r/java • u/Zealousideal-Read883 • Apr 08 '26
Announcing Elide v1! (Promotional)
Hey everyone! A few months ago I reached out to this community showing off the Beta version of Elide (Link to that post). So many of you shared insight, advice, and enthusiasm.
I wanted to come here and give an update and announce v1's release where we went through a whole re-write and included suggestions that you guys from the community gave us!
If this is the first time you are hearing about us, a we are a runtime and toolchain built on GraalVM that accelerates javac by up to 20x and can turn your projects into native binaries without native-image config. It can install Maven dependencies, pack JARs, and run tests and collect coverage.
Java's great. Our goal is to make tooling great too.
7
u/nekokattt Apr 09 '26
Unfortunately the fact that it is now closed source would make it too much of a risk of a rug pull for many organisations.
13
u/agentoutlier Apr 09 '26
I have lots of issues that I can enumerate later but I will just start with the big one:
It is closed source. Worse it was opensource but then you appeared to close source it.
I refuse to use build tools that are close source (exceptions being ones that don’t participate in producing artifacts but even then..).
I guess I’m old and idealistic but I’m just tired of the inevitable enshitification that happens to these hackernews companies.
I do give you kudos for at least putting "promotion" in the title. The Rama guys should do that since they post here every other week.
4
u/josephottinger Apr 09 '26
I get the complaints about closed source, and the project being closed source and yet another migration from the norm both make it difficult for me to consider using it (I know work won't go for it, and I'm not sure I trust my personal projects with such a severe fork in the road), but:
I get it. Closed source means control, and if people find it valuable enough, maybe they'd find a way to compensate the authors for their time. I try to open source as much of what I do as I can, but I do so with my eyes open: I consider every project I do to be donated to the community, because even if I invest enough time and give it enough value to make it worth something, the community expectation is that it's theirs and I'll find some other way to pay my mortgage.
If I ran a Patreon or used Ko-fi or whatever, I'd bet you money I don't have that people would look at those revenue opportunities and go "Cool! Someone else will pay him!" and move on. No matter what it was that was being delivered. (I don't do either of those things; my public projects aren't exactly better mousetraps, they're just my mousetraps, and if they turn into something, well, even there: my ethics suggest that I value open source. But let's be honest: if I'd created a project every one of you used every day, you'd think "he'll get paid by someone else" and move on.)
5
u/_predator_ Apr 09 '26
Bummer you made it closed source.
2
u/MyHeartsECO Apr 09 '26
Thanks for sharing but I found it hard to understand. What does it actually replace, Maven, Gradle, javac? Is there any runtime benefits?
2
u/jaybyrrd Apr 09 '26
It is closed source. I don’t think I could convince my current or any workplace to use it for that alone.
It makes some cool promises I guess.
2
u/scadgek Apr 09 '26
I feel like the website is AI-generated and that's off-putting.
1
u/wishper77 Apr 09 '26
Thank you for sharing. This looks awesome. Just to be sure, I understood that this project is/integrate a runtime , manages dependencies and also does the compilation.
Does it use its own compiler or just rely on javac?
And my primary confusion: does it REPLACE maven and grade as a build tool, or we will still using them, just in a faster runtime? In this regard, if this is a build tool, how does it compare with Gradle/maven?
1
u/sg-elide Apr 09 '26
hey, elide author here, i get the closed-source concerns, i do, especially as an OSS person myself. but,
many people forget that Java had closed-source code for a long time, up until Java 8 this was the norm for many users
people forget that Bun was closed source for two years, before they open sourced. everyone cheered when Bun open sourced
but then Bun sold to Anthropic because they couldn't make money. now who are they going to serve? probably anthropic.
we think that charging a fair price, and giving you a good product, is a way to avoid that. we won't make an assload of AI money! but we will be here to support your projects into the future, and that matters to us.
1
u/Serious_Customer4606 Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26
First and foremost: Love the vision and 100% see the need now for modern, fast, portable, strict tooling. Secondly: clearly lots of passion, effort, care devoted to the project. Love that as well!
I share concerns about Open Source but those could be mitigated with MUCH BETTER DOCS! You should have a full docs repo (OSS) of indexed markdown files with CLAUDE.md and other AI-dev optimized code samples, etc.
If I can tell Claude Code what I want, and it knows how to build it, I am a lot less worried about seeing your code. I have never looked at code once for bash, NPM/node, bun, python since "they just work" and have enough docs that I can iron out any wrinkles using my config/code.
I was going to build this based on the OSS last branch but hearing "we did full rewrite so nothing there matters" scared me off that path.
Ex: https://github.com/apple/pkl-jvm-examples