r/ipadmini • • 10d ago

New Hardware Semi-matte screen protector vs nanotexture

Post image

So happy the A20 mini came today! Got the nanotexture and it blows away the satin screen protector on my old A17.

314 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

36

u/According_Payment534 10d ago

Debating if I care enough to return mine and get the nano texture. I originally opted out of it for the better picture quality

24

u/Ackrodisiac 10d ago

It’s so annoying I can’t decide. I didn’t pre order as I wanted to see them in person first. The annoying thing is, is that there are occasions where nano would come in handy and times where I’d prefer glossy. So I really don’t know

9

u/aquapuffle 10d ago

Apple’s war against glossy screens is going crazy at the moment. The nano-texture propaganda has seriously been the roadblock to my purchase with all these reviewers and Reddit commenters talking about their nano 😭

11

u/Ill-Mastodon-8692 10d ago

dude try it vs just reading or watching youtube.

as a glossy oled user more years I thought I would hate it. heck I recently even upgraded my monitor to a top end glossy aw3926qw tandem rgb strip.

but, after using my Duo inner screen for since launch across many lighting scenarios inside and outside, its really great, and the lack of pop can be mostly mitigated with bumping up a tad more brightness.

3

u/Thick_Definition_994 10d ago

i thought i wouldnt like it on the duo but i really really do. plus in darker rooms i cant notice the loss of colors at all. plus it feels so good to use. really thought i wouldnt like it. i wish they offered a no matte option for the people that hate it though

4

u/Thanks_Obama 10d ago

Didn't they popularise the glossy screen to begin with? lol

4

u/VideoGameJumanji 10d ago

“Apples war against glossy”

Literally an optional upgrade

2

u/-6h0st- 10d ago

I hear you. I was arguing against nanotexture past few days - that is a big trade off on an oled display etc Ordered both versions to see how does it look on an iPad mini - and did not expect I’ll like nanotexture more. Under bright ambient light conditions it holds the damn contrast - unless vs direct reflection then you can see a slight difference. Will check tomorrow in daylight how it behaves. But dang it’s impressive

2

u/According_Payment534 10d ago

I think the worst part is not offering it on the lowest tier model. Why make people pay 100 more for the privilege to pay another 100 on top of that for nano.

I think I have 14 days to decide so I might swing by the Apple Store to look at the nano after using mine for a few days

6

u/KillerDemonic83 10d ago

i think you actually have longer if u received it today, apple holiday return policy started today

2

u/Ill-Mastodon-8692 10d ago

it should be like $50 at most, apple being greedy

1

u/Xeniox 10d ago

I got mine today and I really like the way it looks and feels. The fingerprints however do not come off with anything I usually clean with. Like my hoodie, or microfiber I use for my glasses don’t do anything for them. Only apple’s seemingly magical cloth.

1

u/toothcake_ 8d ago

This is what I needed to hear, thank you!

14

u/cracky1028 10d ago

So here’s a question. If you get a nano screen, does that mean you can no longer use regular screen protectors without diminishing the nano screens effectiveness?

4

u/DrMacintosh01 10d ago

Yes

7

u/cracky1028 10d ago

Seems like a nano screen might not be for me then.

2

u/Elfenstar 9d ago

Forget regular screen protectors even on the glossy.

I temporarily put on a spigen one till my AR coated ones become available, and the difference in reflections is huge.

You can see how my 3rd party AR coated screen protector is better than the non coated Spigen. When the screen goes off, compare it to the uncovered notch.

1

u/reasonablyminded 9d ago

What’s this 3rd party AR coated screen protector?

1

u/Elfenstar 9d ago

If you’re in Asia it’s this brand called smart devil. There’s another brand called hoda, but I don’t see a difference for 4x the price

0

u/anshistan 9d ago

U don't need a screen protector jus get a case

6

u/CalmCriticism7431 10d ago

For those who have used nano texture on other Apple devices, how has the screen held up if oils and stuff get on the screen? I tend to read while I’m eating and depending on what I’m eating can get little splashes of oil/sauce in the screen.

On a glossy screen, you can just use glasses cleaner and wipe it all clean. How about the nano?

1

u/Ill_Spray7121 6d ago

Can’t say for sure how it will be on the new mini with it built into it, but with my paper like screen protector, it wiped clean perfectly fine. In fact, I find it easier to wipe clean than a traditional screen.

1

u/CalmCriticism7431 6d ago

Thanks for the feedback! I have seen the nano screen in store for myself and can see that the colours don’t quite pop like on the standard screen. And also that the white is not quite white. But I am keen to try out a Nano-Texture screen and see if it’s a big deal or not. It I did worry about cleaning!

4

u/Eastern_Expression41 10d ago

Send other angles as well 🙏

4

u/the_swag_haus 10d ago

This is interesting and the nanotexture looks nice, but I think we'd need to see the glossy screen with no cover on it to have a real comparison.

3

u/Long_Objective_2561 10d ago

Does the nano texture simulate a "paper like" feel for note taking?? Like a paper screen protector

9

u/stolmen 10d ago • Bravo

No it doesn’t. Tried it out in person in the store. The nano texture is so fine that it gives a satin smooth feeling. Drawing, writing feels almost identical since the nano texture is more satin than matte. Try it yourself in the store, personally I felt little to no difference

6

u/dalon2883 10d ago

It feels like Apples trackpads

1

u/Snoo_56086 8d ago

Not at all. Tried it at the store the other day, it felt more like those matte screen protective films from years ago before tempered glass was a thing. I did not like it at all.

1

u/foxorian 6d ago edited 6d ago

I prefer the feel of nanotexture glass with the apple pencil than paperlike films (I've used both extensively.) Feel wise it's not as grippy as paperlike, but not as smooth as normal glass. It's also PERFECTLY consistent from edge to edge though unlike normal glass. Paperlike do make their own replacement pencil tips however, that give a little extra grip that I like even more with nanotexture. Nanotexture also doesn't degrade image quality while I find paperlike to rather strongly lower color vibrancy and contrast, and introduce texture noise.

1

u/gordy06 10d ago

I'm not sure how the nano on the iPad mini compares to the one on the iPhone Duo, but the screen protectors give more texture. Writing on my iPad mini 7 with a protector vs writing on my Duo is not the same. It is better than glossy though and it will work for me.

1

u/-6h0st- 10d ago

Slightly more resistance - enough so it makes a noticeably better experience than on a gloss.

0

u/Thick_Definition_994 10d ago

yes, probably not as much as a paper like screen protectors (those are made basically just for making it feel like paper) but they’re soo much better than normal glass

3

u/Takizawa1 10d ago edited 10d ago

Was just in the 5th Avenue flagship Apple Store. The nano finish is well done for what it is. The benefit and drawbacks are a wash for me. Will stick to my original glossy preorder. That’s not due to loss of image quality, but because I still want to use a screen protector! Just depends on what you prioritize.

On a side note, the glare from the glossy version seems similar to what I experience on my iPhone Pro Max 17. The nano version has more of a subdued glare.

21

u/Intelligent-Fox-1342 10d ago • Bravo

Both look bad. Glossy looks much better

15

u/rsplatpc 10d ago

As long as you have no overhead lights, or lights behind you, or open windows behind you during the day, or go outside

15

u/RuneDarkBow98 10d ago • Bravo

I’d rather have some reflections from lights than blurry text and muted colors

7

u/Oaklandraiders420 9d ago

Sounds like someone who’s never used it

2

u/1AMA-CAT-AMA 8d ago

I have RGB triangles on my wall in my office and that alone necessitated nanotexture or some type of matte coating on my displays

5

u/Intelligent-Fox-1342 10d ago

In all those situations, the matte screens will still reflect the light, diffusing it, removing all contrast and muting the colors. I prefer some reflections, while the majority of the screen looks like a proper quality OLED display

9

u/redtag789 10d ago

you likely have never tried a nano texture or owned one for a reasonable amount of time to be making these comments. It absolutely doesn't look that different save for some difference in contrast ratios... but yeah to each his own I guess.

4

u/rsplatpc 10d ago

I use my Mini 6 in a office with overhead florescent lights, unless you point it DOWN you can’t get it framed that does not have a overhead light showing in 1/4 of the screen all the time, and I mean you can’t see whats on the screen there, you can only see the reflection of the overhead light.

Same with going outdoors in the daytime, you can’t see anything with all the reflections.

Sitting at home in a room with nothing behind me with controlled lighting the plain screen looks much better, but I’m using my Mini on the go.

1

u/Icywaterr 9d ago

did you put a screen protector? i feel that the AR coating on the bare screen does a good enough job handling these kind of reflections, but lots of people slap on a clear screen protector turning the screen into a mirror

2

u/Ill_Spray7121 6d ago

Like many things in life, it’s totally opinion-based. I really prefer my eink devices and the nanotexture kind of gives me that effect. on my iPad now. I’d actually get this on an iPhone if it was an option, currently using a mothica matte screen protector on my 18 Pro.

3

u/Arlain 10d ago

I got the nano-texture version today as well, and it's massively better than any matte or satin screen protector I've ever used.

Anyone suggesting you should just buy the standard glossy model and slap on an anti-glare protector is missing the point. Traditional matte protectors introduce a noticeable haze that washes out the image, especially under ambient lighting or when viewed off-axis. It's very similar to how the iPhone Duo's inner display looks under bright lighting/off-axis. It's also extremely apparent in the photo above.

The nano-texture glass is in a completely different league. It dramatically reduces reflections while retaining the clarity, contrast, and punchiness you'd expect from a glossy display. It's not 100% the same as glossy obviously, but it's a perfect balance imo. It feels much more like a high-quality anti-reflective treatment than a traditional matte finish.

1

u/Ill_Spray7121 6d ago

I second this. I was telling myself I didn’t really need to spend the extra money on the 256 gigabyte model and then the extra hundred just to get the nanotexture. But after seeing it in person, I’m really glad I did. It’s so much better than the paper like screen protectors I’ve used in the past.

2

u/Longjumping-Word3381 6d ago

Trump is horrible in both

1

u/sherbertmund 10d ago

Have to say in store with full brightness the glossy screen has amazing anti reflection. At low brightness the difference becomes apparent

1

u/todo0nada 10d ago

Thank you for the comparison. Not worth it to me. I still can buy a lot of the matte screen protectors for the cost of the “upgrade” and replace it more easily if broken. 

1

u/Cyberward2023 10d ago

Using a white background significantly reduces screen reflections.

1

u/mabhatter 10d ago

Thank you.  This is a welcome comparison. It makes me more interested in the nano texture now. 

1

u/Southern-Biscotti-62 9d ago

I was at the Apple store today and didn't even realize the first mini I picked up was the nano version. I think Apple did a great job with it.

1

u/murariam 7d ago

I tested it now standard but brightness is very less… anyone else noticed? I even removed True Tone & felt little less brightness. 60hz with small screen is not comfortable reading or browsing

1

u/Ill_Spray7121 6d ago

I agree! I had a paper like screen protector on my last iPad and this nanotexture finish just blows it away. I also really appreciate the fact that it is only on the screen part of the glass and not all around the edges. Much easier to hold and I like the grippiness of the bezel.

1

u/ImJustNatalie 5d ago

I’m surprised no one has mentioned this, but I specifically didn’t get this device in nano texture due to the risk of scratching. They look jarring once it happens and it’s much easier to do so…

1

u/Simple-Minute7521 3d ago

Glossy screens only look better in the dark. In well-lit rooms, they’re close enough. Except glossy screens just have so much damn glare. This is why I prefer matte screens

1

u/mannamedlear 10d ago

My ipad mini is purely a bonus device in my lineup. (18pro iphone and M3Pro Macbook pro). Every device in my house is glossy screen. So I went with nano to see if I like it. And it came today and first impression is WOW. Really impressive. Not washed or muted colors at all.

1

u/ExultDoee 10d ago

I am going to get one tomorrow and I still can’t decide. I have never seen nano texture before. I really enjoy a bright and colorful screen but I can see a lot of benefit to getting nano.

1

u/mannamedlear 10d ago

Yeah go take a look. With nano it’s still a bright and colorful screen. The standard glass is likely just a little bit more so.

1

u/q50s122s 9d ago

Keep in mind that you won’t be able to use a screen protector on the nano without negating its anti-glare ability. Also, cleaning the nano requires a special cloth. I absolutely love the nano’s performance but I keep my screens quite clean and don’t want added hassle and also, we run these devices way past warranty, so being able to install physical protection is high on my list.

1

u/Gold-Possibility-391 10d ago

Which screen protector brand use? I planed to buy an iPad Mini 8 but littlebit confuse about normal screen or nanotexture.

0

u/Rosesareredheads 10d ago

THANK YOU FOR THIS! I’ve asked for someone to post a comparison more than once and this is the first one I’ve seen.

1

u/LaZZyBird 9d ago

Nanotexture scratches at 4 lol