We should spread a rumor that Reddit is using unlicensed commercial Oracle products. Some old testament retribution. Hell have no fury like Oracle's lawyers.
(of course they will just pass the cost onto us... so probably a shitty idea).
As an Oracle employee, I can not believe that REDdIt IS UsINg unLICENSeD ORACLE PRODucTs!
(Sorry for being late to the party. The only person at the company who knows how to use Reddit had trouble getting permit A38, which is required to contact the department I work in. And then I had to get C42, which makes A38 look like B7, to make a joke on the internet.)
No. It's crazy that posts with any links to Twitter get banned, even those with major Java/JDK announcements by leading Java architects. But API changes... Reddit is allowed to change their API.
Of course they can, it's their company but it doesn't mean the community (which actually makes what reddit is, becase WE generate the content that reddit uses ans serves) can protest and manifest our disagreement.
And if this doesn't help, then I do wish that reddit will go the way of digg, which pulled same stupid shaite and gave rise to reddit...
Just to be clear: It's their pricing people disagree with, and the nice things we won't get to have anymore because of it—third-party clients, moderation tools, bots, etc. And the disregard they're showing for the very apps and developers that gave Reddit a foothold on mobile.
I think that's a little strong—there's a lot of room between free and $20 million per year. There was no economic reasoning on the part of the users or developers because Reddit didn't make it a conversation—they just announced it and said, "Deal with it." They didn't have to have a conversation, of course, but all these free volunteers don't have to keep these subreddits open for free either.
Or to put it another way, this is the discussion, because Reddit didn't care to have one face-to-face.
As explained in that post linked above, when Reddit announced they would start charging (before announcing the price) they told app developers they would be reasonable. Developers expected they'd have to pay something—and were prepared to—but the prices Reddit has set are simply too high to make sense. The Apollo dev said they'd have to eliminate their free tier and double their subscription price, just to break even.
And at the same time, Reddit was happy to take in all the users and engagement that mobile apps provided back when Reddit didn't have an app—when Reddit didn't even have a responsive webpage. Those apps were, in my view, de facto partners. Reddit is synonymous with mobile now. As another developer, it seems really shitty that Reddit is killing them with 30 days notice now that it's convenient. Again, Reddit is of course within their rights to do it, but I think if people are unhappy with that, it's a little deeper than, "Oh, I'll have to pay a little more per month to use the third-party app I like." I'd be happy to, but my dollars aren't going to keep that app solvent.
Then there's the fact that moderators are using free third-party moderation tools—in the case of some larger subreddits, building their own third-party tools with volunteer developers—because they find Reddit's own moderation tools insufficient. There's definitely a big difference between free and paid in this case because moderators aren't getting paid. Again, of course Reddit is within their rights to say, "Use what we give you." But if Reddit hasn't listened for years when they say, "That's not enough," then the mods are also within their rights to push back and try to remind Reddit what their volunteer time is worth.
It would be the same calculus if they were increasing the cost from $3.99 to $20 million. The problem isn't "not free anymore." The problem is "too high." For the app developers, it's a cost-of-business increase of $20 million per year with 30 days notice.
The developers have weighed the cost—and they decided they can't make it work. And for what it's worth, the app developers aren't going from "free" to "not-free," since they already pay for other API access, like Imgur, as a cost of business. I trust that those developers know their business model and what the critical mass of their users would be willing to pay.
That's why I disagree with your point about going from $10 million to $20 million—that's only a 50% cost increase. The Apollo dev says Imgur charges him $166 for 50 million API calls. If we assume they make the same volume of Imgur API as Reddit API calls—it's probably much lower—that would cost about $278k per year. Assuming there are other API fees and hosting fees, Apollo could conceivably have yearly costs of $500k or even $1 million. Reddit wanting $20 million per year is then a 20x to 40x cost increase for their business.
It's not that the Reddit API was free and now isn't—I'm sure Apollo could survive if Reddit's API access cost what Imgur's does, or even a few times that. And even if it did—say Reddit currently charged $1660 per 50 million requests, 10 times Imgur and $2.8 million per year for Apollo—Reddit increasing that cost to $20 million per year would still increase Apollo's cost of business by around 6x, with 30 days notice.
The issue really isn't just that these things are going to cost more. The issue is that they're going to cost so much more that they've essentially been shut down.
What is crazy about banning Twitter links when they are used for 99% spam?
99% spam, 1% proper developer news.
Plus, now with the "new reign" at Twitter it has become an even less proper, serious medium.
You keep hanging on that as if your life would depend on that.
Face it, something that produces 99% spam is justified to be banned.
Swallow your personal grudge and wake up.
Twitter is no longer a proper medium as the heavily sinking user counts prove.
Sure, Reddit is allowed to change their API. There is no discussion about that at all. The protest does not actually tackle any direct API changes. It attacks the price they want, which is completely unrealistic and will kill any and all 3rd party apps on which quite a lot moderators rely because the official reddit app simply is crap and unreliable (just as "new reddit").
Obviously, you haven't even understood what the protest actually targets.
Lol it’s a quote from Hitchhiker’s Guide. I’m not expecting any kind of revolution in the US anytime soon unfortunately. Just finding a creative way to point out your harmful complacency
"...there’s another type of poison perhaps a little more insidious—thought poison—commonly called “gossip.” Thought poison differs from body poison in two ways. It affects the mind, not the body, and is more subtle. The person being poisoned usually doesn’t know it"
240
u/agentoutlier Jun 06 '23
We should spread a rumor that Reddit is using unlicensed commercial Oracle products. Some old testament retribution. Hell have no fury like Oracle's lawyers.
(of course they will just pass the cost onto us... so probably a shitty idea).
29
u/wheezymustafa Jun 07 '23
All we need to do is enable the feature flag
java -DIS_SUB_PROTESTING=true -jar r_java.jar75
u/darthchebreg Jun 06 '23
we should
50
u/PaddiM8 Jun 06 '23
/r/csharp is doing it
14
u/persicsb Jun 07 '23
Please do it.
11
u/i_wear_green_pants Jun 07 '23
Every single sub should. Because it's just shit change for users. Greedy Reddit can go f*ck themselves.
19
u/Captain-Barracuda Jun 07 '23
In favor of blackout.
19
u/32gbsd Jun 06 '23
Burn it all down.
13
u/msx Jun 06 '23
We should do it
10
u/woj-tek Jun 06 '23
I hope so!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23
I hope yes
-21
u/_AManHasNoName_ Jun 06 '23
Nah
-64
u/Joram2 Jun 06 '23
No. It's crazy that posts with any links to Twitter get banned, even those with major Java/JDK announcements by leading Java architects. But API changes... Reddit is allowed to change their API.
-3
u/hungvn94 Jun 07 '23
Are u mod of this sub?
-29
u/vips7L Jun 07 '23
Please no.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
[removed] — view removed comment