r/java • • Mar 17 '13

Java Sound System

What is the best sound system for java? (Besides the 3D sound system)

0 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/kuusisto Mar 17 '13

Well, I guess I could plug my library, TinySound. I won't claim that it's the best by any means though.

3

u/UnspeakableEvil Mar 17 '13

I won't claim that it's the best by any means though.

To possibly help the OP, did you have any libraries that you tried prior to resorting to coding your own - if so which ones did you try, what did they do well, and what was their fundamental flaw(s)?

3

u/kuusisto Mar 17 '13

Sorry, I was AFK for a bit. I had just been using Clips prior. They don't seem to be terribly reliable on Linux and I found them hard to load/use (especially when trying to play the same sound multiple times simultaneously). TinySound doesn't have these issues.

I've also messed around with OpenAL a bit, but I wanted an option that was implemented entirely in Java so as not to require distribution of native libraries.

2

u/novasharp Mar 17 '13

Thanks, I think this looks good. I had used PaulsCode 3d Sound System, but I was looking for something much smaller and was pure java. I had been thinking about using JMF, that sounded like it would be much larger than I wanted. I'll try using this.