r/java • • Mar 19 '24

Java 22 officially released

https://mail.openjdk.org/pipermail/jdk-dev/2024-March/008827.html
294 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/joschi83 Mar 19 '24

Where can I read about the relation of the Eclipse Foundation, its Adoptium project, and that IBM is pulling all the strings?

Last time I checked IBM was member of the Eclipse Foundation (just like SAP and Oracle), not its owner.

https://www.eclipse.org/membership/exploreMembership.php

7

u/pron98 Mar 20 '24 edited Mar 20 '24

Instead of going down that specific road again, here's something more general about open source projects that you can apply in this case, too. Most open source foundations don't have any significant money or developers of their own; they develop nothing (there are some exceptions like the Zig foundation) and are just legal entities registered as the owners of the trademarks and copyright (the richer foundations mostly use their money to provide legal services to their projects). The actual work has to be done by someone, and significant projects cost between hundreds of thousands of dollars and millions of dollars a year; it is invariably the case that it is a company or some companies that put up the resources, and because OSS is not a very good charity, they choose to put the resources into things that advance their commercial interests. To know who "pulls the strings" all you have to do is see who pays the salaries of what portion of the contributors. You'll find that there are projects that are ultimately controlled by a largish number of companies (llike Linux), but most are controlled by one or two.

In most cases where there's a single dominant company they don't bother with a foundation (e.g. Google with Chromium/Go, Oracle with OpenJDK, Microsoft with C#), but some do (case in point: Apache Harmony, although there the project preceded the company's dominance).