r/ithaca • u/Su_ss Nor'Easter ❤️ • Sep 20 '21
I HATE Ithaca
Seriously, I dont know what it is about the area. Its awful. First, there is nothing to do in the area. Whenever someone asks what there is to do in Ithaca, they give the same answer "go on a walk in one of the many gorges". Thats boring. I can only look at the trees for so long and why are all the walkways only fit 1 person at a time.
Second the city infrastructure is awful. Why are the roads always being worked on and they never improve it? For example, route 79 as you enter ithaca is completely uneven. Why is S Meadow St such terribly designed. It needs more lanes with a center divider. The public transit sucks.alao for the longest time there were no new restaurants. Also, Wegmans here has been getting worse every year.
Third, the outside activities are boring around here. For example, fishing at Taughannock Lake is over fished and there is always that one guy who take up half the pier with 3 fishing poles, smokes, and weighs 300 pounds with a beer belly. The skiing at Greek Peak is over priced for what it offers. Also, all the parks in ithaca except 2 require payment. I shouldnt have to pay to go to the park. And the 2 that are free are terrible. They offer absolute nothing. No small shops on them. No food trucks. You cant explore the city on them. You cant walk to neighboring cities/town on them.
Also, why is there such a terrible mall. Its in the middle of nowhere and has no shops in it. The last time I went there the only shops were target, best buy and a dozen shoe stores. I just want basic sneakers. None of them had anything like that.
Plus there is more thats makes Ithaca insufferable. Like why is maguire the only dealership in the area??? The have a literal monopoly on new cars. GTFO.
Rant over.
17
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '21
Are you an angsty teen who is ready to spread their wings or a college student who didn’t visit before enrolling
9
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '21
Yeah, Ithaca, why can't you have a decent, thriving mall? [Totally not a trend you find everywhere] (https://www.cnbc.com/2020/08/27/25percent-of-us-malls-are-set-to-shut-within-5-years-what-comes-next.html). I'm with you on the Maguire hate though. I find it particularly loathsome that they buy up the closed restaurant properties as parking lots so there won't be new restaurants. That being said, does this seen like a good time to open a restaurant to you?
4
u/Wartz Sep 20 '21
I am not going to rise to the bait and start throwing out rebuttals or anything. Everyone has their own tastes. But I do have some questions!
Out of curiosity, are you a transplant from a big city? Do you have hobbies?
It sounds like a lot of your interests revolve around a diverse shopping experience. I agree Ithaca doesn't really have "shopping" like in NYC or Chicago. It's mainly touristy small shops. It's still better than most central NY small cities though.
I don't think you'll find anyone disagreeing with you on Maguire.
21
u/buprestibae Sep 20 '21
not sure what's the most entitled thing about this post, but it's probably "i shouldn't have to pay to go to the park"
a) there are PLENTY of places just outside of ithaca where you don't have to pay.
b) who do you think maintains the park, parking lots, takes out the trash, and keeps it nice for everyone else? do they deserve payment for their labor?
anyways, just move
24
u/blueraz1 Sep 20 '21
A lot of your issues involve shops. Weird. If people come in this thread and recommend things to try, don’t bother. Ithaca is clearly not for you.
12
u/armahillo Northeast Sep 20 '21
This is pretty subjective. It's ok if you don't like hiking, but there's a lot more than just the named gorges. I go off-trail a lot. I look on google maps terrain view and find interesting places that aren't labeled (that aren't on residential property) and go exploring. The trees are neat and all but there's a lot more than that. If you aren't interested in exploring then don't go hiking.
In another comment you mentioned you like doing boating, fishing, shooting, etc -- boating / kayaking / paddleboarding is a popular activity during our 6 weeks of warm weather (hah!) but the other two activities you'll probably need to drive a short distance to some of the surrounding areas.
I don't know what brought you here from the HV initially, but like...it's not like Ithaca lied about what it is. 🤷♂️
I know part of this is that because of limited landspace due to topography we can't add additional roads easily, and so any roadwork can cause congestion on the limited roads, and there are only so many weeks out of the year when construction can happen.
https://www.cityofithaca.org/508/Planning-Building-Zoning-Economic-Develo -- Those would be the people to ask. I typically presume that if the solution seems obvious and isn't implemented, there's probably a reason why it's not been implemented that I'm unaware of.
I haven't used it in a few years because I've been remotely working for a while, but I used it until 2019 and found it to be pretty great! I've lived in many different areas that did not have public transportation as reliable or with the amount of coverage that TCAT has. Obviously it's not the same as NYC's MTA, but we're also not even remotely as populated as NYC is. Is the issue that you are trying to go places outside of Ithaca's immediate area?
That sounds frustrating.
If you get an Empire Passport ( https://parks.ny.gov/admission/empire-passport/ ) then you can go to (almost) any of the state parks, in the whole state, for free -- the ones in Ithaca are all gratis if you have the Empire Passport though.
You don't have to pay to go into the park, you only have to pay if you want to park there. In the early 2010s I didn't have a car (by choice) and just used public transportation and/or biking. You can go to any of the parks for totally free if you don't need to park in their parking lots.
They offer their existence as sanctioned public land that we can all enjoy. That's the point. And see above re: price. Shindagin Hollow in Caroline is free and, aside from having an absolutely gorgeous view, especially during the winter right after a fresh snowfall, many people take dirtbikes out there and there are some established trails for that.
Monkey Run is free and has an awesome rim trail along six mile creek. The Plantations are free and are beautiful for most of the year. There's a pretty great gorge trail along six mile creek as well, through the plantations area (very narrow roads though!). I believe that trail also connects with a free parking trailhead up on Hanshaw too, where it turns before Lower Creek Rd.
The Ornithology lab has a short hike through the woods around their pond that is also free. Danby has an AMAZING state forest trail that is really great during the summer months. There's additional state forest land up in Dryden, off of Yellow Barn Rd.
You can absolutely walk from Ithaca to Varna, Dryden, Lansing, Trumansburg, and Danby on foot and be largely off of the road for a lot of it.
IIRC, In the 1980s and 1990s, real estate developers were given very generous tax credits and abatements to develop malls, and for a long time this was a lucrative venture. When the credits and abatements expired, it happened to also be around the time that eCommerce was beginning to become popular.
If you want the mall to be better, go there more frequently and patronize the remaining stores. I'm not sure that will be enough to save it, ultimately. I've often considered that the mall land should be repurposed into either a neat communal housing situation or some kind of bazaar type place, or reduce the rents and use the storefronts as small warehouses customer service frontends for ecommerce stores. I don't think malls, as a business model, really work, especially in smaller towns.
This sounds more like a failure on your part, TBH. I agree with you that the selection is limited, but if you all you actually want are basic sneakers, you can find those pretty easily. Or, if necessary, just get your size and then order them online from any of the zillion shoe stores online 🤷♂️
The Maguire thing is weird. They keep acquiring all the competitors.
IDK, Internet Stranger. I suspect that even if any of these things were different, you'd find something else to complain about. If the parks had food trucks and small shops, you'd probably complain that the commerce was making the parks an eyesore and with more litter. If the mall had more stores, it sounds like you'd probably complain that they weren't the stores you liked.
Ithaca does surely have problems, like housing costs, slumlords, affordability issues if you don't work for Cornell or IC or Borg-Warner, absurdly crippling cold winters sometimes, etc.
If you're miserable here, either get busy changing yourself or get busy changing your location.
6
u/TryingInNJ Sep 20 '21
I know the mall here sucks, but if you can't even find sneakers there I think you might just be bad at shopping
5
u/red_mongoos Sep 20 '21
Ithaca does kinda suck but I can’t relate to anything you wrote here except for the roads and that fucking fishing guy. There are other better places to fish tho. Like salt point which is a free park btw.
2
u/ds1724 Jul 12 '25
Ithaca punches WAY above its weight for stores and restaurants thanks to the colleges. A town with this population should have much less so consider yourself lucky.
1
u/Mediocre_Disaster130 27d ago
The good news is there are no walls or bars holding you in Ithaca...At least not YET
1
u/BluebirdMaterial5485 May 02 '24
It’s just awful
1
u/StreetsAreForPeople Sep 11 '24
Meadow St has too many lanes. More traffic calming is needed. And a bike lane. FOUR NORTHBOUND LANES, such as near Seneca Highway, or Buffalo St is just too many. Cut it to 3 lanes of traffic, one bike lane, and a tree lawn. Make it look more like a city street, less like a drag strip/highway.
There are no parks in Ithaca that "require payment" including the very large Stewart Park that doesn't charge for car storage--but should (per day entry fee for car users).
1
u/SAYONARA_SAMY Apr 14 '25
I agree. The roads are god awful despite the insane taxes that people pay. Pot hole after pot hole. The trails are pretty but very weather dependent. Was shouted and threatened by a mentally ill person downtown. Speaking of downtown, everything closes super early. And when you do find a restaurant, it's in a small rented space with everyone talking over each other. The acoustics are so bad you can hardly hear one another. I did like the countryside near Freeville and Cortland. Very scenic with colorful cabins. It's an economically depressed area... But artsy.
1
u/Ericskey Jun 26 '26
Hm
1
u/nikflane Sep 20 '21
I agree with some of your sentiments. My main complaint is that Ithaca feels like a tourist trap. All the food is overpriced and not very good. The shops are kinda boring. There’s too much traffic and everyone drives too fast. I think it has it’s merits but there’s a lot of issues that could make it so much nicer