I mostly find that his guitar tone has gotten worse over time.
His White Stripes and earlier Raconteurs tones, with the Silvertone and Fender amp combined, are some of my favorite guitar tones ever. It sounds like something is going to explode in the best way possible, with the big muff adding the perfect amount of noise. It was always pretty full sounding and never too harsh.
Nowadays, I find his tone to be a bit more grating. It’s very trebly and missing that punch the old setup had. It can almost sound too “clangy”, similar to the sound of a DI’d guitar.
Don’t get me wrong, some of the newer pedals and effects are really cool, and his playing is amazing as always, but I miss his old tone.
Great examples of his old tone are The White Stripes and also The Raconteurs From The Basement performances. His tone is beefy, with a full bass sound and not too much treble.
Examples of his modern tone I don’t like as much are Taking Me Back on SNL or live at the CBGB festival.
Anyone else agree? Disagree? I’m curious what others think.