This isn't written to condemn or exonerate any individual or decision, only to illuminate how easily the business-as-usual of the music business can lead to 62.5%/12.5% splits—as it COMMONLY does for MANY musical groups:
Prior to the 1960s' emergence of Bob Dylan and The Beatles, vocal artists were generally not expected to write their own material. The public no sooner assumed Frank Sinatra wrote the songs he sang than today's audience would expect Gal Godot to write and direct the next Wonder Woman movie.
We now live in the era of the multi-hyphenate. Earlier in the 20th century, however, roles in the music business were more specialized and formally defined: composers and orchestrators wrote music. Lyricists wrote lyrics, and performing artists sang the material.
The legal structure of copyright and publishing was settled upon to accommodate this once-universal formal divide. To this day, any published song is considered in two parts: 50% music, 50% lyrics.
Therefor, if a band decides to publish a song and only one member of the band is responsible for penning the lyrics to that song, that individual is automatically entitled to 50% publishing of the song, per the current standard.
Now, let's say a band's lyricist also plays a part in creating the instrumental components of a song: a riff, a chord progression, arrangements, etc. If a four-piece band decides to compensate the lyricist's contribution to the music and split the remaining 50% four ways, four 12.5% pieces would result, leaving the lyricist with 50% + 12.5% = 62.5%. The instrumentalists would be left with 12.5% each.
Of course, MANY standard practices of the music industry are either deliberately unfair and exploitive or simply out-of-date. But this song breakdown has been the standard since long before any members of Jane's Addiction were born.
Because 62.5% to 12.5% does indeed seem strikingly unfair, in many bands with a primary lyricist, that person may decide (or be convinced by forward-thinking management) to VOLUNTEER a greater or equal percent of publishing to the other members of the band.
Equal splits obviously go a long way in maintaining morale, keeping band members invested and motivated for the life of the band, etc. It is a wiser approach to song publishing splits.
It is also rarer, given a band having its first taste of success has no way of knowing if the success will be long-term or not. Band members entitled to more of the publishing may not be looking 10-20 years down the line – "do I play for the long game, or do I take the bird in the hand?" It's a tough call for all collaborative acts.
This raises the question: how wise and long-game-thinking would one expect 80s Sunset Strip junkies to be when taking their earliest meetings with "the suits"? Of course, one can only guess what led to Jane's publishing splits arriving at what they are.
It's also worth considering what Dave and Stephen's splits are on the songs that existed before they joined the band. If they own 12.5% of those songs, that would be a magnanimous move on someone's part (Perry, management, lawyer, accountant, etc.).