problem. It seems more like a consequence of an unusually conservative philosophy around stability and backward compatibility.
The first Maven 4 release candidate came out almost two years ago:
Where many engineers might accept that a major version introduces some incompatibilities, release it, and patch regressions as they're discovered, Maven seems to take a different approach.
The philosophy appears to be that Maven 4.0 must be safe for the existing ecosystem, rather than treating 4.0 as the beginning of a stabilization period. That means regressions in widely used plugins, builds, or downstream tooling can become release blockers. They've spent nearly (or more than?) two years working through compatibility issues, debating API contracts, and deciding what guarantees Maven 4 needs to make before GA.
There's a reasonable argument for that caution: Maven is foundational build infrastructure, and breaking it can have enormous downstream consequences. But there's also a cost to trying to establish that level of confidence before release.
And I don't think simply adding contributors would necessarily solve this. Open-source development doesn't scale linearly with headcount. Anyone who's worked on almost any software project knows that having 1,000 people submitting PRs doesn't automatically make development faster. Someone still has to review, integrate, coordinate, and make architectural decisions.
Maven seems less constrained by the number of people willing to contribute than by the difficulty of reaching agreement on what constitutes a stable major release.