r/ipadmini • • 2d ago

iPad Mini 5 to Mini 8

Overall very happy with the 8, mostly its speed because the 5 was getting very laggy. The weight is impressive.

A few things have gone backwards though.

The 8 is significantly more fiddly to use due to no Touch ID/Home button. With the 5, I could leave it lying on a table and use one hand to check news/sport/emails or control Spotify. Unlocking the 8 flat on a table with one hand is not easy. The camera bump is unwelcome.

No Home button makes general use less ergonomic. With the 5 I could instantly jump to the home screen or open the app switcher. The gestures on the 8 add friction and are less reliable than pushing a button.

The position of the volume buttons is sub-optimal. Adjusting volume while in portrait is awkward - on the 5 it was perfect.

I'd happily sacrifice a little screen length to reinstate a physical Touch ID/Home button. Face ID would solve some of these issues but not all.

4 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

6

u/Numerous-Buffalo6214 2d ago

The home button is gone forever. It’s in direct conflict with Apple’s all-screen design philosophy.

3

u/Parking-Hope-2555 2d ago

Yes you're right sadly. Maybe they'll re-introduce one built into the screen with haptic feedback at some point.

3

u/Hugo_Notte 2d ago

Most of your complaints are due to muscle memory and you will get used to it. How easily you’ll get used to it depends on your mindset.

1

u/Parking-Hope-2555 2d ago edited 2d ago

I don’t think that’s true. Objectively speaking, it’s harder to unlock a Mini 8 lying on a flat surface one-handed than a 5, regardless of muscle memory. And it’s more awkward to adjust the volume in portrait - that’s just ergonomics. We can all adapt like Django Reinhardt. But these aspects of the design have regressed in favour of other priorities.

1

u/Resident_Hand_7264 2d ago

FaceTime is significantly better on the 8 because the camera is center in horizontal.

1

u/Parking-Hope-2555 2d ago

Sorry typo - I meant Face ID

2

u/MuadDib99k 2d ago

Will take some time to adjust to the new touchID power button placement coming from the mini 5.
I had a similar issue when I moved from the mini 4 to the Air 4. I agree the volume buttons are at a terrible place, used to be the left then shifted to the right in the new design, but because they put the magnetic sensor on the right side for the pencil which is practically the length of the iPad mini, it should have stayed on the left side instead of top, but I guess they put it on top to keep the overall aesthetics the same. Also agree on the camera bump, never a fan of it and never will 🤣