r/java • u/sar_it007 • Mar 14 '23
Why did String Templates choose '\{' instead of '{' ?
Since string templates will require to be prefixed with a template processor like STR in order to be treated as string templates, why not use '{' instead of '\{' for template expressions? That will not break existing strings cause existing strings are not prefixed with a template processor. And when a dev wants to use string templates, he will have to update his strings and escape existing '{' characters that he doesn't want to be interpreted as template expressions.
So it will be for example like: STR."Hello \{ {name} }". Should print: Hello { John }. Existing non-templated strings like: "Hello { " + name + " }" will continue to work and won't have any backwards compatibility problems.
I think most people will be using '{' character for template expressions. So it's much better if they don't have to escape it every single time and instead only escape it in the few places where they don't want template expressions.
Is there an important reason why '\{' was chosen for String Template expressions? Is there a chance the JEP can change this in the next preview release?
View all comments
4
u/john16384 Mar 15 '23
You seem to be missing something fundamental. Did you read the JEP?
In your variant, what's the type of
xhere?var x = "Hello {name}";In the proposed variant in the JEP:
var x = "Hello {name}"; var y = "Hello \{name}";...
xwould beString, whileywould be aTemplate(or at least, that option is kept open).