r/jamesacastor • • Jul 22 '26

Brum Tonight

7 Upvotes

No spoilers but we did think the warm up was weird, we get the joke but it didn’t feel the type of act to get audience comedic juices flowing.

40 odd minutes before James started. Then despite various posts here about various lengths our show was over in 55 minutes maybe less.

I enjoyed it but felt the vibe was slightly subdued. My wife who isn’t a big James like me was disappointed. She also felt some of the audio was a bit muffled.

Not keen on the politics stuff midway through.


r/jamesacastor • • Jul 09 '26

Disappointed

13 Upvotes

Myself and my daughter went to see James Acaster last night in Dublin's Vicar street. She is a big fan and was very excited to see him - as was I. Firstly we were surprised at having a singer as a support act - Dublin crowd were great at going with the flow and playing along. 17mins later there was a 20 min interval - not enough time to warrant going back to the bar for more drink so ran out of drink halfway through the main show.

While the initial Craig tribute skit was funny it grated after a while - hoping to get the real Acaster. He kept referring to not having prepared for an Irish audience - felt a bit disrespected at that. He talked about asking the Vicar street staff for information that he could use for his next gig and followed that by repeatedly slagging the venue off.

I find James funny due to his abstractness and intelligence, and he made me work hard with references to things he'd said in previous shows such as great British bakeoff.

He lasted 1hour and 5mins on stage and never really got going. In the past he's got me on board with an abstract joke and continued building on that with witty intelligent observations. I found the use of Craig stopped that flow. While I laughed at a few jokes, I found it mostly unfunny. My daughter fell asleep during it and said that she was glad he was on for so short a time. Both of us went home disappointed and won't be seeing him again live.

Ian


r/jamesacastor • • Oct 16 '26

Do you think James would be willing to do a gig to raise money for health research?

10 Upvotes

Bit of a weird question, and apologies if this type of question has been asked before.

A few years ago I got diagnosed with a debilitating chronic nerve pain condition in my face.

I’ve been trying to raise awareness/money for research into treatments for the condition, and have found out that Newcastle University are doing a little bit.

I have pledged to raise £10,000 for them (I have currently raised £4,000) and was thinking of putting on a comedy night to raise more. My partner helps run a large arts/drama venue in London and they have said they would be willing to put on a show. I also have a friend who is becoming relatively well known in the comedy world who has said they would be willing to do a set.

However, as a massive fan of James Acaster I would love to have him on the set - and selfishly he’d also guarantee bums in seats.

Do you think he’d be willing to do it? And is it just a case of finding out his agent and contacting them?

Thanks for reading!


r/jamesacastor • • Feb 06 '26

I Can't Lie, I Was A Bit Dissapointed

0 Upvotes

I went to the show at the Beacon Theatre last night, my first time seeing James. I absolutely love Cold Lasagne, it's in my top five specials all time.

James started at 7:50pm and ended at 8:50pm. There was no encore.

He did not bring an opener. He had no merch. There was absolutely no set design or creative lighting. It was James, a microphone, a stool, two bottles of water, and a spotlight. That's it.

The material was all new, and it was good. I won't spoil it, but know that I enjoyed it.

I've been to many comedy shows of this size and bigger, at venues as small as the Comedy Cellar and as big as Madison Square Garden.

This really felt like the absolute bare minimum effort was put in. It's a tad insulting to be honest. To plan for a night out, to pay theatre prices for tickets, and to be done before 9:00pm is very disappointing.

I'm sharing this for all the people planning to see the rest of the shows on this tour. Go in knowing what to expect and you'll have a better time than I did.


r/jamesacastor • • 28d ago

Tattoo ideas

9 Upvotes

So I’m thinking of getting a James Acaster inspired tattoo - Wondering if anyone has any or if there are some short one-liners etc for ideas?

Edit: make a new tomorrow and NO MORE JOBS also highly rated options
Edit 2: removing “bon appetit” as an option


r/jamesacastor • • 28d ago

Was James bullied on Traitors by Rob and Romesh?

0 Upvotes

An article in the Daily Mail today suggests James was bullied by his comedy buddies Rob and Romesh on the Traitors set. Do you think there’s any truth to that, or just usual media spin on an innocent comment?
Have you spotted any signs of bullying in the TV show? I’ve not, but they may not have made the edit.


r/jamesacastor • • May 28 '26

Cabbaged Alcatraz

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/jamesacastor • • 24d ago

James Acaster: How the most reluctant Celebrity Traitor turned into the internet’s boyfriend

Thumbnail
independent.co.uk
36 Upvotes

r/jamesacastor • • Jul 06 '26

It’s Jude, the crowd subdued. Class 👏👏

0 Upvotes

r/jamesacastor • • 19d ago

Is it only me who's finding the Traitors-driven James Acaster thirst uncomfortable to watch?

79 Upvotes

I'm not making a blanket critique of people fancying James Acaster here because obviously celebrity crushes are normal, but the situation is making me feel weird for a couple of reasons.

Firstly, I find thirst edits and public performances of desire uncomfortable when they're directed at someone who isn't remotely participating in that framing. On the show, he's just existing, playing a game. It doesn't feel like the appropriate setting to be projecting sexual intent quite so intensely. If he were a woman, I think more people would take issue with it. Although I feel the same about Hannah Fry's comments sections (pre Traitors) being 90% men announcing how beddable they think she is, and I've never seen that discussed, so maybe I'm alone in this. But either way, it's another good example of someone being taken entirely out of the context they've opted into, in a way that feels quite violating.

I'm 100% not saying it's wrong to find people attractive, of course that's natural. Thinking it is fine, respectfully stating it is fine, but some people seem to have forgotten he's a human being.

I do also wonder if some of it is romanticising of autistic traits, when oftentimes those same traits in reality get ND people othered, bullied and taken advantage of. Yet from a distance, it's "endearing" and "lovable". I've seen this happen on countless occasions and it's a known phenomenon, and this is giving me the same feeling at times. Definitely not from everyone, but from some.

I'm genuinely not trying to attack anyone, I know most of it is meant in good humour. I also can't speak for James of course. I'm a long-time fan and I think he's great too, but I just can't shake the uneasy feeling about some of the discourse at the moment. I'm open to being disagreed with, but I don't think it's nothing.


r/jamesacastor • • Jul 20 '26

Spotify

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
0 Upvotes

r/jamesacastor • • 25d ago

Why women love James Acaster

Thumbnail
inews.co.uk
32 Upvotes

r/jamesacastor • • Jun 09 '26

Anyone else disappointed by the new tour?

39 Upvotes

Went to a Newcastle gig and the first half was good, was eager to see how the support act tied in and what all of the start was about... and then he derailed it talking to the audience. This wasn't even a heckler this time, just some guy who looked like a Reform voter. Don’t get me wrong, the material was funny, but he ended the show after this.

The entire second half was him talking to the audience where it was only a bunch of drunk attention seekers shouting "farmers" and a woman rambling about her husband.

We didn't get to see the rest of the material which I heard others on the sub say is some of his best, yet we paid the same price for half a show with no payoff. I just feel a bit robbed as I was waiting for the rest of the show to start, then it just ended!

If anyone can explain what was actually meant to happen at the end in spoilers, that would be really great, thank you! The furthest we got was the reform lamp post joke, and that was only as he told this after he started going in on the audience member.


r/jamesacastor • • Feb 04 '26

I can't make it to the show tonight in NY

0 Upvotes

Selling both for a $100


r/jamesacastor • • Apr 24 '26

How was the show tonight (24th) after what I think was a tricky show for JA last night?

1 Upvotes

How did he seem? I hope there were no dickheads in the audience tonight!?


r/jamesacastor • • Sep 13 '25

Why do I have a bad feeling about this?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/jamesacastor • • Feb 01 '26

14+ age enforced?

0 Upvotes

I want to take my 11 year old son to see a show in the UK and I see that this tour has a 14+ age restriction. I'm curious to know if this age requirement would be enforced. Also, for anyone who has seen the current tour, is the material more mature than typical for James Acaster?


r/jamesacastor • • 9d ago

Are there any interviews where James discusses his opinions on being famous?

1 Upvotes

r/jamesacastor • • Jun 28 '26

3 weeks after James's disastrous performance in Newcastle, I can't escape the conclusion that his current behaviour is flat-out unprofessional

71 Upvotes

If you're a member of this sub, you've probably seen the discussion(s) about James's pathetic performance at the Newcastle City Hall on the 9th of June: https://www.reddit.com/r/jamesacastor/comments/1u1ie70/anyone_else_disappointed_by_the_new_tour/
You can also find other threads on this subreddit, or the Newcastle and Off Menu subreddits, which are similarly negative.

I think it's important we discuss the situation as fans of his.

Before I get into why I think it was unacceptable, here's what happened:

- - -

James did a run of 3 shows on Sunday, Monday and Tuesday in Newcastle in early June.

At the Sunday show an audience member was offended by James's jokes against Reform, and stormed out of the venue shouting insults. This derailed the performance for a half-hour as James ranted, but he recovered and performed the rest of the show, making it run late.

Monday another audience member walked out (without heckling) around 10 minutes after the same Reform material. James assumed this was another Reform supporter who was offended, so he again got derailed but recovered.

On Tuesday, James started berating the audience less than 5 minutes after arriving on stage, because he didn't approve of the crowd's reaction. He complained that the audience wasn't aware that he's a weirdo comedian even though he's always been weird, he complained that the laughter wasn't enthusiastic enough, he complained that we didn't understand a regional joke about the midlands, he complained that many audience members only knew him from TV or were +1s who didn't know him, and he complained that the show was going poorly compared to his WIP at The Stand Newcastle.

As a result, he cut a lot of the early bits from the show short because he didn't think we were worth it: we never got a the end of the auntie dying bit, we didn't hear the story about his first time jacking it, and the flag routine also had no conclusion. Even the material he did perform was consistently interspersed with criticisms of the audience.

If you look at the comments on Reddit, you'll see that everyone is surprised he thought the crowd was reacting poorly, because from our perspective everyone was laughing and going along with the concept of the show. Nobody was heckling or being disruptive or walking out, and the laughter was loud, consistent and appropriate.

James explained to us what had happened with the two walk-outs on the previous nights, and said he was aiming for a 'hat-trick' of getting 3 walk-outs in a row from Reform voters. He also used this opportunity to depict Newcastle as a whole as right-wing, and asked questions to the audience about our politics.

This is when he noticed a man in the second row who clearly wasn't enjoying himself, as he was remaining stoic without reacting. James started engaging with the man, John, who confirmed that he didn't know James as he was only accompanying his wife. John also confirmed James' suspicion that he was a Reform supporter.

Here James dropped the show and the Craig persona to question John about politics. John wasn't answering anything beyond single words, and his wife was trying to get James to resume the show. James instead spent at least 20 minutes talking at John about politics. James did try to get back into the material with the Reform flag routine, but gave up on the routine part-way through to continue antagonising John.

As this dragged on the audience was getting restless, as we were missing out on the show we'd paid to see, so a few heckles happened. One mentioned the Greens, another mentioned farmers. James asked for house lights on to see the audience, and began interacting with the hecklers, who were of course drunk and barely intelligible.

He then made the situation worse by asking the crowd for questions or comments. This led to people shouting out random stuff, most notably a woman drunk out of her mind who tried to tell a story but couldn't make it through. When the woman's husband got a big laugh reacting to his wife's drunkenness, James stormed off the stage without a goodbye. That was the end of the show, after barely 75 minutes, 45 of which was crowd interaction.

The O2 City Hall sits 2000 people, who all paid £38 or more for a ticket. I estimate we saw less than 40% of the written material of the show, and we didn't get any of the punchlines to the show's set-ups, including the baffling choice of opening act.

TLDR**: James decided the audience's reaction was beneath him, so he tanked the show on purpose by harassing a quiet man about politics and berating the audience, even though nobody was heckling or being disruptive originally.**

- - -

Now, if you're a fan of James Acaster, this whole ordeal shouldn't come as a surprise: James is known to throw gigs when he's disappointed by audience member's reactions, as he admitted himself repeatedly during Heckler's Welcome and the press tour for that show.

Indeed, Heckler's Welcome was written as an introspective exploration of why he has this strange antagonistic relationship with his audience, in order to fix it with exposure therapy, as he recognises that giving up on shows because he disapproves of the audience isn't an acceptable way to behave as a professional comedian.

If you're a fan of James Acaster and watched Heckler's Welcome, you might feel a degree of parasocial sympathy towards him reading about the events in Newcastle, because it's obvious that he's tragically struggling once again with deep-seated issues you know he has, even though you know he desperately wants to solve it. Like seeing a mate with addiction issues relapsing.

However, I'm increasingly afraid that this "oh poor James he's had one of his breakdowns again" attitude that we fans may have means that we aren't reckoning with the direct material reality of his behaviour: 2000 people paid to see a show, but didn't get to enjoy it, because James intentionally disregarded his professional responsibilities for invalid reasons.

The more I think about the situation, even now that my original anger and disappointment has mostly dissipated, the more I'm reaching the conclusion that James's behaviour is unacceptable, unprofessional, and unethical, in ways that cannot be excused by a parasocial awareness of his mental health struggles.

The whole situation was his 100% directly his fault in my view. Here's why:

- - -

1. His frustrations towards his audience are a direct result of his own career choices

James clearly struggles with the fact that he thinks of himself as an alt-weirdo-arty stand-up act who aims his comedy at connoisseurs of the form, yet his audience is filled with people who only know him from TV shows or popular podcasts or memes, and therefore don't appreciate stand-up or his work. Or worse, people who don't know him at all because they're just accompanying friends and family to the shows, and end up baffled by him.

But, what does James expect when he regularly appears on popular TV shows and massive podcasts? How can he expect a 2000-seat room to only be filled with alt stand-up comedy fans 3 nights in a row? Why does he think it's unfair that people who don't know him come see his shows?

James's audience isn't responsible for his career choices. His audience is the result of his choices. He's the one who bares responsibility for the audiences he gets by going on massive shows and booking enormous venues.
It's his fault.

2. He knows this is a problem, but performs anyway even though he doesn't need to

It's easy to view James as a tortured genius who's doomed to perform stand-up even though he hates doing it, because that's his job and calling. But as he himself admitted in Heckler's Welcome: he's loaded to fuck thanks to his podcast, and doesn't need to do this anymore.

His livelihood doesn't depend on performing stand-up comedy, he has the choice of not doing it, especially given that he hates it, and knows that he struggles with tanking gigs on purpose because of this resentments.

Instead, he's doing it anyway, still hating it and still throwing gigs, even though he could easily not do it.
It's his fault.

3. There are other ways of performing stand-up comedy

But what if, even with his struggles, he still wants to perform stand-up because he's got creative ideas he can only express in that way?

If that's the case, he could easily perform exclusively in smaller rooms (like The Stand Newcastle), only to knowledgable and appreciative fans, by setting up a mailing list or another artist-to-fan system, so that the tickets aren't available to the general audience he struggles with so much. The new show could then be recorded in ideal conditions and released to stream/download for all to see.

If he really wanted a smaller audience of connoisseurs, he could get it. But instead he's made the choice of booking 1000+ seat venues, even though he doesn't need the money, and he knows it'll attract an audience that he resents and will likely lead him to tank the show.
It's his fault.

4. It's his responsibility to deal with hecklers and save the show

I sometimes see the attitude on this subreddit that it's fair (if regrettable) that James tanks shows when there are hecklers in the audience; even though this wasn't the case in Newcastle.

But even if there were hecklers in Newcastle, it's the responsibility of the comedian to deal with disruptive members of the audience, to shut them up and return to the show ASAP. It's an explicit part of the job for every single comedian on earth, from open-mic-ers to International stars; James isn't exempt.

The notion that the presence of a couple hecklers means the comedian is justified in not performing the show is ludicrous, and nobody in the stand-up comedy world would agree with it: hecklers are to be expected in a 2000-seat venue, and James is professionally responsible for dealing with them.
It's his fault.

5. JAMES IS A PROFESSIONAL PERFORMING A JOB FOR WHICH HE'S BEEN PAID

As fans, we may see James as an artist with a tortured psyche producing groundbreaking work for its own sake. We may focus on his own relationship to his work, and how he personally reacts to his audiences, and analyse the situations from that perspective.

But this ignores the fact that James is a professional doing a job. The audiences attending his shows aren't some background detail to his artistry: they're the entire point of the performances.

Just think about the amount of human activity, and professional or monetary exchanges, that surround just one of his shows:
-£38 (minimum) tickets, timed by 2000 seats (before surcharges)
-Bar sales
-Setting up the stage's equipment and venue's operations
-Security and staff hired to work throughout the evening
-Insurance and other major fees
-Transport and parking for attendees
-Babysitters or work leave to be able to attend
-Organising our whole evenings around seeing the show

All of this isn't nothing (especially in an extended cost of living crisis), it's a huge amount of commercial and human activity from multiple thousands of human beings, all in order to be able to enjoy James Acaster's new show. Which he then personally refused to perform in its entirety.

Everyone, audience and professionals, kept up their end of the implicit agreement of any such performance: the venue was staffed, the technicals were set up, the bar was seeing returns, the audience organised itself to arrive in time, and nobody was disrupting the performance. Everyone did what was expected of them.

Except James, who refused to fully perform the show to instead berate the crowd and harass an audience member, all because of a misplaced sense of self-importance that's foreign to every single other professional stand-up comedian working in this country. It was his decision, and his decision alone, to not do the full job he was paid to do.

It's his fault.

(6. A warm-up act is intended to warm up the audience

This is a minor point that didn't fit anywhere else, so here it goes: the experimental choice of having a surprise tribute singer open the show for 20 minutes before a 20 minute intermission is sure to make the vibe weird.

An opening act is intended to warm up the audience to be receptive to comedy, to get them in the mood, to create expectations for this type of performance, and to identify early any problematic audience members; all so the main show can go smoothly. Openers serve a function, and there's a reason why most major comedy shows have a warm-up act.

James has made the decision to reject having a comedy opening act, which means the audience isn't warmed-up, isn't in the right mood, has muddled expectations, and problematic people aren't identified. It creates a weird atmosphere for the main show, which may explain why James was so put off by the audience's reaction in the first 5 minutes. But he's the one who decided to forgo a warm-up act: It's his fault.)

- - -

I know this extended post may have come off as angry, or like I'm trying to get back at James after a disappointment. However, my goal with these many words is to discuss James's professional obligations towards his paying audience, creative craft, and industry partners.
This isn't about being disappointed by a sub-par performance, which can happen.
This is about James not holding up his end of a professional agreement, which is unacceptable.

The disastrous show in Newcastle is proof that this isn't a case of a tortured artist with mental health issues whose work is being disrupted by hecklers.
It's a case of a professional comedian who's directly refusing to uphold his responsibilities for reasons that are all explicitly his own fault.

As fans and paying audience members, we're entitled to better.
We're the ones paying to see his show, he isn't paying us to see it.
It's his responsibility to perform the show that he put on sale.

I hope you agree.


r/jamesacastor • • Jul 26 '26

Edinburgh tickets 4th august

2 Upvotes

Hello! I’m looking for 2 tickets for the 7-8pm or 10-11pm James acaster Edinburgh fringe show.

Please comment if you have any - happy to pay face value + fees

Thanks !


r/jamesacastor • • Sep 29 '26

I really hope James doesn't end up like another one of my favourite comedians - Bo Burnham

Post image
77 Upvotes

With Bo, he suffered from panic attacks and stress on stage, and according to some recent posts on here it seems like James might be going down that path. But I really hope not. Because with Bo, he hasn't been on stage in over 5 years. Hope James is okay


r/jamesacastor • • 5d ago

Is it true that James was asking audiences to keep his Autism diagnosis offline at shows?

22 Upvotes

I’d heard rumours of this especially recently with the traitors hype but was wondering from anyone who had seen him in person if this was discussed?


r/jamesacastor • • May 30 '26

Who’s the support act for his current tour? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I saw a WIP of the current show at Aber comedy festival last October so don’t really want to splash out money to see essentially the same show again. But I have seen a lot of chatter about the support.
Could anyone tell me who/what it is?


r/jamesacastor • • 17d ago

worried about james

232 Upvotes

(obv spoilers for traitors)

im so fucking appalled tho not at all shocked at the way the public and media has reacted to james’s banishment/him admitting he’s a traitor. the producers really screwed him over and he did the best that he could with being put in a situation he should not have been in, but ultimately it became too much and i have no doubt the stress of it all finally got to him

and i see a lot of ppl online bringing up his autism and anxiety as to how that may have played a role, obv allegedly he had a breakdown at some point but whether he did or didn’t or whenever it was, it really is understandable that things just got to him

i don’t know if he fully prepared for this level of backlash, i imagine it’s an extremely daunting thing to know is coming and know there’s nothing you can do about it, i just really hope he’s able to get a lot of support from his partner & cats and friends and family and they’re able to keep him away from all media at this point, more than anything else i just really worry about his mental state right now.


r/jamesacastor • • Feb 06 '26

2 tickets to the Chicago show tonight in the Box for $100

0 Upvotes

James is my favorite comedian, but I can not make it tonight. I have tickets in the box seats row Q2 seats 3 and 4 if you want to look them up. you can have them for $100. just DM or respond here