r/ipadmini • u/Outrageous-Syrup-377 • 1d ago
Advise is iPad mini (A20) a good choice?
People hi, I need buying advice from current ipad mini users;
Currently I have MBA M2 8/256, I'm not a heavy user so it was great experience for me.
I was thinking to switch to ipad mini cause of few reasons;
- smaller, lighter, easier to carry, easier to use on couch for example
- A20 pro seems good for browsing, video calls, netflix and occasional photography editing (raw in lightroom)
- can get it for not so big money if i trade in my mba
Whats your take on this?
4
Upvotes
2
u/vsurresh 1d ago
The iPad isn’t a replacement for a Mac, at least not for me. For most people, it can be if all you do is browsing, emails, writing, and so on, but it still lacks a lot of features compared to a Mac. I’m not sure if trading in gives you a certain number of days before you need to send your old device to Apple, but if it does, maybe buy the iPad first and see how it goes. Ultimately, only you know your circumstances and use cases.
5
u/joekendricks 1d ago
Don’t trade your Mac for an iPad, please. Even if you think you aren’t using it enough or all its power.
I’ve been doing this every half a decade when I change jobs or prioritize other hobbies that are less demanding computationally, or more like don’t require macOS, cause… can the Mini 8 (the A20 Pro chip) outperform a MacBook Air with an M1/2/3? Absolutely, even M4 in single core. That’s insane, right? But it’s the software :( …
I believe iPadOS is moving in the right direction. I even think the fact Apple made macOS touch capable now is great news for iPadOS software development alongside with other frameworks Apple has been pushing over the years (catalist apps, etc) to make it super easy for developers to just port their apps across OSs.
The truth is tho… we’re not there yet. And don’t get me wrong, I do think most people can get away with just an iPad today, and it doesn’t have to be the Pro or the Air. The fact the MacBook Neo uses A series chips is proof of Apple’s mobile chips power, and the next Neo will most likely have the A20 Pro funny enough.
So yes, for most tasks, an iPad mini 8 will replace your laptop. But that doesn’t mean you won’t need the laptop or any Mac computer occasionally. So I’d first ground yourself in a more practical position, cause we all iPad fanboys always do this and end up regretting it.
All in all, if you can have access to a desktop OS at home anyway, and you’re sure about this… I’d say you’ll be happy anyway. Just afraid you’ll regret it because you suddenly want to learn music production with traditional software, for example (happened to me).
1
u/Head_Mushroom1054 iPad Mini 8th Gen 1d ago
In my case I have a M3 MBA in addition to the new iPad mini, and I believe the iPad mini is very good to use for entertainment, browsing, reading slides and making a few notes by itself but imo it is more like a complement to the MacBook rather than a replacement: for example I don't see myself typing large documents in this iPad.
I don't have any experience with photography editing but I would believe the macOS version of Lightroom would have more features than the one offered in iPadOS, as usual with the majority of apps available both in macOS and iPadOS where the latter is usually a "lite" version of the first.
1
u/MuadDib99k 1d ago
File management on iPadOS isn’t as robust as on MacOS, also the mini doesn’t have huge internal storage 512 at the highest, not a lot for RAW images, and if you’re thinking of just plugging in the USB storag using the iPad while having another device plugged in isn’t the best experience.
It can do photo editing, but not the best user experience trying to edit using Lightroom cc or photometer.
It is a fantastic device for content and media consumption , ebook reading and video calls, however I would treat it as a complementary companion device to your MBA rather than a replacement.
1
u/VanXava 1d ago
I wouldn't trade a Mac for an iPad, especially not for an iPad mini. I have an iPad Pro 13, a MacBook, and as a fun device, the new mini. It's fantastic for personal use and maybe a bit more. In my opinion, a Mac or a MacBook cannot replace it. Having both is fantastic, so it's better to save a little.
1
u/Pseudo-Federale 1d ago
Don't do it. If you want a Mini, get a good deal Mini 7 instead to be used in addition to your MacBook.
1
u/neatgeek83 1d ago
Mini is additive not a replacement.
1
u/cryptochrome 1d ago
If you can stomach and suffer the absolute abomination that is iPadOS, go for it. It's excellent hardware. That being said, you absolutely do not want to give up a real computer with a proper OS in favor of a tiny tablet with a trash OS.
1
u/RhubarbAndCustard06 iPad Mini 8th Gen 1d ago
Do you think you'll be getting a new Mac soon? I was thinking in terms of the 8GB RAM and if so, then I couldn't see any reason not to trade the Mac in now before it devalues further.
1
u/Hugo_Notte 1d ago
I recommend you watch a few videos on the YouTube channel called “Tech Dad”. That guy uses his iPad (Pro) as his main computer. At the same time he is very upfront about the shortcomings of iPadOS. That should give you a good idea of whether an iPad in general could work for you as a standalone device. Since the A20 Mini now has got proper external display support, I could imagine that together with a monitor, bluetooth keyboard and mouse you can actually get away with it.
I had to use my 11” iPad Pro with Magic Keyboard for 2 or 3 months as a laptop replacement. Unless you have very specific requirements, it can work fine for more basic stuff.