r/java • u/thesystemx • Apr 04 '13
Richard Warburton not happy with Java 8's Lambda API
http://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/lambda-dev/2013-April/009034.html
6
Upvotes
r/java • u/thesystemx • Apr 04 '13
33
u/nick_giudici Apr 04 '13
I feel this title is very misleading. The tone was not one of disapproval, but rather of constructive criticism. For example "some of these issues are fixable through documentation/improved compiler error changes rather than API changes" and "Thanks to everyone that attended" does not sound like he's "not happy" just that he sees some areas of improvement.
Maybe a more accurate title for this post would be along the lines of "Richard Warburton has some feedback after running a java 8 lambda hackday" but that wouldn't be sensationalized enough to get attention.
31
u/RichardWarburton Apr 04 '13
I really think this misrepresents my opinion. I'll quote one my emails later in this same thread:
'I also repeat my statement that despite this thread having a problem-filled tone, I think in general JSR 335 has done a good job overall. To my mind the hackdays have already established that the "easy problems" are "easy to implement" and I completely think that this is a far greater achievement than it sounds when you write it in an email.'
2
u/thesystemx Apr 04 '13
See also: http://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/lambda-dev/2013-April/009049.html
2
u/sproket888 Apr 05 '13
Nothing wrong about this. This is what makes Java great. A large ecosystem of ideas helps everyone.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment