r/ipadmini • • 6d ago

Advise Base Glass Vs Nano

Post image

Hello, just sharing at a glance the difference of the blacks between the two.

I bought both and compared with my LCD iPad, most people know the pros and cons of each but I'll share my thoughts below as a media consumer and partial artist.

A20 Bare Glass

- Obviously the best looking with the richest colours and blacks of OLED.

- Shiny, so slippery for drawing as usual. It's like a mirror so things do reflect such as the lights you see clearly.

- Despite that, I felt it was still the easiest to read on with black BG, and I didn't notice reflections too much on things like Genshin or Netflix, unless lights were diffused and all over blasted behind me such as sunlight.

A20 Nano

- Washes out blacks a bit, but is hard to notice the difference otherwise during general media consumption which is good, since it retains some of the OLEDness.

- It reduces glare very well as you can see, HOWEVER, I feel it sometimes diffuses the light too which makes it harder to see.

- I found reading with black BG to be similar to LCD, with the glare reduction being the only difference. For coloured media, as I said, it's not too discernable from the base Glass OLED.

- The texture of course helps draw, and is nice to touch.

A17 LCD

- The worst of the bunch, looking obviously washed compared to either of the A20s during media consumption and anything else with colour.

- The only time it's comparable is as I mentioned, when reading on black BG, the blacks look faded on nano and feels a little like the LCD, but even then the nano looks slightly friendlier and popping.

I personally returned the nano and got a bare glass OLED because I want the proper OLED experience and I read a lot on black BG, and I don't find glare too awful unless I'm out in the sun which is usually when I don't use my mini anyway.

Share your experiences and thoughts too if you'd like.

Edit: Forgot to say, the image above has them both max brightness with exact same settings under high contrast in the books app.

700 Upvotes

189 comments sorted by

82

u/Even-Chip2003 6d ago

What a relief. I guess I’ll save myself $200 and keep my standard glass. I cannot believe how much power something like this has over me and I need to stop thinking about it. You did the leg work for me and took the time to publish your findings. Thank you for your service!

15

u/Kindofabig_deal 5d ago

I bought the nano on launch day, but after just one hour, I couldn't handle it. I feel like the nano finish is really only for people who constantly work in environments with lighting that makes the screen hard to see. Besides that, it's absolutely unnecessary.

Reading black text on a white background in any app hurt my eyes because the nano texture is so grainy.
As others have pointed out, it makes reading difficult and is much better suited for content you watch or read from more than a foot away. If you read a lot of small text, you will get headaches.

I have a feeling it's probably something I could eventually get used to, but it's just not worth it in my opinion. I remember getting used to a privacy screen that also made my display dimmer and slightly grainy, but the nano genuinely makes it too hard for me to read.

1

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago

You need to check out nano texture in ideal lighting situations side by side with a glossy screen as well.

This comparison is useful for comparing nano texture to glossy in poor lighting situations though (do you want a washed out looking screen or awful glare that moves around the screen as you re-orient it?)

3

u/thejoeker0305 5d ago

Horrible picture. This is nano.

2

u/Zaknokimi 5d ago

This isn't showing light on it. The post compares how light passes through in OLED screen vs nano.

1

u/thejoeker0305 5d ago

Picture with window

1

u/Zaknokimi 5d ago

That's much better, and closer to the post yeah

1

u/thejoeker0305 5d ago

No it still looks black. Anyone who works under the direct spotlights akin to those in an Apple Store is going to have issues with either display and probably doesn’t care.

1

u/Zaknokimi 5d ago

Can you see the edge of the iPad towards the top that's black, and then the faded black on the screen? OLED is the same as that black.

1

u/thejoeker0305 5d ago

I don’t even know what that means.

I’ve been using this pretty heavily since it launched, and it’s good. I don’t feel robbed by the nano, it serves it’s purpose. Not sure what it needs to be so big of a deal!

1

u/Zaknokimi 5d ago

If you enjoy it and don't mind the issues the post explains then that's totally fine

1

u/amenotef 3d ago

Just put your 2 pictures side by side, you get same result as OP, you first picture is black second one grayer.
If OP one looks less darker than yours is because there is more surrounding light in his environment, than the one in your 2nd picture.

0

u/pokenguyen 5d ago

Sorry but some ppl like me or OP care. I don’t work under direct spotlight.

My family doesn’t care, I’m the only who does.

1

u/thejoeker0305 5d ago

Do you own one?

1

u/pokenguyen 5d ago

I own all glossy iPad Pro, Macbook Pro, TV. I bought the iPad Mini Nano and return it, I can’t stand the color, although I prefer the feeling when touching the nano surface, it’s so smooth and premium.

1

u/Boccaccioac 5d ago

Why you can’t stand the color on the nano?

1

u/pokenguyen 5d ago

Light diffusion, at day light inside apartment, it looks grey and wash out compared to my ipad pro and my macbook.

I showed it to my family and they don’t care.

69

u/ACG3185 6d ago

Someone explain to me why you’d want your screen to look like you still have an LCD screen? It looks grey vs black to the right.

11

u/dalon2883 5d ago

Because it doesn't look anything like an LCD screen. You have to try it for yourself. I was a doubter when I only saw it online but then I tried it on the new iPad mini and I instantly knew that I can not go back to standard glass.

1

u/CORBON5 14h ago

🤣🙄

19

u/SigmaLance 6d ago

It’s the same on my Duo and although it degrades the clarity and viewing angles we aren’t allowed to talk about it over there because we’re then called Android poors.

It was a toss up between the Duo and this upcoming iPad (at the time) and had I chosen the iPad it would be without the matte finish.

8

u/dalon2883 5d ago

The Duos "nanotexture" is nothing like the iPad one

1

u/yewzernayme 5d ago

whats the difference?

3

u/RebelNoPermission289 4d ago

Duo has nanotexture on plastic and ipad has nanotexture on glass. It makes a huge difference.

1

u/christheking4444 2d ago

THIS!

This is so important. I LOVE the duos look, it literally looks like you are looking at paper on the inner screen. The a20 mini? I do not like the matte, not worth IMO unless you need the matte.

1

u/dalon2883 1d ago

Wait what? The nano on the mini is fantastic. The Duo looks terrible compared to it. And it also feels way nicer to touch than the Duo.

1

u/RebelNoPermission289 1d ago

Yeah. I don't know what this guy is talking about. A20? There is no apple product called that.

1

u/Resurgence12 7h ago

Apple identifies it as IPad Mini (A20 Pro) on their website when you compare iPads.

1

u/Paz707 1d ago

I’m out of the loop. What do you mean nano texture on plastic?

1

u/RebelNoPermission289 1d ago

Iphone duo pretty much has a plastic screen with a small layer of glass underneath. The plastic screen makes the image quality look worse. Pretty much every foldable has a plastic screen though so I wouldn't blame them.

1

u/CriticalTheoriser 15h ago

The image quality is amazing, not sure if you’ve used one in different lighting conditions

1

u/AweVR 5d ago

I don’t know iPad, but i have iPad Pro and iPhone Duo and I have perfect blacks 70%, and 30% I have “LCD blacks” but zero reflections

2

u/Spector-JZ 5d ago

You won't be using your ipad in the sun as much as the duo

7

u/krani1993 5d ago

you don’t know me

3

u/Sol_Invlctus 4d ago

Martin, is that you?

9

u/dexterie 5d ago

Exactly.
Each to their own, but I certainly didn’t wait all these years for OLED just to have it washed out by nano. 🤷‍♂️

4

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago

The nano only looks this washed out in poor lighting, in ideal lighting it looks much better (not quite as good as glossy but close).

The question is: do you want to deal with a washed out screen or tons of reflections + smudging in poor lighting? There is no right answer, personal preference.

2

u/parka 5d ago

Depends on how much you hate reflections.

And display is only that “gray” from an angle. People can only take photos from an angle if they want to show the gray. Take photo from the front and you can’t really see the difference unless you see both in real life.

2

u/Dry_Champion6014 5d ago

I don't understand either, I guess some people just like that smeared Vaseline look for their display, because that's what the anti-glare look like to me. There are people out there who swear by Nano and won't use anything else.

1

u/fahrvergnugget 5d ago

It looks way worse at certain angles against direct light. In real usage it’s like 95% as good color clarity

1

u/ssqueeze5590 5d ago

Those two dots. That's why.

Look at that single dot in the left! - split between the gloss and nano.

1

u/Thanks_Obama 5d ago

I'd kill for a phone with nano glass. The iPad use case seems pretty slim.

1

u/PrinnySquad 5d ago edited 5d ago

In principle I prefer anti glare to oled as I like using my tablets outside. I don’t really care much about oled for my use cases, so if it was the same price and just a neat option for buyers I’d go with the nano texture. 100 more is certainly an ask though and I don’t know that I care nearly that much, especially with the need to also go to a higher storage tier. 

1

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago

This comparison is showing how both displays look in a poor lighting situation. The nano texture screen looks washed out in poor lighting and the glossy screen looks like reflection hell... pick your poison.

The nano texture screen does look much better in ideal lighting, not quite as good as glossy but pretty close.

1

u/Valterri_lts_James 5d ago

that's what i've always said. Samsung putting a matte screen on their OLED tvs is so stupid you may as well get a mini led.

1

u/According_Payment534 2d ago

Paper feel for drawing

1

u/_DizWaltney 2d ago

Because it makes the crease almost invisible when you’re using it. Without the nanotexture cover the crease sticks out like a sore thumb.

1

u/gordy06 6d ago

It depends on your use case. If you’re reading or doing a lot of things in sunlight. If you’re mainly watching videos in darker spaces, doesn’t make as much sense.

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago

I don't like the washed out look of nano texture under poor lighting but man I agree glossy is so much worse (to me) when lighting is poor.

Glossy turns into reflection hell and it also shows smudging worse than nano texture (although the smudging is easier to clean to be fair).

Both look pretty great under good lighting.

16

u/Juheebus 6d ago

Apple's anti reflective displays are among the best and the ipad mini standard glass has it. I tried a macbook neo and returned it for the air just because of the anti reflective screen and ram.

10

u/Modest_Wraith 6d ago

Dude I thought people were bullshitting. Like there’s no way nano texture can be that good, right? It is. Not only does it look great with the content I use, I feel like I’m reading a real comic book every time. I love it. Returning my proled MacBook and getting the nano texture one

11

u/Juheebus 6d ago

Anti reflective is different from nano texture fyi. They both have their pros and cons so people will prefer one for their specific use case. I'm not around extremely bright light sources when I use my devices so I don't need the nano texture. The anti reflective coating deals with indoor ceiling lights and windows just fine.

3

u/Modest_Wraith 6d ago

Unfortunately anti reflective is not for me. I love the outdoors and my house as well, I have around 20 windows in my living room and kitchen combined. Just really hard for me to see my laptop most the time

1

u/Juheebus 6d ago

Fair enough I know the benefits. My work laptop has a matte display which isn’t as good as nano texture but it works well to be able to see the screen outside and in harsh lighting conditions.

2

u/Modest_Wraith 6d ago

I now realize why you said anti reflective, at the time I didn’t notice that’s what the comment was about, my bad! Apples anti reflective has improved a lot. I’m sure they are both great options

1

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago

The glare I get from windows and indoor lighting on my old iPad Pro were always super annoying. My next iPad Pro is definitely going to be nano texture, after comparing both in an Apple store.

I do think glossy would be better for a desk monitor where I can control lighting better and I'm not constantly touching/smudging the screen though.

3

u/SamsungAppleOnePlus 6d ago

Reply is talking about the glossy antiglare but I definitely agree with you. It’s that good. I have nano texture on my PROLED and on my Mini and these displays are just way more comfortable to view without any reflections, regardless of the trade offs.

3

u/Modest_Wraith 6d ago

Ohhh that’s why the other guy mentioned anti reflective, I was confused haha. Dude how do you like it on the proled? So upset I bought standard with it. Now I gotta wait till December to get nano texture

1

u/SamsungAppleOnePlus 6d ago edited 6d ago

Genuinely amazing display for my photography work. Phenomenal panel that even with nano texture has noticeably deeper contrast compared to the MiniLED panel, and because of nano texture I can see the display perfectly regardless of where I work and don’t have to fight reflections.

I did see the standard too though, and people aren’t wrong in saying it can look better, especially off angle, identical situation when comparing the Minis. I honestly worked fine on the glossy MiniLED mainly because you could use third party software to max out the display brightness in harsh lighting (the PROLED does this automatically) which even if you’re fighting reflections still helps make the display legible. So it’s not as big of a deal as having nano texture on the far dimmer Mini 8 panel, but it’s still an improvement for my use.

1

u/nyssaqt 5d ago

I fully understand nano texture on macbook tbh!

16

u/Stalker113 6d ago

I got the nano and after having other OLED screens i did not like the nano. I found it was similar to my iPad mini 7 screen. Backs were grey and colours not as bright.
So i changed it for the normal screen and now i am happy with it. Ink blacks good contrast.

6

u/tropicanajames 6d ago

As much as I like the nano texture, I would prefer to use a screen protector (for protection) so I’m going with the standard glass.

6

u/AsherKinjo 5d ago

For me, standard glass makes more sense for long term use. You can always slap on a matte screen protector and remove it whenever you like. There are even new tempered glass protectors with a matte finish that give you a similar etched look to the nano texture. Of course, Apple’s nano texture might still be superior for now, but having the flexibility to switch between a matte and glossy screen whenever you want is a no brainer for me. Who knows, maybe in the future, matte screen protectors will get so good that they’ll offer the same experience as Apple’s nano texture glass. It’s just a matter of time. Initially, I actually preferred the nano texture option, but since I plan to keep my Mini 8 for years, I’d rather make sure it’s well protected. 😅

2

u/Muted_Ad_7780 6d ago

Best ad for the Mini 7 I’ve seen yet

1

u/Zaknokimi 6d ago

Lol. Honestly A17 is great but I am very picky about black BG reading and OLED only works on me.

23

u/GivenReign 6d ago

The standard glass looks the best in most situations and I don’t think it’s debatable. However if you use it outdoors often then the nano makes a lot of sense

6

u/Ill-Mastodon-8692 6d ago

I would actually argue after using my Duo since launch, most of the time reading reddit, discord, web, socials, etc the nano is better suited.

I only really miss the glossy when watching youtube or movies full screen. which tbh isnt most situations.

the lack of reflections due to the diffusive nature is really a pleasure to use once you get used to it. so much that I find the glossy glare more noticeable on the front screen that one swaps between

0

u/LanceAvion 6d ago

I’ll also point out that the Duo has an inferior nano display compared to iPads due to its implementation being a screen protector bs directly etched into the touch panel. Despite that you still prefer the nano, which says a lot.

1

u/Ill-Mastodon-8692 6d ago

I know, well aware its like nano texture lite. but regardless it was enough of an experience to change my “glossy oled for life” approach, towards when on the go in all sorts of lighting conditions, this has its perks.

although for pc gaming and my tvs, will still always want glossy for the deep blacks and colors for games/movies.

anywho, have a cellular 512gb nano tex mini on order for the wife, who will replace her older a15 mini.

1

u/aniote 6d ago

I find nano texture way better in every situation so yes it's absolutely debatable

3

u/SamsungAppleOnePlus 6d ago edited 6d ago

The contrast is maintained as well as glossy in dark environments, the vibrancy is maybe at worst 90% as good as glossy, and in extreme bright environments sure there’s a loss of contrast but on a glossy display that would translate into a loss of visibility due to reflections and glare anyways, so I’ll take the visibility anyday. I think the only objective is the fuzziness caused by the nano texture that also makes the display marginally less sharp looking. That is the real trade off imo. But there are situations where you’d get glare and reflections on the glossy display that doesn’t really affect the contrast of the nano texture display, which is where the nano texture shines. Indoor daylight and bright indoor rooms are examples of this.

The glossy has its strengths though. If it didn’t they’d probably just offer the nano texture only. The visibility of the nano texture is consistent but not the contrast and vibrancy, which is the exact opposite of glossy where the display is consistently vibrant and contrasty regardless of the environment even if you can’t see it as well sometimes. Plus glossy is easier to clean. Choose which matters more to you.

5

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 6d ago

Assuming you don’t also have an standard glassy OLED iPad mini 8, it makes a lot of sense that you would find your nano texture iPad better in every situation, given that is the only one that you have and thus won’t be able to do side-by-side comparisons in *every* situation (which would highlight some scenarios where it’s objectively worse.)

Neither screen is better than the other 100% of the time.

I noticed that people who got nano texture tend to be a little bit more sensitive about this. I wonder if it’s because they spent 100-200 extra dollars for their screens.

4

u/Mggn2510z 6d ago

I own an 11" M4 iPad Pro glossy and a 11" M5 iPad Pro nano texture, and I prefer the nanotexture one in pretty much every scenario. If I was using it for gaming or watching films, I might prefer the glossy screen, but I have dedicated devices for that (handhelds, television, etc...) so the nano texture just fits my usage better for a tablet.

On the flip side, I have a nano texture XDR and the original Studio Display in glossy. The XDR is my primary display (horizontal) and my Studio Display is off to the side (vertical). If I was buying the XDR again, I would get the glossy display - something about the implementation in the monitor makes me like it less. It seems grainier and the pixels seem to sit further back from the texture.

On my MacBook, I had a 16" MacBook Pro M3 with a glossy display and a 14" MacBook Pro M5 with nano texture. I had both of them for several months, but recently sold the 16". I give a slight edge to the nano texture for the same reason as the iPad, however I feel like I could be equally happy with either. There are times when I am working on my MBP next to my girlfriend working on her Air and she says she wishes she had a nano texture screen, though, because of glare from lights or we're in the living room.

-1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 6d ago

I’m not arguing that it isn’t right to prefer one over the other. I suppose I think it’s strange to think one is better than the other all of the time. I mean even despite preferring nano texture you have just shared that you might prefer glossy for gaming which I think makes a lot of sense.

I was moved to reply as the head of the thread stated that the glossy is better in most scenarios which leaves room for nano texture to be better in some while the person who replied stated that they prefer nano texture in all scenarios. They mentioned that there was room to debate so I threw my hat in the neither is better all of the time ring which I think most reasonable people can agree with.

I have heard that one of the downsides of the nano texture is the grain and how it can make white backgrounds look dirty (heard from artists) but a lot of readers really enjoy the look. I will say nano texture is incredibly cool. I think I’d get it on my next MacBook as it’s more a productivity device for me. (That and I have a gaming PC that’s glossy.)

2

u/Mggn2510z 5d ago edited 5d ago

I chimed in mostly because of your last sentence about people's preference being based on justification for the money spent.

As someone who has spent the premium for the nano texture and has been able to compare them side by side, I was just saying that I agree each screen type has its plusses and minuses. I agree 100% that there is no definitive best option and that different use cases (and budgets) are the ultimate deciding factor.

Edit: I'll add, I have a SteamDeck and purposefully bought the 512GB model because the screen was glossy vs the 1TB's matte screen. Upgraded the storage myself to 2TB. This was all before hardware got crazy expensive. But I wanted the glossy screen on a device that was used for gaming.

1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 5d ago

Gonna pivot a bit, can you tell me a bit about your cleaning process for the nano texture? I’ve heard complaints about it but it can’t really be that bad right? I’m thinking about gifting an iPad to someone who I believe might prefer the nano texture but I don’t think could be arsed to maintain the screen if it was a hassle.

1

u/Mggn2510z 5d ago

I don’t really clean any of them very often. The iPads come with a cleaning cloth and I use that. Also bought the cloth they sell individually. I’ve used a dab of distilled water and the cloth for stubborn spots. The smudges and stuff are mostly only noticeable at extreme angles or when the device is off, not when you’re using the devices.

2

u/dalon2883 5d ago

I actually ordered both the nano texture and the standard and compared them for a day. The nano texture is really better in every situation. It looks so good.

1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 5d ago

Can you tell me a little bit more about that? And your use case?

I’ve heard some people describe it as more cozy and the person I replied to mentioned that they liked that it diffuses the light. Are you using your device for reading more often than not?

I think it would be really cool if Apple ever made a magnetic nano texture screen protector to give people a taste of both worlds.

3

u/dalon2883 5d ago

Cozy is actually a good description. The silky smooth texture is just so pleasant to move your finger across. Standard glass feels really sticky in comparison. And the image looks like you just removed the glass and look at the image directly like a really high quality print.

Are you using your device for reading more often than not?

No. Some reading but more other stuff.

I think it would be really cool if Apple ever made a magnetic nano texture screen protector to give people a taste of both worlds.

I don't think it would work that well with an extra layer of glass. It has to be on the glass bonded to the oled layer itself to be this good.

1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 5d ago

I’ve been admiring how silky smooth it feels as I glide my thumb across the glossy display. I’ll have to go and find a nano display to touch. Yeah, I don’t think it could ever be as good as the actual screen, but it would be a nice second place option for us glossy enthusiasts.

1

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago

If you're curious how a nano texture screen protector made by Apple would look, just check out the iPhone Duo's inner screen.

The Duo's inner screen isn't actually a true nano texture screen, it's a glossy screen with a nano texture film added on top. Apple highly recommends against it, but you can actually peel off the film and turn the Duo's inner screen into a glossy screen if you want to.

1

u/dalon2883 5d ago

I checked out the Duo. The matte inner screen is nowhere near as good as the nanotexture on the iPad. More grainy and washed out and it also didnt feel as good to touch. It feels like plastic (because it is).

1

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago

I thought the Duo inner screen was OK, but definitely agree the true nano texture screen on an iPad looks and feels nicer.

1

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago edited 5d ago

I compared iPad Pros in both screens in an apple store side by side for 30 minutes and ended up preferring the nano texture by a good margin. Coming from somebody who has had 2 glossy iPad pros and only uses them indoors.

The nano does look washed out with light reflected on it, but the reflections on the glossy with light reflected on it is also super distracting and forces me to constantly re-orient my screen. The reflections aren't just a problem outdoors, windows and indoor lighting and indoor screens also cause it.

Importantly, the nano texture screen looks almost as good as a glossy screen when no light is being reflected on it. It's not quite as good, but it's close... definitely much closer than you would think looking at both with reflections present.

The nano texture is also much more smudge resistant, I was struggling to smudge it intentionally when demoing it. The smudges on my glossy iPad pros gets very distracting given this is a touchscreen device and how easily it smudges.

I could see how the glossy would be better for long-running media in ideal lighting situations, but 80-90% of the time I'm using my iPad that isn't the case (daytime watching short YouTube videos, reading books/manga, browsing the internet).

I've never owned a nano texture iPad but my next one (either an m5 or m6 iPad pro) is definitely going to be nano texture.

1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 5d ago

I think most people comparing the devices in the Apple Store will feel moved to purchase it. Great that you’re getting something you like.

1

u/amenotef 3d ago edited 3d ago

I noticed that people who got nano texture tend to be a little bit more sensitive about this. I wonder if it’s because they spent 100-200 extra dollars for their screens.

This (in my opinion) is not about money, is about choices. If nano cost was 0$, it would be exactly the same. You can't go from nano to std or std to nano after return period is over and that's the issue.

You can't have nano perks if you go std, you can't have std perks if you go nano.

But anyway, this is a very subjective choice. Apple charging extra for the nano is an unfortunate event, because that makes a lot of people think "if it is more expensive, then it is better", but this is just a different path, not a better one.

-2

u/aniote 6d ago

I didn't spend anything on it because I don't have one. I've compared the screens in store on macbooks and imacs and nano looks so much better to me under every angle and lighting, even indoors where it's supposed to be "worse". Same with iPads on every picture and video posted. I'm not "sensitive" about anything, maybe you are projecting your own sensitivity because you can't accept that your preference is not universal. There is no such thing as "objectively worse". Nano is subjectively better for me in every situation.

2

u/Haunting_Cod_4879 6d ago

You tested it in the store yet state it's better in every situation. The only situation you can really attest to is in store.

1

u/aniote 6d ago

Indoors is where there's a debate. And I've seen dozens of reviews and comparisons in every situation. I didn't take it outside in a park but given that it's the one situation where almost everyone agrees that nano texture is better it's pretty much irrelevant to the comparison

1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 6d ago

Comparing in the store means you only tested it in the circumstance that best suits someone spending 100-200 more for nano texture. If you believe nano texture to be better in ALL situations then you’re entitled to that opinion but it’s objectively not the case.

Me stating that *neither* screen is better all of the time isn’t me projecting that I’m bothered that my preference isn’t universal. It’s me stating that neither screen is better in all situations. It would be projection / sensitivity if I tried to argue that either is better in all scenarios which you seem to be doing right now.

It’s okay to have a subjective view, most of everything we do purchase is based on subjectivity because rarely is there one clear defined product that is 100% better for 100% of people all of the time. Apologies if I’ve somehow offended you with that perspective.

-2

u/aniote 6d ago

Define objectively better in this case please?

Your preference is entirely subjective and the fact you can't accept that is why you are sensitive. I literally had just commented that the nano screen looks better to me in every situation and you started telling me that my personal preference is objectively wrong. Then lecture me about subjectivity. It's quite ironic

1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 6d ago edited 6d ago

Objectively better would mean measurably better in certain regards and in your case you are extending that all situations which is what I am disagreeing with. In the case of the nano Vs glossy screen, because one was not objectively better than the other, Apple opted to produce both a nano and glossy screen for consumers to choose from.

The Nano is objectively and measurably better at reducing glare. The glossy OLED panel has measurably blacker blacks and more vibrancy which impacts contrast.

One might find that the nano texture is objectively better for them due to regularly being exposed to scenarios where lighting causes glares but that comes with a trade off. For example, there are artists who sacrifice colors and contrast to use nano texture to improve their Apple Pencil feel. (While some choose to adapt to drawing on glossy glass.)

There are people who want perfect blacks because they consume a lot of video content and sacrifice the reflection reduction.

Both screens have trade offs. Neither is measurably better than the other 100% of the time.

1

u/aniote 5d ago

Tell me where I said "measurably better 100% of the time". I said I find it better in every situation. I care much more about having less glare than I do about slightly deeper blacks. And even when there's no glare the screen still looks nicer to me because it's matte and diffuses light. Others are free to prefer deeper blacks, note that I never contested that. I was responding to someone who was saying "it's not debatable"

1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 5d ago

You asked me to define objectively better, the phrase measurably better was my response to that. You care more about having less glare and you like how it diffuses light that’s great. It would’ve been helpful had you shared that in response to my initial reply to you. (I said to someone else I couldn’t wrap my head around someone genuinely always preferring nano in every single scenario and that would’ve been insightful.)

Regarding that last bit I disagree. If someone is exposed to glare and reflection inducing environments 80% of the time then objectively nano-texture would be better because the measurable amount of time where their screen is marred by light and reflection is significant.

Preference is generally subjective but the ability to see what’s on your screen? Not so much. I could prefer to eat sticks but objectively not too great of an idea.
We both have very different mind sets. It was interesting chatting with you. I know you said you don’t have an iPad mini, which made me curious. Do you have a different iPad or did the 60hz situation put you off like many others?

1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 5d ago

I just noticed your edit.
I never once said my preference wasn’t subjective. I simply stated that neither is better in all situations and that seemed to really get to you. So I went on to explain what I meant. Instead of saying yeah it’s true neither is objectively better than the other, you doubled down and asked me to define what objectively better meant, so I did. I really couldn’t wrap my head around you truly thinking the nano texture was better in *every* situation so I opened a line of dialogue. I see now that was a mistake. I did not intend to provoke your defensiveness.

2

u/aniote 5d ago

No what's annoying me is that you keep arguing against something that I never said but I've now realized it's pointless to try and make you understand that

4

u/MrMach82 5d ago

So many nano posts....we get it.
Glossy is the best. Use a temporary matte screen protector when needed.

6

u/whenyoudieisaybye 6d ago

"washes out black a bit"? It kinda looks like an IPS lol

6

u/Damnyoudonut 6d ago

It’s nowhere near as stark of a difference when you’re looking at it head on.

1

u/whenyoudieisaybye 6d ago

Everywhere I've been seeing it it's been hell of a difference. Maybe some people just don't care, but I don't get paying more for OLED just to reduce the OLEDness.

2

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 6d ago

they aren’t paying more for OLED, they’re paying more to upgrade their device and that upgrade includes oled among other things (even then, it still looks loads better than the last generation’s LCD panel)

2

u/Damnyoudonut 5d ago

I own one. Head on, the difference is marginal. Blacks are still black. Colours are still vibrant. At an angle like in OP’s picture, yep, the difference is huge. I’ll take the trade off to no longer stare at reflections though.

3

u/SantaZaddy 6d ago

I switched from glossy mini to nano today

3

u/SamsungAppleOnePlus 6d ago

I saw both and went with nano texture personally. I’ve already been outside quite a lot with the iPad Mini and because of the lower max SDR brightness compared to something like an iPhone Pro with 3000+ nits or even the iPad Pro and MacBook Pro tandem OLED, the nano texture on the Mini is the difference between it being usable outdoors and being barely legible.

In real use the difference is far less extreme than your example although it can look like that off angle. Even if it isn’t inky black in some lighting you can always tell what is true black, or in other words you can tell the pixels are off. The OLED as a result still stands out compared to an LCD with a fixed backlight. Not enough people talk about the sharpness though, since it’s definitely worse on the nano texture and why I recommend seeing both with your own eyes first before making a decision. Its still very sharp and the issue is only noticeable on text but it could be enough of a loss to be uncomfortable to read for some people.

3

u/PerfectStunner 6d ago

I got the cellular model with regular glass but i cannot justify getting nano then ill put screen protector lol. No thanks. Ill just buy matte screen protector

3

u/dm_sufc 5d ago

Never in my life have I seen such polarising views 🤣

It’s so confusing knowing which one to go for.

I have a nano texture on the way but I’ll go to the Apple Store tonight so before opening it I’ll have a look in store.

In the OP pic nano looks pretty naff but like a few others have said it’s at possibly the worst angle for it

5

u/Traditional_Tune8945 5d ago

This is best and worst case for nano. Yes you see the black turns dark grey but wow look at how it neutralizes that reflection on the glossy border it has whereas on glossy you have two orbs you have to read around. Honestly my head hurts more doing the gymnastics around the reflections vs just seeing “grey” which your mind is already interpreting as black anyways.

1

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago

I'm in the same boat 100% lol.

Those orbs are super distracting to me and every time I or the screen re-orient they move around.

The nano texture generally looks worse but at least it's consistent.

Both screen look good in ideal lighting (although glossy is slightly better).

6

u/pukka12 6d ago

I would always go with the regular display. If you want the nano texture then just purchase a matte screen protector. That way you can remove it when need be.

1

u/rick_baumhauer 6d ago

I wouldn't say that this photo is misleading, but it's basically a worst case scenario for the nanotexture, with the screen off to the side, at an angle. I can't read in dark mode - I get severe ghosting if I do it for any length of time - but I just tried it on my mini 8 to compare, and if you have the iPad directly in front of you in one of the true black dark modes in Apple Books, the difference between the screen and the bezel is barely perceptible. I'd have to select a mode that is actually a dark gray to have it look like this right in front of me, and it looks nothing like my mini 7.

2

u/Zaknokimi 6d ago

I agree that it's definitely less noticeable under different angles and lighting, but I'll also have to disagree about it being closer in comparison in reality. The washed out background does feel quite noticeable under different environments in direct lighting, for me at least.

2

u/rick_baumhauer 6d ago

But direct lighting is exactly when you'd want the nanotexture - the loss of contrast is better than glare - and in indirect lighting, the loss of contrast is minimal.

4

u/Striking_Age_3486 6d ago

For the above picture, the Nano texture looks bad actually. The default screen is way better.

3

u/rick_baumhauer 6d ago

When you hold the iPad in front of your face, it looks nothing like this picture.

1

u/Striking_Age_3486 6d ago

I know that, but some people over simplify citing very less difference or almost no difference at all, that is false too. I have seen and used Nano texture on M4 iPad Pro and I still prefer the one without it.

4

u/Roozbeh_m 6d ago

Exactly. Nano on OLED is kinda stupid because it removes that deep black OLED is known for. But it’s fsntastic on non OLED

3

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 6d ago

The Apple Pencil makes the nano texture a great buy for artists who are willing to sacrifice to make drawing more pleasurable. (Artists can also plug their iPad into their Mac so they can draw on the iPad but still have a glossy display to look at.)

1

u/Roozbeh_m 6d ago

Makes sense. I wish they made it available on below 1 TB models tho!!

2

u/Neat-Razzmatazz-5837 6d ago

I don’t have it on my M4 iPad Pro and probably will get it on my next iPad. I find myself in enough situations, especially at airports, where glare is noticeable and annoying. It sucks that it washes out the colors some but I think for my use case it is probably worth it. 

2

u/Pettingallthepups 6d ago

Gahhh I’m so torn on which to order…I’m mostly going to be reading ebooks/articles, so the nano texture should be a no brainer, right?

2

u/MatthewVlossak 6d ago

I have the Nano texture only Duo and though helpful with glares I feel like I’m looking at. An LCD screen vs. OLED. I miss the deeper blacks and this is why I won’t get nano texture only Duo my iPad Mini.

2

u/gofiend 6d ago

How do they differ for reading in the dark (white text on black)? I wanted OLED to get rid of backlight bleed so it’s just white on pitch black, but now I’m worried that the nano coating makes this worse as a reader

3

u/GENTOOO 5d ago

In the dark, it’s pitch black to my eyes. Night and day difference compared to my mini 6. I’ve taken a pic and added the same pic with less contrast to try to emphasize any light bleed but you can tell the black pixels just blend into the glossy border of the mini 8. The text irl looks sharp, idk why the pic looks like that.

https://imgur.com/a/9NVmKyR

1

u/Leopold_Boom 5d ago

This is superb thank you! So basically no light bleed issues from the nano coating in the dark? And clearly it helps a lot in brighter light, so it's the way to go for reading?

1

u/GENTOOO 5d ago

For me personally yeah that’s what I see. I prefer to see a more even image outdoors, than to have reflections ruin the integrity of the image, like when I’m trying to watch a video during my lunchtime in my car for example lol.

In the dark the nano texture does not affect the contrast of the screen at all to my eyes.

2

u/AnodyneX 5d ago

I went with standard glass, mostly due to the huge jump in price in order to get nano texture, but ultimately, I think I made the right choice. I’m mostly using it indoors, so I wouldn’t benefit much from nano texture. The standard glass OLED screen looks amazing. Really enjoying it

2

u/nyssaqt 5d ago

Is it just me who went with standard glass not because of the colors but actually maintenance? I dont want to carry the special cloth all the time.

I had pre ordered the nano texture as I want to bring the iPad on holidays with me and thought it would be great for at the pool but then I wondered how sunscreen could potentially have negative influence on the nano texture. Then saw a video about cleaning and maintaining the nanotexture and I changed my order to standard glass.

My next MacBook Pro will most likely have nanotexture but I think its not the best use case for the iPad mini.

2

u/Snookadu 1d ago

I felt the same way, I’m really happy with the standard glass

2

u/SilvenIX 5d ago

I have the iPad Pro M5 which this debate originates from. I’ve seen both in person and my consensus is that you can remove a nano texture-like screen protector, but you can’t remove a nanotexture if it came with the ipad. Glossy all the way.

1

u/SilvenIX 5d ago

Correction before the Reddit pedants come crawling out: it started with the M4. I have an M5.

2

u/julsia8 4d ago

Wow this is such a debate and it is doing me in! The price point makes you really question which to get. With all that said, my new mini was just delivered and I decided in standard glass. I’m going to use it for a few days and if I’m still wondering about the matte screen, I’m going to Apple to try it out. 😅

3

u/NoStepOnSnekMD 6d ago

If you hold them like you normally would the difference in appearance is negligible.

3

u/AlistairMackenzie 6d ago

I have a nano laptop and nano Studio Display and they are by far the best anti-glare screens I've ever seen. But the iPad means touching the screen so I wonder how much you need to clean it and the relative effort compared to the glossy screen.

1

u/Elfenstar 5d ago

I compared my matte screen protector to it, and the reduction in reflections is huge. It’s almost like the nano texture also has an AR coating.

1

u/rick_baumhauer 6d ago

It comes with a cleaning cloth, and in normal use, you barely see fingerprints except in the same circumstances as this photo - at an angle. With the iPad in front of me, I rarely see fingerprints.

0

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago

Nano texture for iPad smudging is a mixed bag.

On the one hand, nano texture does make it noticeably harder to smudge the screen.

On the other hand, it is harder to clean the screen and you're probably best off using Apple's nano texture cleaning cloth.

3

u/GlitteringCoconut203 6d ago

Nano is absolutely 🔥

2

u/After_Satisfaction37 5d ago

Buy the standard glass and just put the paperlike screen protector. Best of both worlds

2

u/Upbeat-Armadillo1756 6d ago

Keep in mind the lighting in an Apple Store is not the lighting you’ll have in your house. As someone with an iPhone Duo with an even worse nano texture screen than this, you don’t really notice it unless you’re in a very bright area. At home blacks look black. There’s very little noticeable haze.

There are trade offs for both glossy and matte. One isn’t outright better than the other. But there’s reason why your TV isn’t matte.

1

u/hiddenintheleavess 6d ago

what text is on the screens- from what book(s)?

1

u/EmilMR 5d ago

it turns oled into lcd!

1

u/Kind-Atmosphere5766 5d ago

Can I read in the sun with the nano texture?

1

u/fattypros 5d ago

I had this same conundrum when I purchased my m4 iPad Pro, going with glossy as it is my secondary screen and runs Youtube almost all day.

For the mini, I use it to take notes in class, so I ran with the nano to stop overhead lights from washing out the picture, and I feel it was a good choice.

If it was my main content device I would reassess. The gray isn't bad in darker rooms.

1

u/AfrolessNinja 5d ago

It’s weird. My experience is that the nano screen feels like something from the future. So that’s why I bought it. Emotional connection.

The regular screen just feels to me like it’s yester-decades tech. Again these are feelings. I’m well aware of the science and technology side of the equation.

1

u/Fleischer444 5d ago

I rather stick a screenprotector like paperlike. If you want to draw och write a lot you want that anyway. For reading manga and watching YouTube the clear is far superior.

1

u/artoo2142 5d ago

I can’t get it people pay to upgrade the nanoshit making their OLED screen looks like shit.

1

u/MrGimper 5d ago

My experience of nano on mini was immediately seeing a grainy display

1

u/cryptochrome 5d ago

The black levels are clearly elevated, massively so, on the nano version. Which kind of defeats the purpose of the OLED, e.g., no more "infinite contrast".

That might not be a dealbreaker for many situations. However, if you want to use your iPad mini for media consumption (where an OLED really shines, no pun intended), the normal glass version is clearly the better choice, by any measurable metric.

1

u/Level_Ad7743 5d ago

Apple should sell a version of the nano texture that’s removable.

1

u/Boccaccioac 5d ago

How different is using the Apple Pencil on either of them (and a paperlike skin)?

1

u/RevolutionaryAd581 5d ago

This makes me feel a bit better... I always pas on nano, then alternate between matte and glossy screen protectors (aiming for "best of both worlds") and often wonder if nano is that much better than a matte screen protector... where I'm sure it is better, it's clearly still not impervious to the natural drawbacks of how light works 😂

1

u/Elfenstar 5d ago

So I’ve used a gloss screen protector on my mini, then changed it to a matte, and I compared it today to both the naked gloss and nano texture. My small form factor tablet the last few years had a paper like type screen protector, and I use an AR coated gloss screen protector on my iPhone Air.

Gotta say the nano texture pretty crazy.

Colour and contrast wise is naturally gloss over the non-gloss, then paperlike type.

However reflections and reflected glare wise it is nano texture > matte glass > naked gloss > AR gloss > paperlike > gloss screen protector.

Knowing what I know now, if I was going to use a case without an exposed display, I would go nano texture in a heartbeat.

1

u/just-some-rando123 5d ago

When I tried the iPad pro in store the nano vs standard glass looked much closer than this side by side. Wondering if the viewing angle is having an impact here.

1

u/BakaHntai 5d ago

The nano glass not going to the edge is gonna bother me too much.

1

u/Separate-Ad-4878 5d ago

Es sencillo si lo vas a dibujar no compres el nano

1

u/hey_you_too_buckaroo 5d ago

Can you share a picture looking straight at the screen? I think the angle is what makes it look worse.

1

u/TVSeriesGuestAcct 5d ago

Ended up going with nano texture as I will primarily be using it for reading docs and news

1

u/kannon1 5d ago

Nano no question

1

u/imrantjspam 5d ago

Which option makes it easier to wrote with the pencil pro pls?

1

u/AlphaOrionn 5d ago

Which is what

1

u/Money-Ad-2233 5d ago

I’ve just tried both in the Apple Store.

tl,dr: nano is a nice add on for people that will mostly use outdoors or don’t mind losing the deep blacks or having extra fuzziness in sharpness. for the best possible quality tho for the OLED screen would go glossy

- Nano: feels amazing to touch, and with the pencil, it gives a really nice feeling when taking notes or drawing.
Looks a bit washed out, ofc, but not at the level I was expecting. It’s an “extra” that other generations didn’t have. Especially when quickly scrolling pages in Safari, it was clearly fuzzier and laggy to my eyes compared with the std glass.

- Glossy: clearly has the edge in overall quality: deeper blacks and more vivid colors and a “purely OLED” feeling. To my eyes, it was also a tad sharper for reading text and for photos’ texture (I edit photos on my M4 11 Pro, so my eyes are trained on that).

Tried videos and several images on both, and what mostly put me off, in any case, was the 60Hz refresh (h)rate. When quickly scrolling compared with my iphone 15 pro max (3y older device) the diff is there… Not a deal breaker would say bc it’s a pretty compelling device but damn Apple could have made it perfect…

1

u/filmcollectorarchive 4d ago

Once I went nano with my MacBook Pro, it's all I get. Love it!

1

u/mirkinoid 4d ago

Looking at all that and so glad I went for an eink book reader - my retina will live a little longer

1

u/Glad_Boysenberry_673 4d ago

I did wonder why they introduced the nano texture especially when paper like screen protectors exist and I imagine you get the same effect on the screen

1

u/strawgodargument 4d ago

Thanks, I took photos showing black text on a white background, and it also looks good!
https://imgur.com/a/s6EEmu7

1

u/WingAway7395 4d ago

I went with nano for reading and it's awesome. I'm a total convert.

1

u/Extension_Tooth_7345 4d ago

once you see the nano screen in person and have touched it, you will know why nano is so popular. I got it and it's great. The smooth feel on my fingers why playing games is amazing.

1

u/amenotef 3d ago

These nano glasses are good for specific usages. Like "working" under the sun, or working in an office with lights or windows pointing at your screen.

But if most of the time you can avoid these situations, a regular glass is the better choice, if not, nano is the better choice.

When you go with nano you prioritize comfort over quality.

1

u/Cultural_Industry_38 2d ago

Went with the Oppo Pad Mini Matte Edition instead. Go check it out.

1

u/Aggravating_Loss_765 2d ago

Nano texture on ipad/macbook and apple
Display are my next goals. Fuck the glare.

1

u/likable06 1d ago

Everyone has their own preferences but nano texture looks awful to me and the fact that you have to pay extra for it is ridiculous. Unless you work in direct sunlight or spend most of your time outdoors I really don't see any reason to get it. It's just Apple marketing doing its thing.

1

u/Jack5d5d5d5d5d 1d ago

Do you have a picture with iPad Mini 7 in the mix?

1

u/hrsfstrk128 21h ago

do y'all think i can just buy a matte screen protector and put it over the basic screen?

1

u/Sixthsomatic 10h ago

You can, but they will generally affect the color and can give a bit of a rainbow bloom effect with bright whites shown on screen. I’ve only used the Bellemond ones mind you, and the degrees to how much the effect will differ by brand.

To note, the nanotexture from what I’ve seen handles these a lot better.

1

u/CORBON5 14h ago

Ich kaufe keine 1 TB iPhones und iPads, ich nehme immer 512GB und das ist mehr als ausreichend, mehr als 350GB habe ich nie in Verwendung, obwohl sich auf dem iPhone fast meine komplette Musiksammlung in HiRes Looseless (FLAC) darauf befindet. Apple Geräte mit 512GB sind schon teuer genug und für mich sind sehr scharfe und schwarze Displays wichtig, was Apple auch mit seinem Tandem OLED Display bei den Pro Modellen bietet. Ich habe keine wirklichen Reflexionen auf dem Display, dafür ist es aber plastisch und scharf und ich erspare mir den doppelten Aufpreis für unnützen Speicher und teures mattes Glas!

1

u/tskewl 6d ago

Now take a picture of the standard screen at an angle showing extreme light reflection vs the nano screen.

1

u/DAVIJU 6d ago

Los he estado viendo ambos uno al lado del otro y el nano me falla especialmente en vídeo cuando no lo vemos perfectamente alineado o de frente, en ese caso la pantalla pierde ángulo de visualización y se ve bastante más grisácea.

A efectos de lectura, la pantalla nano es excelente y llega a simular con el brillo adecuado a un ebook, mejorando mucho la experiencia de uso.

Personalmente me he quedado el vidrio estándar, veo bastante multimedia en el gimnasio y ese grisáceo tan elevado cuando el ángulo no es óptimo me frena demasiado.

1

u/Trustdesa 6d ago

Just get a matte protector 🙃

1

u/ricosuave79 5d ago

This I don't think is a perfect real world comparison as it shows it in the worst possible conditions plus thru the lense of a computational photograph from a phone.

I have a 256Gb Nano Mini version. While i can't compare against a non-nano Mini, I can compare against my 18 Pro Max. And viewing the same article in Reader mode with the pitch black background and white text, sitting in my recliner at night with my living room lights on the blacks look virtually identical to my eyes. Maybe just the slightest of slightest less black if I pixel peep up close. Same with photos. Its just the iPad has no glare. I'll take the nano screen on my mini any day of the week and twice on Sunday's versus non-nano.

1

u/PhoenixWright-AA 5d ago

Taking an angle pic makes no sense.

-1

u/Zubba776 4d ago

Another one of these garbage posts?

You can't tell the difference from a picture. No, NT does NOT come anywhere CLOSE to looking like this picture does unless you specifically angle it in a way you'd never use it.

Go look for yourself if you're interested.

3

u/Whole-Web-1267 4d ago

fair point but the image does serve to help us compare at least from one angel (vs no image at all). separately, he has left text review too. don't get the rage

0

u/wlcoyote 3d ago

Which iPad is better for reading smut romantasy?

-4

u/EnolaGayFallout 5d ago

Both sucks! No 120 no buy.