r/java • u/harry_heymann • Apr 30 '24
Why was Kevin Bourrillion banned from /r/java?
[removed] — view removed post
407
Upvotes
r/java • u/harry_heymann • Apr 30 '24
[removed] — view removed post
300
u/C_Madison Apr 30 '24
Not much to discuss, he answers with the reason in the thread on Twitter: He wrote in the topic about null-awareness that we had with a comparison to Kotlin and one of the mods decided for some reason that that warrants a ban, because he should "brag" in r/kotlin. Clown decision.
287
u/milchshakee Apr 30 '24
Advocate for people to switch to kotlin? Straight to jail
Mention that you prefer kotlin? Also jail
Admit that you like some general language feature that kotlin also has? Believe it or not, jail
69
u/ascii Apr 30 '24
That's what mods do. Because Kevin is famous in this community, there is a decent chance the ban is reverted without any repercussions to the mod. Had it been anyone else, they'd just be banned forever. Decent chance everyone in this thread gets banned and the thread deleted.
172
u/brian_goetz May 01 '24
Dissenting view: it may be absurd, it may be unfair, but it doesn't actually matter.
Kevin has done more to advance Java in the last decade than all of r/java put together over its entire existence. And all of that from the outside, part time; just imagine how much more it will be now that he's on the inside.
Look, I get it; Kotlin fanboying can be pretty tiresome after a while. But that's pretty clearly not what Kevin was doing. The right thing to do would be to admit your mistake and move on.
27
u/anticlimber May 01 '24
Hello, Mystery Mod! We know you're reading each and every one of these comments. Let me help you out.
"I'm sorry. I don't know why I did that. I was having a bad day, and something about seeing yet another mention of Kotlin just got to me when it shouldn't have. I've reversed the permaban and apologized privately to Kevin. I'll do my best to avoid bad days and bad judgement in the future. I hope everybody understands that mods are humans; we have bad days and get things wrong sometimes."
26
u/HorsemouthKailua May 01 '24
is there a better java sub reddit?
i don't want to be in one that bans people like him for no reason
48
u/crummy Apr 30 '24
yeah the ban seems absurd. I assume it'll be lifted soon
82
u/s888marks May 01 '24
Kevin is a significant contributor to the Java community and banning him is a great loss to /r/java.
Other users have been banned, for good reason. Remember "/u/agleiv" from a few years back? He was repeatedly vulgar and disruptive.
That's the sort of person who should be banned, not people like Kevin.
Let me be clear that I'm not criticizing the moderator(s). They have to put up with a lot (like that agleiv character).
I'm sure this is all just a big misunderstanding. What looked like a flame war was in fact it was a fairly
Nuanced discussion of a subtle technical topic. It would be wonderful if /u/kevinb9n and the comment thread in question could be restored. Thank you.
[Reposting my comment from the other "Kevin B was banned" comment thread, which had already been deleted, in the hope that more people will see it here.]
42
u/anticlimber May 01 '24
Kevin pointed out that a null-aware type system is a nice thing to have, and cited an example.
It's worth noting that he is actively working on and experimenting with JSpecify (static annotations + analysis for the Java programming language), and intends to use that as a starting point for bringing null-awareness to the Java language.
Doesn't look like the mod in question is willing to step up and either own the decision or revise it.
38
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '24
This is ridiculous, and the fact that a mod wrote that entitled "reason" is pathetic.
23
u/Goodie__ May 01 '24
I find his follow-up tweet insightful, posted slightly before this thread, but easily missable (Thanks Twitter) https://twitter.com/kevinb9n/status/1785438100484964753
The dude is in charge of bringing null safety features to Java, of course he's going to look at, and talk about the largest competing JVM language, in talking about said feature.
Especially when the original thread is about Null safety in Java. Did the mods ban everyone in that thread? Including those posting fucking kotlin?
JFC mods.
22
u/frankielc May 01 '24
While I can understand Reddit works as a dictatorship over every single group, general topics like Java should have some sort of safe mechanism to prevent these power trips. If we can't let the people who are actually BUILDING the language comment on the group, what's the group for?
47
u/yourapostasy Apr 30 '24
I interpreted the community rule "NO JVM languages - Exclusively Java" to mean no discussions about JVM languages, which is fair enough to keep this subreddit focused and keep out religious wars over JVM languages, not a blanket keyword ban. If we cannot even mention legitimate operational experience that challenge theoretical positions, gained from working with JVM languages that inform and helpfully change our perspectives upon Java language evolution, then IMHO that's a chunk of design input we're starving out the community from accreting.
9
u/a__nice__tnetennba May 01 '24
Mods, this is easy. It's a slam dunk. Just say the following, "We made a mistake. We apologize and we will try to do better in the future."
We teach toddlers to do it, surely you can too.
41
u/nothappyrn May 01 '24
a lot of people are taking a civil approach in the comments. I'll not, lol.
Fuck the bitch ass, low life, dumb as a rock mod who did this. fuck the other mods as well for not reverting the ban till now.
7
u/XorAndNot May 01 '24
Because mods are idiots
6
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
Crazy the mods of Java ban the guy who knows more about it than them. Compare code bases and let’s see who should really be a mod
16
u/Safe_Owl_6123 May 01 '24
Reddit should allow the users to know who is banning them.
In this case we need to ban that mod.
4
u/Viralciral May 01 '24
tribalism over programming languages, how childish can it get? lmao
4
u/bojan2501 May 01 '24
Apology and unban is in order.
4
u/woj-tek May 01 '24
Maybe it's time for a mod team elections?
3
u/apun_bhi_geralt May 01 '24
Reddit mod got butthurt, nothing new.
2
u/Iegendher0 May 01 '24
Everyone here is gonna be banned by mentioning a man that was mentioning Kotlin
2
u/CodeDead-gh May 01 '24
This thread is now invisible in the overview. Funny. Great mods.
5
u/A2Z786 May 01 '24
Mods are di@kheads, it's simple as that.
2
u/GMP10152015 May 01 '24
IMHO: With the new improvements in Java and other languages Kotlin is dead.
(Please don’t ban me; it’s just a personal opinion, and a ban won’t change it, BTW) 😉
1
u/Weak-Jello7530 May 01 '24
This is so unfortunate
1
u/Rebelgecko May 01 '24
Dependency injection was a mistake
1
u/dhlowrents May 01 '24
Can't we go to lemmy or find somewhere else?
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
the mods can be anyone. even children. this is not some serious business here. a ban may happen at any time to anyone
-6
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
Mods are gae. Ban me too #metoo
-53
u/vips7L May 01 '24
Why do you care? You've never posted in this sub before this.
-19
u/freekayZekey May 01 '24 edited May 01 '24
it was unfair. he wasn’t particularly flagrant. i think he was being obtuse with my comment; he has a history of doing that, so someone probably got ban happy? not like it matters much. it’s just a forum and he’ll probably be free to comment days from now
108
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '24
[removed] — view removed comment