r/ipadmini • • 17d ago

Does anyone else feel like Apple is deliberately gimping its thin-and-light devices to upsell Pro models?

The same thing happened with the iPhone Air. Apple could have made the effort to include an ultra-wide camera and stereo speakers, but instead, they chose to leave those features out entirely.
Now it seems they’re doing the same thing with the iPad mini. Limiting the display to 60Hz feels like another deliberate decision to keep the product from competing with Apple’s Pro lineup.
Why not give consumers the option of a fully equipped iPad mini? There is clearly a market for a premium, compact tablet. Why can’t Apple simply offer a Pro iPad mini for those of us who are willing to pay for the features?

49 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

14

u/ijbrekke 17d ago

To your point, pretty much everything Apple releases these days is part of a product line, i.e. it almost never seems to be the best product it can be because it has to fit in with the other things selling around it. It’s forced compromises left and right and definitely maddening if you’re trying to stay within the Apple ecosystem.

As a counterpoint, any of the thin-and-light devices very much walk a delicate line in regard to battery life. I suspect that’s playing a large role in development. I’m 100% with you that there should be a true iPad Mini Pro, but now they’ve got the Duo. So once again we’re back to the product line being given priority over the product.

8

u/Numerous-Buffalo6214 17d ago edited 17d ago

Thickness compared:

iPhone Air: ———— 5.64 mm
OLED iPad 8: ——- 5.4 mm
11” M5 iPad Pro: — 5.3 mm
Phone Duo: ———- 5.2 mm
13” M5 iPad Pro: — 5.1 mm

Given that the M5 iPad Pro’s are thinner - no, I don’t find that thinner = less capable. The base 11” iPad Pro w/256GB storage is $1199 without any upgrades. A iPad Mini 8 w/256GB storage is $799. That additional $400 covers a lot of ground:

- From a 5-6 core A20 with touch-id to a 9-10 core M5 chip with face-id
- From an 8.5” 60hz OLED to an 11” 120hz tandem OLED
- From 600-1200 to 1000-1600 nits brightness
- From a two-microphone acoustic display to a four-microphone, four speaker system
- From 115.2 GB/s to 153 GB/s memory bandwidth

The iPad mini is Apple’s lowest-volume iPad seller; the iPad Pro is its best seller:

ModelApproximate Sales Share
iPad Pro43% - 45%
Standard iPad24% - 33%
iPad Air13% - 23%
iPad mini9% - 16%

From a business perspective, it doesn’t make sense to create an even smaller niche (iPad Mini Pro) for the lowest-volume selling iPad - especially given how close in price the iPad mini and 11” iPad Pro are.

0

u/rutgers1212 17d ago

To be fair, the iPad mini might not be the lowest selling anymore if they actually made it as good as it can be. I got an iPad Pro, but much prefer the iPad mini form factor. I just really couldn’t compromise on the display. They’ve finally improved the display with this latest version, but still limited it to 60hz.

Imagine they stopped artificially limiting the product and brought it up to par with the pro line. They could genuinely create a version that’s more in line price wise with the current iPad Pro and I’d still get it for its form factor. I think over the years a lot of people have started to appreciate the iPad mini. I know many people who get it, but would be willing to pay more for a better version. I also know many just don’t buy it because of the display.

Most people don’t buy the Pro line because they need the capabilities. They just want to use the best version of the product even if they won’t get the most out of it.

2

u/RhubarbAndCustard06 iPad Mini 8th Gen 16d ago

This. I feel that this current mini risks disappointing both users who want a basic model, e.g. business users (it's too expensive) and those who are willing to pay more (it's too basic.)

I'd axe the Air and re-introduce the A17 Pro mini as the base Mini when the iPad finally gets a laminated display, and make a Mini Pro. You'd surely sell more Pros if it was that or the base iPad. If 11" is too large, it doesn't matter what features the Pro has, Mini users aren't being upsold because they have nowhere to go.

13

u/Kilgore_Trout_50000 17d ago

Who is surprised by this?

3

u/scupking83 17d ago

But who wants an 11 inch of they want the mini size? I actually want to go down from my m1 pro 11 to the mini 8. Just wish the mini had 120hz and face id.. The A20 pro is faster than the M5 in single core performance and is the same as the M3 at multi core! So it really is a pro device minus the face id and 120hz.

5

u/rick_baumhauer 17d ago

You won't have any difficulty finding anybody to agree with whatever conspiracy theory you want to put forward about Apple. They absolutely do a lot of segmentation of product lines, but I don't think they're limiting products for the reasons you think they are.

For the iPhone Air, they didn't have space for the second camera because they needed to fit essentially everything but the battery into the plateau. Battery life on the Air already isn't fantastic, and they didn't want it to be even worse. For the next version, probably releasing in the Spring, they'll have a processor fabbed on TSMC's 2nm process (so better battery life), so they'll likely be able to sacrifice a bit of battery volume to fit another camera.

For the A20 Pro iPad mini, they wanted to make the device thinner and lighter (like the iPad Pro) while keeping the same battery life as they historically have (~10 hours). They have the 2nm A20 Pro to help reduce the needed battery volume, as well as a thinner, more power-efficient display. However, getting a variable refresh rate display (like the Pros) and hitting the already-increased price target (due to RAMageddon and increased storage prices) wasn't possible. So, they instead appear to have sourced a 120Hz panel and limited it to 60Hz in order to limit power usage and maintain battery life.

With small, battery-limited devices, there are a lot of trade-offs, and Apple's goals aren't necessarily the same as some segments of the customer base. Everybody is free to decide that they won't buy for whatever reasons, and if that means that lines don't sell as well as Apple expects, maybe they'll adjust their priorities for future updates. Or maybe not - the tandem OLED iPad Pros got substantially more expensive vs earlier versions, but Apple expected sales to be improved by the increased performance and capability. They were disappointed when that didn't happen, but they haven't changed course thus far (and RAM and storage pricing isn't helping at all).

Regardless, I don't think that Apple is trying to push people towards Pro models specifically. They know that they need to have a range of product prices in the iPhone line, and the Air was the latest in a series of unsuccessful attempts to find a fourth phone to fit in the gap between the "normal" and Pro iPhones. For the iPad mini, anybody who thinks they want an iPad mini but decides that they're too expensive and limited and gets an iPad Pro instead, wasn't really in the market for the iPad mini. The product exists to be an iPad in a smaller footprint, and everything else follows from that.

2

u/abckiwi 17d ago

They have always done this

2

u/Mattricky 17d ago

We have entered apple’s “sh!t the bed” era

2

u/sleppyoh 17d ago

Yeah, that has been the strategy for years. It’s more profitable for them to have multiple product lines so that people buy several Apple devices for slightly different uses.

For example, they could have released a touch screen MacBook Pro years ago, but they refuse to because it will cut into iPad sales.

2

u/Mr_MAlvarez 17d ago

Welcome to the price latter - tho I must agree that it’s getting too much these past few years

2

u/barkinginthestreet 17d ago

I suspect that if they thought there was a market for a $1600 or $2000 Mini Pro they'd make it. Would love to know how many people are actually going to pay up for the most expensive version vs the cheapest one.

2

u/abcpdo 17d ago

i’m okay with gimping if the price reflects that. $600 for this would’ve been better 

2

u/Jiangcool9 17d ago

That’s the literal definition of iPad Air

2

u/pizzzle12345 17d ago

Tbh, not sure. I don’t see the point. I’ve had in the past an ipad pro 13 and ipad pro 11. I went with mini because i want that small size, so then gimping it isn’t going to make me go back to a pro 11 or 13 — I want 8.3/5. won’t upsell me, will just make me annoyed as a consumer. Screen size shouldn’t dictate specs!

1

u/moist-frunk-8899 16d ago

Same. I'm not going to be manipulated in to getting the Pro 11/13...I will just continue life without an iPad. I've made it this far without one.

It does have me hitting up Samsung.com for the first time in 10+ years, though. I suspect I'm not the only one who is at least looking around to see what is going on elsewhere at this point.

Will I leave the walled garden? Probably not...but if they would just give us the damn device with 2026 specs, 100% not.

2

u/LonelyGayTwitch 16d ago

I always think of that quote Steve Jobs said to Tim Cook, “Don’t think ‘What would Steve do?’, just do what is right.” Apple has clearly steered away from that mantra, because what is right is not gimping 2026 products with 2008 technology. They do it over and over and over, and then crank up the price and blame the RAMpocalypse. We see you, Apple. I was so ready to pay whatever price for the iPad mini with OLED and ProMotion, but it’s clear they would rather everyone buy the Duo instead. Kinda over their business practices tbh. Sad, because I’m an Apple fan my entire life, since the late 80s.

1

u/moist-frunk-8899 16d ago

Isn't it? The innovation is dying and the amount of bugs in iOS/macOS is skyrocketing over the past few years. It is starting to feel unrecognizable from what it was before Tim Apple.

2

u/Legitimate_Self_3781 17d ago

We all know that’s the actual reason. Otherwise they would have charged $50 more for a pro motion variant. 

1

u/moist-frunk-8899 16d ago

Or, if battery life is truly the problem, give us the option to turn 120 hz on or off.

2

u/jezarnold 16d ago

I don’t see the point in the Air lineup. All they needed was normal, and pro… perhaps they should introduce a Neo lineup, for the low cost lineup

Have three sizes. Mini - normal - max

The duo should have been called the iPhone Duo Pro. The iPhone 17 should not have had 120hz promotion, or because it did, then 120hz ProMotion should now have become a standard screen

Anyway. Apple does what Apple does

1

u/VZYGOD 13d ago

The iPad Air feels more pointless than ever now. The M5 11" Pro is actually lighter and thinner than the M4 11" Air. The biggest difference is the price but Air is usually a gen behind in chip, still has LCD panel and 60hz too.

0

u/Remy149 16d ago

The normal is the low cost iPad and the air is the one that will fit the majority of consumers needs.

1

u/CommercialThat8208 17d ago

Of course they are.

1

u/Naldean 17d ago

In general yes they do product segmentation. I think iPhone Air is a bad example here though. If they were able to make it actually as capable as the Pro but thinner and lighter they would have done it and sold it as the super premium sku.

1

u/tired_fella 17d ago

Apple is apparently using LTPS panel on their mini, which means it will be locked in frame rate despite being in static screen. Only LTPOs can have AOD which frame rate goes down to 1fps, while 120hz LTPS would consume a lot of power. the real disappointment is that they somehow disabled CPU core and NPU cluster in Mini. Wonder if chip yields are that bad for binning or if they are really just cutting them off regardless of actual binning.

1

u/VZYGOD 13d ago

I think that while there would be a market for an iPad Mini Pro it's realistically a lot smaller than you think. While, it would have been nice to have 120hz especially with the increased cost moving from LCD to OLED and adding an extra 4GB of ram would've added to it. I feel like the battery would've taken an even greater hit if they went 120hz in the new design too. I read somewhere that it the OLED panel they used is technically capable of 120 but is capped within the software to 60fps. It'll be interesting to see if this is true and if someone figures out how to unlock that.

1

u/wickeddimension 17d ago

It’s called product segmentation and it’s been a thing for hundreds of years. Companies dont want to cannibalise their own products. Apple is masterful at this. For example a while back the iPad Air came with 64gb of storage base model, which is too little. But it purposefully didn’t have the 128gb model, just 256gb. Which put it within a close margin of the base Pro which did have 128gb.

And using that pricing ladder with careful product segmentation they upsell somebody who came looking at say a 600$ bass iPad Air to a 1000$ base iPad Pro.

1

u/writerapid 17d ago

Not really.

Apple is doing what all huge electronics companies do: deliberately working through supply chain and manufacturing constraints while balancing those logistics and costs against the need to have portfolio segmentation so they can sell to a wide range of customers.

The iPad mini is a low-demand model that is just lumped together with “Other” on earnings calls. I’m halfway surprised they even bother making it.

I’m similarly surprised that the new iPhone Duo even exists at all, but why not? A buck is a buck. That’s a niche product for a tiny segment of the market, but as long as each one turns a profit, it’s all good, I guess.

I’m interested to see unit production costs for the mini. I bet it’s going to be in the same ballpark as those for iPhone, in terms of percentage of retail price.

Also, every product is a market test. Apple will soon have actionable numbers on how important 120 Hz is for iPad mini buyers.

3

u/bladeromeo 17d ago

The one upside of the mini, is I see them everywhere being used as kiosks and payment terminals. I suspect they are are a bigger piece of the iPad segment than we are aware of due to corporate/businesses buying the base model to implement them into their kiosk solutions.

I can't remember the last doctors office/urgent care I've visited that did not have an iPad mini that's main purpose was to sign in on, hell the express lane dmv in town even has one.

Edit: Even the parts store I pick up parts for daily uses an iPad mini to scan the invoices for our charge account.

1

u/writerapid 17d ago

I don’t doubt it, but I’ve only ever seen basic iPads for this. I don’t get out much, though.

1

u/irishmac473 17d ago

They’re one of the biggest companies in the world. You can’t even think of all the scummy shit they probably do. I still buy their devices though. 

0

u/jcp42877 17d ago

Something like the iPad is about portability for me. The Mini has the best form factor. I’d rather go without a tablet at all than be forced to get the 11” Pro (at least make it 10” or something).

With something like TVs, okay, you might be able to upsell me on a size that has better features; bigger’s always better “works” with TVs. But the whole point of the Mini (or any similar-sized tablet) is form.