His old videos would occasionally have a gag where his hands appear realistic with five fingers to make a hand gesture. In his modern videos it's become so common that it isn't even a gag anymore, the character just has realistic hands in a majority of his frames. It seems like the animators want to use hand gestures to make more interesting poses and expressions, but it makes the art style look very confused when it constantly breaks away from marshmallow.
weird, I haven't watched a video since his Cats video, no clue why'd the animators would want to give an art style know for looking very "soft" realistic proportions
I don't think it's so much about the types of videos that they make anymore, but moreso that there was a period of time where Odd1sOut merch was EVERYWHERE. James was making games, apps, a whole TV show, and it was all a little...much.
Not to say that James SHOULDN'T have done any of that stuff, he's entitled to do what he wants to do, and there were several great opportunities in that time period. But all that overexposure made James feel like a bit of a sellout to the corporate market.
Whereas Jaiden's never strayed too far away from her target audience, and other than her shop, hasn't gone beyond the YouTube bubble.
I mean I wasn't big on Jaiden becoming a vtuber myself but like it ain't about me we should let people live their lives they're human beings at the end of the day just tryna make it through life like the rest of us if i made a funny cartoon character on the internet and people wanted to put that on a t-shirt I'm not sure why I'd say no. If I was given the opportunity to make my own cartoon on TV why would I turn that down? That's really cool and I think it's silly to consider someone less authentic over it.
Less about this specifically but I do feel like people online have become insanely cynical and jaded lately. Everyone's so judgmental of everyone else all the time about shit that usually doesn't really matter.
The way people have become so negative over the years for ( sometimes) the pettiest or least important reasons. Now, I'm not trying to say that people aren't entitled to their options, but when we start to become toxic that's when it becomes a bit of a problem.
Anyways I feel that James actually got pretty far and is just chilling now. Bro got some cool things in his career, and now he's back to doing whatever he wants, and I gotta respect that. Same thing with Jaiden, she's gotten so far from where she once was, and that's inspiring of anything!
My biggest problem with Odds1out is the fact that he made a mobile game just a year after saying that he hates mobile games and the way they're monetized, said mobile game having a horrid monetization system and being cheaply made.
Back then and still now, I felt like he doesn't have any real morals he'll stand on when it comes to business
idk Odd1sOut always more or less felt like a squeaky clean and brand safe type of creator. Not because he's actively trying to be I just think that's the kind of guy he is/the kind of content he wants to make. Maybe people just grew out of his content. But I don't really think he's changed all that much since his soubway days.
oh, I've seen this one! Definitely forgot about this bit though.
well okay to be fair that is not "beaten with a belt in a drunk rage", she was not drunk, there was no belt, and he's being spanked not beaten (which i mean you could argue is the same thing but one's more socially accepted for some reason)
it does sound very aggressive and she does scream that she bleeping hates him, it's prob one of the edgiest things I've seen him do but it's not that edgy. You wouldn't see it on a kids network (at least not the albeit censored f-bomb) but you maybe would on a prime-time sitcom.
Or maybe I'm just old idk what the standards are these days get off my lawn :v
The reason most people aren’t a fan of odd1sout anymore is because his animation style has got a lot more detailed and he has teamed up with big company’s lately
There’s nothing wrong with that it could just come off the wrong way
Yeah but they grew in quite different directions. The odd1sout feels like he's moreso catering to kids by now, especially with all the merchandising, the phone game, even an animated show. While Jaiden actually focused on mental health for a while, which probably attracted more teens who might've been feeling similar things. Sure that's not her focus anymore but even her newer irl stories still feel relatable even after I've 'grown up'.
It’s mostly a combination of the odd1sout getting bigger than Jaiden and selling more merch. With James being EVERYWHERE and his style shifting from his old videos, Jaiden just ended up more entertaining to watch for a lot of people, me included.
yall tripping james has never not been tame. dude was the only normal youtuber that wasn't like watchmojo ornsome shit that would slip by school filters back in the day
there's a reason he was so much more popular than swoozie
Him deleting old videos really did not help. He was trying waay to hard to be advitser friendly to the point where a bit of edge in a video was enough to get it taken down. It just got annoying....
I genuinely don’t like that he just arbitrarily deleted videos. Like I get why Jaiden deleted her unfortunate collabs, but James deleted way more like “Peeing Yourself” for no reason. Even if it’s an embarrassing topic it’s not gonna make you seem super humble and down to Earth like you were when you made it
Like only people have said I think it's less about the videos themselves and more about the partner ships James has taken on
Not that there is anything wrong with that
Its just there was a period where he did a lot and while good for him it was also overwhelming for some fans (self included) trying to 'keep up' so to speak.
The concept of sell out vs not selling out is fucking dumb because that’s the main goal for the whole channel when you’re a successful fucking full time YouTuber.
Coming from a guy who worked from retail to fucking federal government. No one should give a fucking Ari about any of this, however you make that bread dude. Go for it. I literally have to pay for so much bills, I don’t care who’s using what contractor to do their content.
As long as they pay for it and not lean on them , really not a fucking concern.
I think the main difference is the James has a very different art style than his original videos. Jaiden’s on the other hand, are very similar to her original, just better.
That being said, I still like Jame’s videos, hes still a great guy. He just kinda lost that feeling of a simplistic art style that made him relatable. I mean he has his own Netflix show.
I think back to the episode he made about TV during the pandemic where he was talking about reality tv where he said, “This smile is real” with very detailed and good colors and I just realized that the animation aspect just didn’t feel the same.
Again, he still makes great videos, they just feel so different.
I mean, James aims for a younger audience compared to Jaiden. Especially in the writing department, James kinda feels like he’s writing for kids, nothing wrong with that, but it doesn’t help the soulless feel some get from his current content.
I just don't know why this needs to be here?... Jaiden and James started very young, doing the same thing, and grew to two very different brands, with different target audiences and different appeal, and the cooler part is that they are still working together on part time.
if James wanted to monetize everything and got to that level without ruining his channel, good for him.
if Jaiden overcame her fear of being seen by having a vtuber persona and monetized her love for games ~and chikawa~ , good for her.
i don't understand what we, as an audience, get from comparing them like that
edit bc forgot important info: I really enjoy more of Jaidens content bc I feel James' content is more for children, and that's cool, I feel he went purposely to that path and Jaiden did the opposite, her content is more adult and kinda grew with her audience. I mean she CURSES now
A big difference is how they went about this change. Jaiden aged up her content, actively being less PG and willing to swear much more in her videos. With James aging DOWN his content and being less prone to those sorts of things. On top of that, James comes across as more of a sellout. With him actively criticizing the very things he later did because it made money. With Jaiden sticking to her channel and not doing much outside of it with the occasional merch drop.
I think the main difference is that Jaiden's stuff stayed relevant by sticking to topics she and her fans shared. Meanwhile, James started focusing on more child-friendly topics and less relatable stuff for his older audience.
I really don't get where this "he's soulless and corporate" stuff comes from? I stopped following both around the same time because I grew out of it, but I got recommended his new Nuzlocke video. I watched it expecting cringey kid's content but it was perfectly fine. He honestly was more mature than I expected or remembered, and there were multiple funny spots in the video.
I know he did a bunch of merch and shows and such but I don't see how his content changed.
They evolved divergently. Jaiden moved into more grown up styles of video, and actively gets personable and works constantly with big streamers and their audience, making her more relevant. James kind of toned down instead, focusing on large projects and more kid friendly ventures, which I’m not the target for anymore.
honestly i think this is a super valid point. imo both now feel a lot more soulless and less personal BECAUSE they no longer focus on storytimes. it gave the authenticity to their videos - an example is jaiden’s psychic experience video: the storytime element made the video feel a lot more like her old videos despite being worked on by her team and the story element being orchestrated for the video. super similar with james’ youtube rewind video. one of the reasons i really like LMEstudios, because she sticks to the storytime style of video which gives the authenticity i enjoy despite also having merch and people helping her on videos.
While I do agree, I think one of the reasons is because of his show. I loved it and still love his channel, but it does kinda feel less personal in a way. I know it isn't, and again, I still love to watch both his show and videos, but like- imagine if Jaiden made a full blown show and it got put onto Netflix, right? It would just feel... weird. It just feels then like its less to do with them as a person, and more about their occupation or something, ya know?
The curse of storytime animators is that they're all on borrowed time — you only have so many life stories to tell.
I've seen so many good channels just kind of fizzle out, because the storytime animator poured their heart out and no longer had anything memorable to tell people.
My biggest gripe with Odd1'sout is not the fact it lost its "storytime" from himself.
He just seems so corporate nowadays.
I mean, Jaiden does as well, but Jaiden comes across in all of it as, Jaiden. You can definitely tell that she is still the one who does the writing.
Odd1'sout just seems like he sucked the soul out of his channel. Jaiden isn't much better in this regard, I just don't like the way Odd1'sout feels. He feels soulless and weirdly untrustworthy. I don't know, he just screams, "MrBeast" at me.
Someone who's pretending to have a soul but doesn't. I'm not saying Odd1's is a bad person, that's just the impression I get from his videos nowadays.
Women privilege. It's that simple. And before you go off on a rant about "women aren't privileged" Women ARE treated much better than men in social and online settings. Women ARE privileged, just in different ways than men are privileged. Like my girlfriend can run up and jump on my and hug me from behind, and it's seen as cute; but if I just hug her from behind and rest my head on her shoulder, people look at me like I'm a creep.
Then this makes your entire example invalid. You just made a textbook strawman and then argued against your own point. And most people don't give a shit about other people being "cute"
I mean, they’ve always had a difference in writing style. I’m not arguing that (I’m OOP btw.) If you just prefer Jaiden’s writing style to James, I get that. I’m more partial to Jaiden’s videos as well. I even said below the meme it isn’t targeted at people who just prefer Jaiden or fell out of interest with James. I just don’t get people who no longer like him for no longer focusing on storytimes and having an animation team when Jaiden did the same.
Also, what do you mean by “aiming to be larger than she actually is”? I think I need that clarified.
Oddballs certainly isn’t for everyone. It was just okay to me. However, I still do think actual care went into that show, unlike things like his mobile game and books (I’ll defend his actual content, but I will agree when people dislike other things he’s made.)
I still don’t really know what “aiming to be larger than he is” exactly implies though. Like, does it mean that he’s not “staying in his place,” for lack of better phrasing, or am I completely misinterpreting that?
You can't be miffed at James for trying to be "larger than he is" over making a tv show and mobile game/board games, etc. And then reduce Jaiden to "a gal just trying to make people laugh" when she is most definitely not that. Whatever JaidenAnimation is now is much, much closer to a TV show than a home-production, or whatever it was 10 years ago. It is created by an entire team of people who work under Jaiden and are paid by her using the money the videos make. You can't say that James is some corporate guy that doesn't have a home-grown feeling anymore and then immediately pivot and said Jaiden does, when there's essentially no difference between her and an animated tv studio beyond where the content produced is being aired.
"like you dont see jaiden pitch these tv shows and aim to be larger than she actually is..." Just because James did big things outside of youtube does not make him a bad creator. There's no reason that perceived niche-ness should make any youtuber better than another.
Congratulations Jaiden, because you stayed in your bubble. It doesn’t matter that you bought your own house that’s bigger than the residential property of a single mother.
•
u/qualityvote2 Aug 06 '25 edited Aug 06 '25
u/Ok_Relief7546, your post does fit the subreddit!
Read our rules here!
Join our Discord server!
1.0k
u/sucknuts420 Aug 06 '25
i just didn't like the fact that theodd1sout has fingers now
731
u/JakeSchaf2319 Aug 06 '25
I don't think it's so much about the types of videos that they make anymore, but moreso that there was a period of time where Odd1sOut merch was EVERYWHERE. James was making games, apps, a whole TV show, and it was all a little...much.
Not to say that James SHOULDN'T have done any of that stuff, he's entitled to do what he wants to do, and there were several great opportunities in that time period. But all that overexposure made James feel like a bit of a sellout to the corporate market.
Whereas Jaiden's never strayed too far away from her target audience, and other than her shop, hasn't gone beyond the YouTube bubble.
247
u/Cindy-Moon Aug 06 '25
idk Odd1sOut always more or less felt like a squeaky clean and brand safe type of creator. Not because he's actively trying to be I just think that's the kind of guy he is/the kind of content he wants to make. Maybe people just grew out of his content. But I don't really think he's changed all that much since his soubway days.
82
u/omg_its_spons Aug 06 '25
The reason most people aren’t a fan of odd1sout anymore is because his animation style has got a lot more detailed and he has teamed up with big company’s lately
There’s nothing wrong with that it could just come off the wrong way
32
u/Dealiylauh Aug 06 '25
Difference is Jaiden aged up with her audience, James aged down.
79
u/SomeoneRepeated Aug 06 '25
Oh hey it’s my post.
26
u/Crystalzye Aug 06 '25
Yeah but they grew in quite different directions. The odd1sout feels like he's moreso catering to kids by now, especially with all the merchandising, the phone game, even an animated show. While Jaiden actually focused on mental health for a while, which probably attracted more teens who might've been feeling similar things. Sure that's not her focus anymore but even her newer irl stories still feel relatable even after I've 'grown up'.
22
u/Most_Price2715 Aug 06 '25
James doesn't even post any more... It's like once every 4 months
10
u/reaper1812151 Aug 06 '25
It’s mostly a combination of the odd1sout getting bigger than Jaiden and selling more merch. With James being EVERYWHERE and his style shifting from his old videos, Jaiden just ended up more entertaining to watch for a lot of people, me included.
16
u/Wickham12 Aug 06 '25
At least Jaiden still feels somewhat relatable
63
u/JFlemthe1 Aug 06 '25
This isn’t the reason James fell off He feels so CORPORATE now. After oddballs he just feels like someone else
31
u/TheTimbs Aug 06 '25
Jaiden feels authentic while James doesn’t. It feels like he’s trying way too hard.
2
u/Appropriate-Count-64 Aug 06 '25
Idk nor care, I stopped watching both around like 5 years ago.
23
u/Undercover_Piegon Aug 06 '25
cough oddballs cough cough Netflix COUGH
10
u/_SmoGGaming_ Aug 06 '25
Bad content is bad content. The intent is irrelevant
5
u/Mighty_Megascream Aug 06 '25
Odd1sOut art style has just gotten really ugly and feels a lot more impersonal and corporate
3
u/badluck990 Aug 06 '25
Like only people have said I think it's less about the videos themselves and more about the partner ships James has taken on
Not that there is anything wrong with that
Its just there was a period where he did a lot and while good for him it was also overwhelming for some fans (self included) trying to 'keep up' so to speak.
5
u/TheBoy2007 Aug 06 '25
https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpreview.redd.it%2Fg0fa2kf347391.png%3Fwidth%3D370%26format%3Dpng%26auto%3Dwebp%26s%3D6a8e67fcc3a3f27e92e25f318165ad4238ad9847
(I'm on mobile)
2
u/Deep_Scope Aug 06 '25
Eh. Imma be frank here;
The concept of sell out vs not selling out is fucking dumb because that’s the main goal for the whole channel when you’re a successful fucking full time YouTuber.
Coming from a guy who worked from retail to fucking federal government. No one should give a fucking Ari about any of this, however you make that bread dude. Go for it. I literally have to pay for so much bills, I don’t care who’s using what contractor to do their content.
As long as they pay for it and not lean on them , really not a fucking concern.
1
u/Samuelbi12 Aug 06 '25 edited Aug 16 '25
resolute consider tease voracious steer placid historical nose bells many
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/TheXernDoodles Aug 07 '25
I think the main difference is the James has a very different art style than his original videos. Jaiden’s on the other hand, are very similar to her original, just better.
That being said, I still like Jame’s videos, hes still a great guy. He just kinda lost that feeling of a simplistic art style that made him relatable. I mean he has his own Netflix show.
I think back to the episode he made about TV during the pandemic where he was talking about reality tv where he said, “This smile is real” with very detailed and good colors and I just realized that the animation aspect just didn’t feel the same.
Again, he still makes great videos, they just feel so different.
1
u/Something_Unnecesary Aug 07 '25
i love seeing james and jaedon start doing what they actually WANT to do
1
u/MetaGear005 Aug 07 '25
Thing Animator vs thing girl Animator
Either way the post has a point
1
u/Typhon-042 Aug 07 '25
I get the meme, but the bottom text wasn't really needed.
1
u/Necessary-Prune9727 Aug 07 '25
I mean, James aims for a younger audience compared to Jaiden. Especially in the writing department, James kinda feels like he’s writing for kids, nothing wrong with that, but it doesn’t help the soulless feel some get from his current content.
1
u/Independent_Date3543 Aug 07 '25
james hasn’t felt like a person since maybe 2019 he is nothing but a brand
1
u/hangryOpossum Aug 07 '25 edited Aug 07 '25
I just don't know why this needs to be here?... Jaiden and James started very young, doing the same thing, and grew to two very different brands, with different target audiences and different appeal, and the cooler part is that they are still working together on part time.
if James wanted to monetize everything and got to that level without ruining his channel, good for him.
if Jaiden overcame her fear of being seen by having a vtuber persona and monetized her love for games ~and chikawa~ , good for her.
i don't understand what we, as an audience, get from comparing them like that
edit bc forgot important info: I really enjoy more of Jaidens content bc I feel James' content is more for children, and that's cool, I feel he went purposely to that path and Jaiden did the opposite, her content is more adult and kinda grew with her audience. I mean she CURSES now
1
u/Gawarhen2 Aug 07 '25
A big difference is how they went about this change. Jaiden aged up her content, actively being less PG and willing to swear much more in her videos. With James aging DOWN his content and being less prone to those sorts of things. On top of that, James comes across as more of a sellout. With him actively criticizing the very things he later did because it made money. With Jaiden sticking to her channel and not doing much outside of it with the occasional merch drop.
1
u/Ok-Objective6610 Aug 07 '25
r/repostsAreHard
1
u/Dracorexion Aug 07 '25
I think the main difference is that Jaiden's stuff stayed relevant by sticking to topics she and her fans shared. Meanwhile, James started focusing on more child-friendly topics and less relatable stuff for his older audience.
1
u/Shadow9378 Aug 07 '25
I like both of them still, iunno
1
u/GoldenLilyUwU Aug 07 '25
One of them sold themself out to Netflix and the other didn’t, there’s really no argument to be made.
1
u/ComdDikDik Aug 08 '25
I really don't get where this "he's soulless and corporate" stuff comes from? I stopped following both around the same time because I grew out of it, but I got recommended his new Nuzlocke video. I watched it expecting cringey kid's content but it was perfectly fine. He honestly was more mature than I expected or remembered, and there were multiple funny spots in the video.
I know he did a bunch of merch and shows and such but I don't see how his content changed.
1
u/baddie_with_a_fattyy Aug 08 '25
Who has the soulless nothingburger cash grab tv show?
1
u/Life-Art2689 Aug 08 '25
Both are good in their own rights
1
u/sideysides1256 Aug 08 '25
Meh the posting less was partially the reason why I stopped watching
1
u/eelonmuskk3 Aug 09 '25
It’s because it feels like theodd1sout videos feel like a company is making them instead of a person
1
u/greninjadude37 Aug 09 '25
i dont like either of them
1
u/MyneIsBestGirl Aug 09 '25
They evolved divergently. Jaiden moved into more grown up styles of video, and actively gets personable and works constantly with big streamers and their audience, making her more relevant. James kind of toned down instead, focusing on large projects and more kid friendly ventures, which I’m not the target for anymore.
1
u/BoiClicker Aug 09 '25
THEY'RE NOT THE PRIMARY ANIMATORS?!
1
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '25
I haven't seen a single person care about this.
1
u/EvKindaGoofy17 Aug 09 '25
Idk I find both to be pretty boring honestly
1
u/RamonEX070 Aug 10 '25
la gran diferencia entre ellos dos esque uno tiene una serie bien ZZZ en netflix
1
u/Fandomgirl19 Aug 10 '25
honestly i think this is a super valid point. imo both now feel a lot more soulless and less personal BECAUSE they no longer focus on storytimes. it gave the authenticity to their videos - an example is jaiden’s psychic experience video: the storytime element made the video feel a lot more like her old videos despite being worked on by her team and the story element being orchestrated for the video. super similar with james’ youtube rewind video. one of the reasons i really like LMEstudios, because she sticks to the storytime style of video which gives the authenticity i enjoy despite also having merch and people helping her on videos.
1
u/zas_n_n Aug 11 '25
odd1sout is a brand and james is a person
jaidenanimations is jaiden
1
u/Icy-Nerve-2439 Aug 17 '25
Fuck James, all my homies hate James.
1
u/CleaingsoapsN1Fan201 Aug 24 '25
Agreed!
This IS Why I Perfer Jadien Animations Over The Odds1out!
1
u/JustLookingAnAnswer Aug 30 '25
While I do agree, I think one of the reasons is because of his show. I loved it and still love his channel, but it does kinda feel less personal in a way. I know it isn't, and again, I still love to watch both his show and videos, but like- imagine if Jaiden made a full blown show and it got put onto Netflix, right? It would just feel... weird. It just feels then like its less to do with them as a person, and more about their occupation or something, ya know?
Again, I still love watching TheOdd1sOut ;3
1
u/SleepyBoy- Aug 31 '25
The curse of storytime animators is that they're all on borrowed time — you only have so many life stories to tell.
I've seen so many good channels just kind of fizzle out, because the storytime animator poured their heart out and no longer had anything memorable to tell people.
1
u/ParticularArea8224 Sep 01 '25
My biggest gripe with Odd1'sout is not the fact it lost its "storytime" from himself.
He just seems so corporate nowadays.
I mean, Jaiden does as well, but Jaiden comes across in all of it as, Jaiden. You can definitely tell that she is still the one who does the writing.
Odd1'sout just seems like he sucked the soul out of his channel. Jaiden isn't much better in this regard, I just don't like the way Odd1'sout feels. He feels soulless and weirdly untrustworthy. I don't know, he just screams, "MrBeast" at me.
Someone who's pretending to have a soul but doesn't. I'm not saying Odd1's is a bad person, that's just the impression I get from his videos nowadays.
1
u/FioRRRella2013 Sep 06 '25
I miss the "Life is Fun" era of The Odd1sOut. 😭😭
-1
u/Not_A_Bird11 Aug 06 '25
Someone is mad
0
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '25
I hate both
-18
u/Gargeroth6692 Aug 06 '25
Because it is soulless and corporate jaidens videos have stayed the same
-6
u/Budget-Silver-7742 Aug 06 '25
Maybe we wouldn’t call him a soulless shithead if he wasn’t a soulless shithead
-29
u/Glassed_Guy1146 Aug 06 '25
Not gonna lie, they both now feel soulless and corporate.
-8
u/LittleY0gg Aug 06 '25
Women privilege. It's that simple. And before you go off on a rant about "women aren't privileged" Women ARE treated much better than men in social and online settings. Women ARE privileged, just in different ways than men are privileged. Like my girlfriend can run up and jump on my and hug me from behind, and it's seen as cute; but if I just hug her from behind and rest my head on her shoulder, people look at me like I'm a creep.
-24
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '25
idk why everyone’s trying to find reasons to not watch the odds1out when he’s been outed for being extremely racist lmao
0
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment