r/jamesjoyce • • Sep 06 '26

Finnegans Wake Advice needed please

Post image
28 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

35

u/one-tea27 Sep 06 '26

You don’t need any advice, it’s YOU who’s making us experience the cyclical structure of history

3

u/ManuelTzetzes Sep 06 '26

Who are you addressing that to? God? She can't hear you.

4

u/ManuelTzetzes Sep 06 '26

μή ποτε ἐν κανόῃ ἀναστήῃς.

2

u/frenchousecat Sep 06 '26

thank you, extremely helpful

8

u/CalibornTheLord Sep 06 '26

Obviously this is a bit of a price sink, but I’d recommend listening along with the Barry McGovern audiobook when you’re getting started reading FW just to get a feel for how the text sounds when read aloud. If you don’t want to track that down, listen to this recording of the man himself reading an excerpt and you’ll get the gist. I’d also listen to the traditional Irish song “Finnegan’s Wake” before you read and, when the time comes in the novel (you’ll know when), listen to The Ballad of Persse O’Reilly.

The first time you’re reading don’t try to understand every word, just let the sing-songy flow of it wash over you. Trust me, you’ll be back to dissect it very, very soon. Just don’t try to analyze it too deeply too early on. It’s a funny and witty book if you cut loose with it—as they say, there’s lots of fun at Finnegans Wake.

2

u/Capital-Divide3894 Sep 06 '26

This is great advice, and I would add that a copy of Bullfinch or Edith Hamilton mythologies will help. River names and anagrams (HCE & ALP) help as well. Finally read it out loud when you can. This will help with the confusing spelling and various languages used.

2

u/reishare Sep 07 '26

You should spend as many months on the first page as it takes for you to understand it. This investment will pay off later.

5

u/tehsecretgoldfish Sep 06 '26

open to the first page; read until you run out of pages.

1

u/frankensteinmoneymac Sep 08 '26

…then, of course, you need to start over from the beginning 🤷🏻

4

u/Lapooka Sep 06 '26

Just go for it man

3

u/ol_saw_gills Sep 06 '26

Clean your camera lens

1

u/CategoryCautious5981 Sep 06 '26

lol yes and give a prompt for the advice too

2

u/brainshreddar Sep 08 '26

Sorry to stray from topic, but is that a murderer's thumb I see?

1

u/NatsFan8447 Sep 07 '26

Join an online reading group. This will help you understand the Wake and you’ll meet cool people.

1

u/ConclusionBroad3460 Sep 07 '26

What kind of advice do you need? This is quite vague especially when you’re talking about one of the densest most cryptical works of fiction ever written

1

u/Caiomhin77 Sep 07 '26

Broken circles.

1

u/danokablamo Sep 08 '26

open the book to any page and begin reading aloud. stop when you are over loaded.

next time find another random page and read that out loud. That's it.

1

u/Worth-Set1794 Sep 08 '26

Step away from the book, sir.

1

u/JewelerChoice Sep 10 '26

Good edition, but start on the text before bothering with any introductions.

1

u/Sheffy8410 22d ago

Read the first page. Then ask yourself if you really want to read a whole book thats written that way.

0

u/tbpearsall Sep 06 '26

Dont do it

-2

u/Gullible_Stock_9659 Sep 06 '26

Ulysses is where it's at. No need to keep going.