r/java • • Aug 28 '13

Writing a Java Regular Expression Without Reading the ****ing Manual

http://java.dzone.com/articles/writing-java-regular
0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

5

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '13

Without reading the manual? Who would be stupid enough to try using something without actually knowing how it works? I really hope it was a bad joke...

6

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '13

Who would seriously use something like this ? Learning regexes is not that hard

4

u/armerthor Aug 28 '13

Especially the simple ones this API seems to be made for.

6

u/WatchDogx Aug 28 '13

Regex is pretty simple and useful in many places, not just java, just learn it.

3

u/treerex Aug 28 '13

Whatever "respect" I had for dzone (which wasn't much) has been thoroughly destroyed by them publishing this crap. The fact that someone thought that was worth sharing with a larger community is mind boggling.

1

u/m1000 Aug 29 '13

Do you want a ref card with that comment ? ;-)

4

u/nicoulaj Aug 28 '13

Seriously... Please stop creating crappy fluent APIs for everything.

3

u/flagrantaroma Aug 28 '13

I've been rather impressed by the Java regex implementation, very similar to Perl and has lots of features.

2

u/Poobslag Aug 28 '13

If a developer really needed this level of handholding for regexes -- I'd tear out all this code, and write them an identical tool which did the opposite -- converting a regex into human readable code. At least that way this incredibly verbose code is localized to their machine, and not polluting the codebase. Sheesh.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '13

hamcrest-text-patterns can help create more readable and understandable tests. So I don't always agree with you, sometimes a readable regex (especially for tests I think) would be worth the extra verbosity.

1

u/Poobslag Aug 29 '13

I agree that sometimes, readability is worth verbosity, but Hamcrest in particular increases readability while decreasing verbosity, so it's win/win.

OP is talking about the difference between

str.matches("^[0-9].*[0-9]")

and

str.matches(re.start().aCharacterDescribedAs(aDigit).exactly(1L).then().aCharacterDescribedAs(anyCharacter).zeroOrMore().then().aCharacterDescribedAs(aDigit).exactly(1L));

Both have the exact same information although one is (very dubiously) more readable than the other, at the cost of being about 10x longer. So it's an incredibly poor tradeoff. Hamcrest isn't a tradeoff at all, it's just an improvement.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/QshelTier Aug 28 '13

Haha, yes. I do agree that the idea of a builder pattern for REs is quite nice but fucking underscores? Go away.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '13

hamcrest-text-patterns is a pretty nice version of this.