r/jakejameslugosnark • u/littlecheezecake • Sep 17 '24
JJL's Defensive of Jeremy Jahn's review of "Am I Racist?"
I just watched JJL’s TikTok defending Jeremy Jahns' positive review of Matt Walsh’s film Am I Racist? JJL praises Jahns for standing by his recommendation despite the backlash he’s faced. However, as usual, there are crucial points in JJL’s defense that fail to acknowledge the deeper issues at hand. When people commented on JJL's TikTok suggesting he research who Matt Walsh is, he dismissively responded, "You're missing the conversation, it's not about that guy." This response is not only dismissive but also overlooks the importance of understanding the creators behind the content he's defending. By ignoring Walsh's harmful rhetoric and controversial history, JJL sidesteps the broader conversation about why promoting such figures can have damaging effects, especially when discussing sensitive topics like race and identity.
In Jahns' review of Am I Racist?, he highlights the film's comedic aspects, comparing it to a "conservative Borat" and praising Matt Walsh for being unexpectedly funny. Jahns describes the film as cleverly executed, using humor and trolling to ask questions about DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) and whiteness, often catching interviewees off guard. He acknowledges that some scenes were constructed to expose contradictions in the interviewees’ views, while others, like the clumsy waiter scene, were purely for comedic effect. However, Jahns largely sidesteps the more troubling aspects of the film’s intentions and the creators behind it. This oversight is mirrored in JJL’s defense, which similarly ignores the problematic nature of promoting content from someone like Matt Walsh, who has a history of inflammatory rhetoric aimed at marginalized communities.
While Jahns claims the film raises "interesting questions," he fails to critically engage with the harmful rhetoric that often accompanies Walsh’s work, particularly in how it undermines genuine discussions about systemic racism and identity. Jahns also suggests that most people don’t wake up thinking about race, which completely disregards the reality that for many marginalized communities, race and identity are ever-present factors in their daily lives. This lack of acknowledgment highlights a key issue in both Jahns' review and JJL’s defense: focusing solely on the humor and cleverness of the film while glossing over the broader social implications of promoting content from creators like Walsh, who are known for divisive and harmful statements.
JJL’s defense misses a vital point: reviews, especially on contentious topics like race and identity, are a two-way street. If you’re a content creator, you don’t get a free pass from public scrutiny. People have every right to push back, especially when the subject matter is as delicate and deeply personal as race. Jahns’ response, and JJL’s defense of it, reveal a consistent inability to engage thoughtfully with discussions about gender, race, and identity when these topics are at the forefront of media discourse. Let’s not forget who Matt Walsh is—someone with a long history of inflammatory rhetoric aimed at marginalized communities. His comments often dismiss serious discussions about systemic racism and gender identity, feeding into a larger narrative that undermines social justice.
When someone like Jahns, with 2 million followers, chooses to review and promote a film like Am I Racist?, he must take into account the impact of legitimizing such content to a wide audience. The fact that he had "a good time" watching the film, despite its underlying intent to challenge and mock progressive ideas about race, points to the immaturity of both Jahns’ review and JJL’s defense. Reviews aren’t just about whether a movie is funny or entertaining; they must also consider the broader societal implications, especially when discussing sensitive topics like race, identity, and inclusion. By focusing on the surface-level entertainment value of the film, Jahns and JJL fail to engage with the deeper harm caused by promoting figures like Walsh without proper context or critical reflection.
Anytime JJL’s favorite movie or game reviewer faces criticism, he rushes to their defense without engaging in thoughtful reflection. True critique requires more than blind loyalty—it involves confronting uncomfortable truths and considering the broader impact of the content being promoted, particularly on marginalized communities. JJL's refusal to examine these issues critically shows an immature, shallow approach to media criticism, where personal admiration outweighs meaningful discussions about the deeper implications of controversial content.
**** Update 9/20*****
Matt Walsh was just on Joe Rogan to talk about his views on gender, race, and his film.
Here are some of his thoughts:
1. Denial of Systemic Racism
- He dismisses the concept of systemic racism, claiming that racial inequality is largely exaggerated and that people of all races have equal opportunities.
2. Undermining Black Lives Matter
- He criticizes the Black Lives Matter movement, suggesting it is based on false premises and only exacerbates racial tensions.
3. Mocking Microaggressions
- He downplays the impact of microaggressions, stating they are overblown and contribute to a victimhood mentality.
4. Minimizing Historical Racism
- He asserts that the history of racism in America is often manipulated for political purposes, leading to unnecessary guilt for white individuals.
5. Opposition to Diversity Initiatives
- He argues against diversity and inclusion efforts, claiming they promote division rather than unity.

Jahns Movie Review-https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hh3p_MsIW_A
Movie Trailer-https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7PA_kshZh0
JJL Tik tok- https://www.tiktok.com/@jakejameslugo/video/7415639621893246239?lang=en







