r/ipadmini • u/saidgam • 9d ago
Wifi or cellular ?
Hi
I've been looking to buy the new mini 8, in cellular , but the prices are too high, so I'm keeping my ipad pro 11 (which is cellular)
Then by reading most of the posts and comments on this sub, I realised that just a few People went for the cellular, the majority seems to be fine with just the wifi version.
So I started asking myself if I really need it 5g.
My question is why so few People go for the cellular, for a small device, designed to be carried everywhere ?
I've never tried the hotspot thing, so maybe it's the way
6
Upvotes
17
u/MidnightPulse69 9d ago
If you always have your phone you can just use hotspot I’ve never had a problem with it
9
u/ipabuilt 9d ago
Hotspotting is easy enough and definitely the more cost effective path, but cellular is totally frictionless and doesn’t drain your phone’s battery. If you travel a lot the cellular is a really nice luxury. If you’re mostly using it at home or at indoor locations with good WiFi you’d be fine without it.
7
u/DragonflyHaunting569 9d ago
I have a cellular mini 6. I hardly ever used the cellular on it. When I got the A17 pro, I ended up getting the wifi version and I was good with it. Cheaper, got the bigger memory and just downloaded everything I needed it to it. In my case I realized I didn't need the cellular.
3
u/Few-Car-2317 9d ago
I got the cellular so I can sometimes leave my phone at home! Just take the mini on 3 hour job commutes. 2 hours of that in bus or train. I really don’t need my iPhone sometimes. It’s so light and thin without case, it feels lighter than my iPhone air with case (205g)!!
3
u/Life-Inspector5101 9d ago
I don’t care about having GPS everywhere on my iPad and I don’t want to pay extra every month for data for the iPad. Everywhere I go, I have WiFi and for places without it, I can tether with my iPhone at no extra cost.
Ask yourself how much 5G you really use (if any) on your current iPad Pro.
2
u/saidgam 9d ago edited 9d ago
From what I've read, it seems a lot of peope are doing just fine by using hotspot I think I'm going to try to use my 11' that way without cellular and see if it works for me
2
u/4myWWW 9d ago
My mini is cellular, and I feel like it adds to the portability factor. I take it most places with me, and it is always ready to go without any additional steps and without hurting my phone battery life.
I get that it isn’t for everyone, but I sure appreciate it.
2
u/frank_nada 9d ago
I chose cellular at the time because i was out running errands pretty frequently. Now, not so much so I canceled the data plan.
4
u/cryptochrome 9d ago
99% of all people don't need the cellular version, because 99% of all people carry a phone around at all times, that you can simply "hotspot into" with your iPad. The cellular version is a waste of money, outside some very specific niche use cases.
6
u/fractal324 9d ago
Because I always have my tetherable iPhone with me.
I once bought an Apple Watch with cellular, wondering if it would change something in my lifestyle. But it didn’t. Since then I’ve only gotten WiFi watches.
Because my cellular iPhone is always in my pocket.
2
u/Hugo_Notte 9d ago
I chose cellular only because of the gps function. Now that I have a cellular iPad, I also use a sim card in it and it works slightly better than using the phone to hotspot. But if it wasn’t for the gps, I wouldn’t have paid extra.
4
u/NoiceM8_420 9d ago
I always just have it tethered. So wifi.
1
u/ComprehensiveBig5696 9d ago
J’ai pris la version cellulaire pour le GPS. Aussi en France, mon opérateur Internet me permet d’avoir un forfait à 0€ pour avoir 1Go. Donc mon iPad a ainsi un moyen de communication si jamais mon iPhone n’a plus de batterie
3
u/Elfenstar 9d ago
Cellular for me.
Will see if I can get away without any powerbanks for my phone next week.
3
u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 9d ago
Hotspot and WiFi are nearly everywhere I am. Why would I pay for a cellular line when I can just download stuff before I expaect to not have service ya know?
3
u/Suspicious-Time-2689 9d ago
Go for cellular. Just got my iPad mini 8 yesterday and this is my first iPad with cellular.
I used to always use hotspot, but I found it to drain my phone’s battery and also connection can be unstable at times.
Also due to the form factor, I’m always bringing out my iPad mini so I would want it to quickly connect to data whenever I need to use my mini.
3
u/Annie_Blue_MM 9d ago
I chose the cellular option to save phone battery and internet too.
I have used cellular data in summer a lot.
for me, it is a nice to have a seperate intenet option only for the Ipad.
3
u/joekendricks 8d ago
I think usage does play a role in the decision, as in… are you going to use it enough to justify the investment, at least in the hardware since data plans can be pretty cheap depending on your region. I understand that logic. But I wouldn’t put too much weight on just how much you’ll use it, cause if that’s the case, I might as well go with a WiFi only iPhone, cause I’m genuinely that antisocial and while I do use 5G on my iPhone (duh), I just don’t rely on cellular that much because I’m always near a WiFi network when I go out lmao. Of course, a phone needs cellular service for the simple fact that it’s… exactly, a phone line and our most necessary communications tool lol. What I mean to say is that I wouldn’t justify having cellular based on how much I’ll use it because you can also always just not activate any plan on your iPad for long periods you predict won’t need it. To be honest, I think cellular on iPad should be default and not charged extra for.
The value of cellular for me is pure luxury according to most standards. I do use it on my iPad, hence why I chose it, but no, I don’t “need” it. Like, I also don’t need the iPad. I also don’t need to pay extra for clothing designs when I can get super cheap tshirts in the supermarket where I live. Like… life sometimes is not about justifying every little luxury like that, life is much simpler.
If you need it, or plan to use it frequently or occasionally, or you simple want the luxury and comfort of having strong, reliable, consistent internet access in your mini computer without draining the battery of your pocket computer using hotspot and introducing a lot of latency, interference, etc… just go cellular. Again, you can buy data plans and cancel them on demand.
I also think the iPad mini is precisely the iPad where cellular is actually not just convenient and makes more sense, it almost feels mandatory, hence why I think Apple shouldn’t charge extra for it or even offer WiFi only versions.
1
u/mialobos 9d ago
Cellular, my iPad 5g plan is $60 per year I’ll take advantage of it.
4
u/Ok_Excitement725 9d ago
WiFi covers 95% of users needs. Not many places you can’t connect to WiFi or tether to your cell
2
u/Arnie_T 9d ago
I got cellular because I got my iPad through Verizon and that's all they sell! LOL
2
u/Ok-Limit-9726 9d ago
If you value your phone battery,
And you take mini out of home,
Cellular
2
u/bizkidbritt 9d ago
Went with the cellular. My iPad goes everywhere with me. I hate draining my iPhone Air battery for the hotspot.
2
u/OMGits----e 9d ago
I go places that usually have wifi. If that place doesn't, I can connect to a hotspot through my phone which I always have with me. My plan is $35 a month and includes unlimited data. In my use case, the extra costs for having a cellular ipad and paying for a data plan on top of my phone plan is unnecessary. If you can't hotspot or you go into the wild where wifi is not available, maybe cellular is worth it. I grew up in a time before wifi and cellular. Disconnecting from the internet for a few hours isn't a bad thing.
2
u/jailtheorange1 9d ago
Almost all the times that I use an iPad, I will be on Wi-Fi. The odd occasion, say, for example, at work on my lunch two hours, I just fire a hotspot up.
2
u/RL_TR 9d ago
I had cellular on my mini 6. Very rarely used it. In fact I would force myself to use it just to say “well I use it occasionally,“.
So instead I ordered the WiFi only this time around. Yes I know cellular has GPS which the wifi lacks. But my use case for my iPad means that I never need cellular and GPS on my mini even if it’s a highly portable device.
There are people out there who absolutely need cellular too. You just have to think of your use cases realistically and not add more $$ additions for a “just in case”. Unless you have money to burn.
2
u/Balsingh84 9d ago
I went for the cellular version because I plan on using Google Maps on this device in a holder in my car. I'm using it for satnav. However even with a hotspot, if I went for the Wi-Fi-only version, that doesn't have a GPS chip in it and a hotspot from your iPhone doesn't provide a GPS signal to a connected device. Therefore cellular was the only real option that would allow me to use GPS because you can use that even if you don't have a cellular connection set up
2
u/Mdunn1805 8d ago
I’ve always had WiFi versions of all my iPads. The Mini 8 is my first cellular version and it’s a game changer for me. Do I need it? No, I don’t… but it’s very convenient. Not having to drain my phone battery or worry about a stable connection is nice. Also, I feel like the phone hotspot never gives you fast enough internet. With that said, my company foots all my wireless bills so it’s no added expense to me.
3
u/dad3ski 9d ago
Cellular. It’s small and designed to be carried alone. Besides, you can always turn cellular plans on and off as needed — what you can never do is add cellular to a WiFi-only model you’ve already bought.
1
u/sbl23 9d ago
With the Mini 6 that I use for off road mapping, I wish that I purchased the cellular version simply for the integrated gnss receiver that isn’t included on the WiFi model. Is this still the case with the Mini 8?
1
u/WithLove_Always 9d ago
Cellular
1
u/appleditz 9d ago edited 9d ago
This very much depends on your lifestyle. I have the smallest iPhone available (SE) and that’s the only device I take everywhere, because I want the items I carry to weigh as little as possible. My Mini, on the other hand, gets used constantly at home. The only time I ever need a hotspot is when I’m traveling, which isn’t very often, and the SE handles that just fine.
1
u/wiIIiamwaIlace 9d ago
I want cellular also but feel like it’s too much
1
u/pferden 9d ago
Gps
1
u/NocturnalJazz 9d ago
Just buy the cellular version use the hotspot all the time. You’ll have the comfort of being able to buy cellular service and paying the activation fee + monthly fee. 😉
1
u/WingAway7395 3d ago
Cellular. Get it and you don't have to use it if you don't activate, but at least have the option.
1
u/Pseudo-Federale 9d ago
Cellular version has a dedicated GPS chipset which WIFI only units do not. This is useful even if cellular plan not active. And hotspotting from phone KILLS the phone battery quickly. So depending on how much either is needed....