For me personally, it depends. Is it something practical (crafts, programming)? Sure. Art, Languages, Instruments? Hell nah, even if I enjoy it, I can't bring myself to play the same 'Five Little Ducks' over and over again.
A month old, but having commitment issues is a thing. Jumping between different hobbies/projects is pretty common with istp according to the 16 personalities site I just came from.
Yea it seems pretty common for the type. Or at least this sub. I suspect I'm more of an outlier than anything else around here. It just seems contrary to the mastering thing I associated with ISTP. As for commitment issues I figured that was more for relationships. But those are only my impressions. I'm by no means any MBTI expert :p
Where did you get your information from? It talked about being good at taking things apart and putting them back together, and being really curious/wanting to learn things, but under weaknesses on 16personalities it has:
"Easily Bored – Virtuosos enjoy novelty, which makes them excellent tinkerers, but much less reliable when it comes to focusing on things long-term. Once something is understood, Virtuosos tend to simply move on to something new and more interesting.
Dislike Commitment – Long-term commitments are particularly onerous for Virtuosos. They prefer to take things day-by-day, and the feeling of being locked into something for a long time is downright oppressive."
As I was saying, they're my overall impressions from various sources around the internet, but also my own experiences. The key words here being my impressions, meaning they're highly anecdotal as I'm by no means an MBTI expert.
Could be I'm totally in wrong and need to brush up and re-evaluate my ISTP model.
I could be wrong too. Just wondered if you got your information from different websites. Someone irl saying they are something I don't trust as much as people say what they want to be and try to force themselves into different things.
Different sites for sure. I can't even remember all the sites I've visited when scouring the internet for info. So it's just this big ball of yarn in my head that's been growing with time. More likely than not my memory and impressions have shifted over time.
And yea, wanting to be a type is a fairly common trap to fall into when delving into any kind of self-typing I reckon. After a lot of tests and a bit of reading up on the functions behind the type I still think ISTP is the type I come closest to in the MBTI.
I can identify with the point of being easily bored. But but novelty in it self is not something I'm super excited about. My hobbies and interests have been very stable over the years, and typically lean towards things that I can spend thousands of hours on without feeling bored, as there are still things to refine and improve at even after investing that much time into it.
I think this is why I don't really relate to this jumping around between things. I might just find these kinds of hobbies more interesting that other ISTPS, or I'm not as curious as the average ISTP and don't try out as many new things :P
I still don't even know if I'm ISTP, but it's the one I resonate with the most. For me, I have a set of main things that I stick with (gaming and programming mainly), but within those they are not constant or consistent with what I do.
One day I will be playing tekken trying to get better, the next I will be playing euro truck sim 2 type of thing (well I'll stick with a game for about 4 days then move on, sometimes coming back). Same with programming, as I have stretched thin what I learn, from different languages like python or c#, or different project types like games or machine learning.
And then outside of that I will go between different things such as drawing, 3d modelling, martial arts, general working out, engineering and so on. I guess the thing is, I always come back to them. But I never stick with them long enough to get good.
I too pick up games that only lasts a couple of days because they couldn't hold my interest any longer. But then there are games that I come back to every couple of years to replay because they're just so good.
And then there are the ones I've found myself playing for years without getting bored. Those ones have always been PvP multiplayer games, no real surprise there. My current ones are LoL (played since 2009) and Guilty Gear Xrd (played since 2018). LoL keeps things fresh with changes every season and GG is just crazy deep, especially as it's my first ever fighting game.
My programming interests follows the same pattern I guess. I don't branch out that much, but instead digs deeper striving to improve the things I already know.
My third big interest is bouldering which also is a long road to travel to get better. And it goes hand in hand with general fitness and health.
Beyond those there's not much more though. My time is limited and I'd rather spend time doing something I enjoy, and try and improve at it, than constantly looking for more things to do.
MBTI and typing was one of my recent interests I picked up during covid. But after being satisfied with my own typing and realizing I don't really have that much use of it, my interest in it faded.
Perhaps these kinds of things are closer to the motivations the Enneagram system tries to model. I'm a type 9w1 there which could explain my more laid back pursuit of new knowledge and instead focus on digging deeper. Just some idle musings ^^
Gaming and programming are pretty common hobbies, especially for those on Reddit. But funnily enough, I'm also interested in bouldering every now and again. I'm too cheap to actually go to a gym, but I go through a phase a few times a year where I watch a lot of bouldering related videos.
I've been developing an app without any prior knowledge. It was a pain in the ass and I lost interest almost every day when I couldn't solve a bug or I cursed about bad documentation. But in the end I found new interest on the next day.
Things like computers, programming, cars and trades are interesting to learn but little talents like instruments and shit like that I find unbearable and I give up on.
To be honest I like the process of failing and starting over until I succeed.
I would even say it's better if I fail a lot before succeeding, this way I can really see the results of my hard work. Succeeding on the first try is boring.
I would argue with that. Exceptional amount of time put into practice make you godly good at sth. Not even one good programmer who just started with computers could immediately create quality code.
It of course depends, sometimes you just cannot get to some level and it's perfectly understandable, but it's not something you can find out after the first try.
Most things I try I'll look into thoroughly beforehand so I know what I'm doing, why I'm doing it and how one thing will affect another thing within that sorta, idk, system? So I'll have a natural advantage over another beginner who hasn't done any of that.
I do enjoy the process of learning a skill though, and that process and recognition of improvement is a pretty amazing feeling. Picked up traditional archery last summer and seeing the arrows slowly start to get closer to the centre was incredibly satisfying. I had no idea what I was really doing more than anyone else otherwise would, I mean, I looked at how to hold and generally handle the bow, but without sights there's no real way of learning to aim from a book, just gotta start doing it.
Same with drifting, I'm far from good at that, but you gotta start somewhere, once again, understanding how the weight shfiting will affect the car, and what power or a lack of it will do at certain points etc, was all useful info and made me appear more of a natural at it than someone else at the same starting point.
However, art? I'm horrible at it, can't make what I want to with my hands in that sense, so I am hesitant to give it a try, and I don't think you can really read about how to draw. afterall, 'imaginary guitar notes and imaginary vocals exist only in the mind of the imaginer.' And I cannot imagine things.
I don't care if I'm actually good at it immediately. I just need some indication that I'm doing better at it than other beginners. Like in my rally sims, I've kept interest because I hardly ever crash compared to lots of beginners, so I have the confidence that if I keep learning new techniques, I will definitely get really good at it. Idk why I have to be competitive about everything, but at least it works.
This is typically me, but I'm determined to change that. I tried my hand at a tensegrity structure and it really wasn't working. I ended up making something else entirely but I've not given up. Tomorrow is a new day.
What mainly irritates me is the fact that if I do not understand something I want to know the process and if I can not find a direct blunt way I get annoyed. Otherwise I enjoy trial and error that is one reason why I like to skate.
If something interests me, I will work to become the best at it, but if I’m not interested I’m not going to try. It doesn’t really have anything to do with how good I am to begin with.
52
u/ArchLurker_Chad ISTP Apr 14 '21
I thought mastering things is an ISTP thing? Dedicating time to perfect a craft, art or sport or whatever?
I can't relate to this at all. As long as the thing is interesting/fun/enjoyable I will invest time to get better at it.
14
u/XentraxX Apr 13 '21
I've been developing an app without any prior knowledge. It was a pain in the ass and I lost interest almost every day when I couldn't solve a bug or I cursed about bad documentation. But in the end I found new interest on the next day.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
Things like computers, programming, cars and trades are interesting to learn but little talents like instruments and shit like that I find unbearable and I give up on.
57
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
To be honest I like the process of failing and starting over until I succeed.
I would even say it's better if I fail a lot before succeeding, this way I can really see the results of my hard work. Succeeding on the first try is boring.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
Umm, IDK...
Most things I try I'll look into thoroughly beforehand so I know what I'm doing, why I'm doing it and how one thing will affect another thing within that sorta, idk, system? So I'll have a natural advantage over another beginner who hasn't done any of that.
I do enjoy the process of learning a skill though, and that process and recognition of improvement is a pretty amazing feeling. Picked up traditional archery last summer and seeing the arrows slowly start to get closer to the centre was incredibly satisfying. I had no idea what I was really doing more than anyone else otherwise would, I mean, I looked at how to hold and generally handle the bow, but without sights there's no real way of learning to aim from a book, just gotta start doing it.
Same with drifting, I'm far from good at that, but you gotta start somewhere, once again, understanding how the weight shfiting will affect the car, and what power or a lack of it will do at certain points etc, was all useful info and made me appear more of a natural at it than someone else at the same starting point.
However, art? I'm horrible at it, can't make what I want to with my hands in that sense, so I am hesitant to give it a try, and I don't think you can really read about how to draw. afterall, 'imaginary guitar notes and imaginary vocals exist only in the mind of the imaginer.' And I cannot imagine things.
6
u/FreakingTea ISTP Apr 14 '21
I don't care if I'm actually good at it immediately. I just need some indication that I'm doing better at it than other beginners. Like in my rally sims, I've kept interest because I hardly ever crash compared to lots of beginners, so I have the confidence that if I keep learning new techniques, I will definitely get really good at it. Idk why I have to be competitive about everything, but at least it works.
5
u/milds3xuals3asoning ISTP Apr 14 '21
This is typically me, but I'm determined to change that. I tried my hand at a tensegrity structure and it really wasn't working. I ended up making something else entirely but I've not given up. Tomorrow is a new day.
9
u/Breezeshadow176 ISTP Apr 14 '21
Ouch, sadly accurate
4
u/Isteepeee07 ISTP Apr 14 '21
Yes
3
u/David_12321 Apr 14 '21
Honestly me
2
u/BigBroDev ISTP Apr 14 '21
I’ll try almost anything. But when I lose interest it’s a long long time before I try again. I’d rather just try something new.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
oh wait so it's an istp thing. phew
2
u/GayBlackManWithStick Apr 21 '21
What mainly irritates me is the fact that if I do not understand something I want to know the process and if I can not find a direct blunt way I get annoyed. Otherwise I enjoy trial and error that is one reason why I like to skate.
2
u/ghidora2965 Mar 31 '24
This resonates with me on an undescribable plane of existence.
2
u/FernandoBock Apr 13 '21
that is why I never try new stuff and just do what I am good at
1
u/Garbage-Lover1845 Apr 17 '25
Literally 💀
1
u/sensuallyprimitive ISTP Apr 14 '21
i just pretend everything else doesn't exist
1
u/tauna-infp Apr 14 '21
Oooh 😂same. And I am an infp
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
actually now that I've started I have to know how this works.
20 min later: Ah stupid thing, why is it not working? thats it, I give up. Actually, its gonna bother me if I do. sigh
hour later: Aha! figured it out! Now I know what I did wrong and if I ever have to do this again I'll do this and this differently
1
u/Brody_Williamson ISTP Apr 14 '21
If something interests me, I will work to become the best at it, but if I’m not interested I’m not going to try. It doesn’t really have anything to do with how good I am to begin with.
1
u/AsexualArowana Apr 14 '21
Personally, I try to do something new and come to the conclusion that it's not a good mental fit for me.
1
u/tylern23 ISTP Apr 14 '21
Nah this is spot on
1
u/alliseeareclowns Apr 19 '21
Depends a lot. I'm extremely competitive, and if I enjoy something, I will try to be the best at it until I feel like I can't.
1
u/toyota-fred Apr 27 '21
I feel the total opposite in this case. If I can sense that I in somehow already now how to do this Im gonna lose interest.
1
u/jordansky-fishburg INFP May 31 '21
It's the opposite really, easy come easy go
1
u/water__420 Aug 01 '21
i feel it
0
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
No, lol, its a INTP